What is the first way anatomy dies? Stop teaching it to medical students. Stop having them do their own dissections. The cost outweighs the benefits, they will say. And make no mistake, cost is the #1 factor for cutting anatomy out of some medical school cirricula. Instead it will be, look at some pictures (mostly Netter's--i.e. drawings!), we'll show you some prosections... The teachers of anatomy will pass, and nobody will have a good sense of the fine structure of the body.
Then who knows. Will our return to the pre-cadaver days of medicine come? We'll have a bunch of people teaching anatomy who have never even dissected a body themselves, not really wanting to touch it? Maybe only surgeons will know anatomy, but only the small amount of anatomy that relates to their own subspecialty... I don't think it will get this far, but I think it would be very sad if it did.
- What is the
TRUE value of doing your own dissections? It may be expensive, but what is worse is how inefficient it is.
As an MS1 doing dissections, for every 10 minutes I spent studying the anatomy of my cadaver, I spent 60 minutes digging out that anatomy from under layers of fat, fat, and...even more fat. It's a waste of time to dig through 3 pounds of semi-liquid adipose tissue just to get to something that, a few years ago, may have been a blood vessel but is now just a calcified hunk of tissue.
- I would RATHER have looked at prosections and Netter drawings. When it comes to surgical anatomy, cadaver anatomy is awful. Structures don't stay in place in the cadaver, so they're not really quite located where they are supposed to be. Furthermore, the people who generously donated their bodies also didn't take great care of themselves....so the lungs crumble into emphysematous bits when you pick them up, the heart is so hypertrophic as to be barely recognizable, etc.
- A lot of MS1s rave about how Gross Anatomy gave them such an "appreciation" for the body. My experience in the Gross Anatomy lab did no such thing. The cadaver's organs have kind of blended into each other, and just lie there - no movement, no grace, no synergy. Nothing.
My experience as an MS3 on surgery gave me a better understanding and appreciation of the human body than Gross Anatomy lab
ever could. I have truly come to appreciate the magnitude of the liver's task only after taking care of liver transplant patients. The course of the ureter when it comes from the kidney makes SENSE only after you trace it with a laparoscope, while the urologist slides stents up. The delicacy of the pancreatic and biliary organs don't really hit you until you see a surgeon working his way around them.
While I agree that anatomy is extremely important, I find myself really questioning the utility of the gross anatomy lab. It really takes 5 hours to dig out the muscles of one part of the body? Is this the best use of my time?