mksapboy

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Jul 20, 2006
7
0
Status
OK, so I was in an MD/Ph.D program, left teh ph.D side and my mentor went crazy and tried to get me expelled from teh MD part. Didn't work but it delayed me starting M3... Went to take my boards later than usual in November. Had technical probelms 3 times straight nov- dec. My dean allowed me to start IM my first rotation, but had to take the boards in Jan during my IM... and nealry 3 montsh after I prepared. I failed.
had to turn around and take it again about 4 weeks later as soon as I finished Im and pass with a 190. I got advanced in IM and a letter of rec from my attending. Have since done surgery and did fairly well...

Bottom line question will this sob story help clarify my poor step 1 performance, will they even care to hear it? or shoudl I probably rule out any of the higher competitive specialties. I realize I will want to take step 2 before applying. Luckily Neuro is one of my main choices and I think will be OK there if I'm not too choosey, but I'm also very interested in urology and possibly neurorad
 

Jocomama

Make 'em bleed!
10+ Year Member
May 7, 2006
292
1
Ann Arbor, MI and Chicago
Status
Attending Physician
I am reading your post, and am wondering if maybe you have dyslexia? Could that have affected your scores.
I am not trying to be sarcastic; there are several letter reversals in your post. A friend of mine had this, and was given extra time for his exam. He is now a Neurologist at Stanford.

mksapboy said:
OK, so I was in an MD/Ph.D program, left teh ph.D side and my mentor went crazy and tried to get me expelled from teh MD part. Didn't work but it delayed me starting M3... Went to take my boards later than usual in November. Had technical probelms 3 times straight nov- dec. My dean allowed me to start IM my first rotation, but had to take the boards in Jan during my IM... and nealry 3 montsh after I prepared. I failed.
had to turn around and take it again about 4 weeks later as soon as I finished Im and pass with a 190. I got advanced in IM and a letter of rec from my attending. Have since done surgery and did fairly well...

Bottom line question will this sob story help clarify my poor step 1 performance, will they even care to hear it? or shoudl I probably rule out any of the higher competitive specialties. I realize I will want to take step 2 before applying. Luckily Neuro is one of my main choices and I think will be OK there if I'm not too choosey, but I'm also very interested in urology and possibly neurorad
 
OP
mksapboy

mksapboy

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Jul 20, 2006
7
0
Status
Jocomama said:
I am reading your post, and am wondering if maybe you have dyslexia? Could that have affected your scores.
I am not trying to be sarcastic; there are several letter reversals in your post. A friend of mine had this, and was given extra time for his exam. He is now a Neurologist at Stanford.
LOL, no I am just a very fast hen and peck typer and I don't proofread unimportant things.... muscle memory, I always type "the" "...teh"

This post sorta made me day. thanks for the laugh. I would say though 6 years of neuroscience bench research makes me a bit out of practice of the no. 2 lead pencil fill in the bubble exams.
 

undecided3yr

Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Sep 14, 2005
130
0
Status
Fellow [Any Field]
Many people fail step 1 and get into many different fields of medicine.

As you said yourself, Neuro is a safe bet that you will still match. It is just that you may not get into UCSF, Mass Gen, Hopkins, etc.

Make it up with a good Step 2 score, which you will take early in your 4th year or late in 3rd year, in time for programs to see the improvment.
 

Pir8DeacDoc

Cerumen Extractor
15+ Year Member
Mar 27, 2004
1,588
311
Virginia
Visit site
Status
Attending Physician
I guess one could never say never but there are just too darn many competitive folks applying in fields like Urology for someone who has failed step I to match. I know it sucks but if you get your heart set on it then maybe you can impress someone during a prelim year and see what happens from there.
 
B

Blade28

You're considering neurology, urology and neuroradiology?

Seems like a wide range there.
 

JackBauERfan

CTU Field Agent
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Dec 24, 2002
963
2
40
Florida
www.myspace.com
Status
Attending Physician
Blade28 said:
You're considering neurology, urology and neuroradiology?

Seems like a wide range there.
I say go ahead and add in neurourology to even it out.
 
OP
mksapboy

mksapboy

Membership Revoked
Removed
10+ Year Member
Jul 20, 2006
7
0
Status
JackBauERfan said:
I say go ahead and add in neurourology to even it out.
Is that the study of pissing on someone's head?

anyways neurology and neurorad are very natural to someone who has done years of neuro and developmental neuro research. neuro icu is anoteh rpossibility.

Urology was fun as hell though and if I decided surgery was viable its the only surgery I think i would do. The life of a general surgeon is just to tough, although the rotation was awesome for a few months. ironically general surgery is probably a viable option for me to get into... we still have a family to start.