Here's my Gay PS, Whaddya think?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

TravellinDoc

So very very tired.
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Messages
171
Reaction score
0
So I thought I'd post a rough draft of my Personal Statement which "outs" me to the med school admissions committtees. Hopefully those who don't understand why my sexuality is relevant might understand in this context. Then again, you still may not understand, but either way, I would love to hear some comments, and those who want to post similar gay essays, I'd love to read them as well. Thanks all!
TD

I have never wanted to be a teacher, architect, or businessman and ever since I was five, I could not see myself doing anything else with my life other than medicine. Though at such a young age it was difficult to explain my reasons for it, as I grew up every subsequent experience with medicine thereafter simply confirmed this desire and helped to further my understanding of it. Some of the most influential experiences drawing me to medicine were ones I had during my many travels abroad. By being exposed to societies and people in developing worlds from Africa to Asia to South America who lacked access to basic health care and knowledge, I was able to sculpt my goal into one that had a more specific purpose. While working as a nurse's aid at an inner city hospital in Dakar, Senegal, I endured the patients' environment and their sicknesses including the ubiquitous and potentially devastating malaria. I also shared in their love of music, dance, their graciousness and importance of family. Thus, I gained a rare opportunity to reach a higher level of understanding of the people and the need for more doctors who were affordable, accessible, and who truly cared for them. I also developed a strong sense of the importance of continuity, perseverence, and a sense of humor in spite of my environment. As a volunteer at the free clinic for the homeless youth, I was exposed to the realities of young people living on the streets. Many were there at no fault of their own, including being banished from their homes for being gay. My perspective about the homeless changed greatly and I vowed to return one day to care for them as a doctor.
Finally, my most significant experience in medicine has been working as a Clinical Lab Technician at Swedish Family Medicine where I work in the inner city of Seattle with the poor, indigent, and immigrant populations. Such a diverse clientele was a joy to work with as I felt as though I was helping to provide care to a population that was in desperate need of it. It is here that I learned through my own experiences with the patients, in shadowing the director, Dr. Tuggy, in clinic and a few residents while on rotation in the main hospital about the finer points of being an excellent physician. The doctors and residents here have been amazing examples to me of people who have dedicated their lives to community medicine by providing high quality care in an underserved area. They have taught me that a key to practicing medicine is establishing a rapport with each patient by gaining their trust through a combination of professionalism, warmth, sincerity, following through on promises, listening, and a sense of humor. When performing phlebotomy, it is essential that I have the patients' confidence that I am capable of drawing their blood efficiently, causing the least amount of pain. Fortunately, I have been able to use my travel experiences and language skills to create an instant connection with the immigrant population, while integrating the aforementioned characteristics in establishing confidence with all others.
One of the most trying, yet amazing events in my life was one that I could never have planned or foreseen. The last two years since college forced me to face myself more than ever and come to terms with my lifelong struggle against my own sexuality. When I finally accepted myself as being gay enough to expect others to do the same, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others. I also gained a clearer sense of what being tolerant truly means. In acting as a part of the majority population my whole life, I was only sympathetic to the plight of the minority populations and I never truly understood or empathized with what they were and are forced to endure. Now that I am part of a very controversial minority, my tolerance, empathy, and compassion for these people have grown exponentially. I have felt and endured discrimination because I am simply being who I am and have witnessed its tremendous injustices.
To this end, the last few years have greatly influenced my intention to practice medicine in that I want to serve communities both internationally and domestically that have the greatest need for physicians; especially those who are impartial to the social situations of the patients, the low compensation provided by Medicaid and Medicare, and who truly care for their well-being both during and after their treatment. More importantly, I want to be a voice for the unheard and persecuted in the medical field. As a physician, I would provide a haven for those in communities which are heavily discriminated against for being poor, immigrants, minorities, or gay because I would deliver a high level of quality of care to all patients, blinding myself to my own personal feelings and prejudices. I want to be there so that they will have a provider who speaks their language, has an understanding of their culture, or is open to discussing any issues involving their alternative lifestyle. I only hope that by being an outspoken and upstanding physician, that I may break the stereotypes and create a bridge between those who are intolerant and those who are intolerated.
 
even your second line is a run on- it appears you are using commas instead of periods to separate thoughts
 
overall it is good. You just need to watch the run on sentences. Also, there are a few sentences in there that are awkward and could be phrased better. But you have a solid essay !!
 
Congratulations to you on such a brave PS. At first I wondered whether outing yourself in your PS was a good idea, considering the conservative establishment you are seeking entrance into, but then I thought "screw them, this guy is confident in who he is and that will make him a good doctor." The PS definitely needs some proof reading but I think the medical establishment will be lucky to have you.
 
I thought it was mediocre... even if you have great intentions, your style of writing makes the reader feel distant. I also wonder how hard it is to claim to care about minority cultures etc if you are part of this "marginalized" culture. And why didn't you care about them before?

You could be more specific.

"I finally accepted myself as being gay enough to expect others to do the same, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others. I also gained a clearer sense of what being tolerant truly means."

This thought is just bad. Now that you're out, everyone who is closeted should be out? I don't think thats what you mean.

I also hope that you have thought about other career options. Again, an adcom will not be impressed by someone w/ tunnel vision.

I can say a lot more, but generally people don't like criticism, even if constructive.
 
Is intolerated even a word?

I don't think you have a very good chance, I mean you volunteered but I don't see any initiative. You didn't actually set-up the clinics in south america. A true humanitarian would have set them up where there was none to begin with.

Does the Pope know you are gay?
 
The thing about this PS is that it is PERSONAL - Sure, there are a few wrinkles in it but the OP did a good job of showing who he is as an individual. Some readers would feel connected to the author after reading it. I mean, its tough as it is to write what you want in 5200characters, let alone connect with people.

There are too many PS's out there that read as if they are resumes written in paragraph form. I'm sure the adcoms thing its quite tirade to read those - this essay would be unique in those cases
 
I think your rough draft is a good start.

I know you are dealing with a character limit, but you might try including a few more detailed examples to give the reader a better feel for your experiences and how they have changed you. I think that would help address the reason another poster said that he felt the essay made the reader feel distant.

Good luck! :luck:
 
4 Ever said:
The thing about this PS is that it is PERSONAL - Sure, there are a few wrinkles in it but the OP did a good job of showing who he is as an individual. Some readers would feel connected to the author after reading it. I mean, its tough as it is to write what you want in 5200characters, let alone connect with people.

There are too many PS's out there that read as if they are resumes written in paragraph form. I'm sure the adcoms thing its quite tirade to read those - this essay would be unique in those cases

Thats just the thing. I don't think this stands out one bit. I've been reading a lot of people's PS's and it's a lot of "I think this" and "I gained an appreciation for". It's trite.

Being a warm fuzzy caring person is what we're all suppossed to be - and interested in medicine etc. It's HOW you say it. This is a personal statement that speaks in generalities far too often.
 
I think it's good. Of course it's a rough draft and will need some editing, but that's not the question. Since your sexuality has made a difference in your motivation to practice medicine, I think it's fine to include it - it helps show who you are.
 
It needs to show more, and tell less. For example, you have a lot of lines that read:

"I endured the patients? environment and their sicknesses..."
"Such a diverse clientele was a joy to work with..."
"It is here that I learned..."

You need to make this self-evident to the reader through vivid imagery, rather than simple explanation. I would suggest trying to avoid the passive tense as much as possible, as well.

Finally, you use the word "I" too many times in this essay (~35). I know for certain that this is a turn-off at the UW, though I'm not sure at other schools.

If you just improve your style some, you'd have a dynamic essay. You have so many interesting experiences to write about, but you need to convey them more powerfully.
 
i don't think you should write about being gay. it won't help you, it will only hurt you.

dig deeper, you will find other stuff to write about. i think talking about personal issues make people look immature and in want of attention. btw, i didn't read your essay or anything, i just think its a bad idea in general.

so is writing about being minority, being poor, being rich, being beautiful or ugly...etc. your audience will not be able to relate in general, so why risk alienating them? you can be as flaming as you want ONCE YOU GET IN. just do what you have to do till then.
 
Thanks for the criticism, guys, good or bad. I'm not looking for accolades, just opinions, reactions, suggestions. I know I tend to have long, run-on sentences and I'll work on that. As far as some of my wording, here's my interpretation:

When I finally accepted myself as being gay enough to expect others to do the same, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others.

here, I never said all gays should be "out." You read it wrong, I said, I accepted myself enough to expect others to accept me as well, not for other gays to be out too.

I also gained a clearer sense of what being tolerant truly means. In acting as a part of the majority population my whole life, I was only sympathetic to the plight of the minority populations and I never truly understood or empathized with what they were and are forced to endure.

Here, you'll notice that I am explaining how I was sympathetic to minorities EVEN BEFORE, but wasn't empathetic (meaning sympathy through experiencing the same thing) because how could I be?


Now that I am part of a very controversial minority, my tolerance, empathy, and compassion for these people have grown exponentially.

So anyways, to Peterock, I appreciate your criticism. If you have any other comments to add that are constructive, feel free to add them.
Thanks!
TD
 
TravellinDoc said:
...
When I finally accepted myself as being gay enough to expect others to do the same, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others.

here, I never said all gays should be "out." You read it wrong, I said, I accepted myself enough to expect others to accept me as well, not for other gays to be out too.

I also gained a clearer sense of what being tolerant truly means. In acting as a part of the majority population my whole life, I was only sympathetic to the plight of the minority populations and I never truly understood or empathized with what they were and are forced to endure.
...
TD

I think you might be able to reword these to make your meaning clearer. You could probably take out the difficult phrase in the first one:

"When I finally accepted myself as being gay, I gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others."

Or maybe something like

"When I finally accepted my sexuality enough to expect others to accept it as well, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others."

though that's still a little awkward.

For the second one, it does mean what you think, but it's awkward. Maybe

"I also gained a clearer sense of what being tolerant truly means. Since I had been part of the majority population my whole life, even though I was sympathetic to the plight of the minority populations, I never truly understood or empathized with what they were and are forced to endure. "
 
I was about to flame you for using the word gay in a derogatory manner until I read the essay.

I think it's good, and very courageous of you to include THIS topic as a PS, especially since Med ADCOMS are well known to hate "gays"
 
Fumoffu said:
I was about to flame you for using the word gay in a derogatory manner until I read the essay.

I think it's good, and very courageous of you to include THIS topic as a PS, especially since Med ADCOMS are well known to hate "gays"

Do you have any evidence of this "hate[red]"
 
Good solid rough draft I would say - I agree with the person who commented on the line about accepting that you were gay enough - at first I read "gay enough" as in not gay enough or too gay. I like how you describe the aspects you find to be most important in doctoring by referring to the amazing physicians you learned from. Sounds like you've had some really powerful experiences.
 
To the OP:

Props on tackling the PS this early (at least compared to what I did..) and thinking through it so much already. It's pretty clear you have some interesting experiences and thoughts, not to mention commitment and motivation. However, I think there are some things you can do to express them better.

Give your PS more impact (and make it more interesting) by

1) giving concrete examples with some details that make the experience more real to the reader. When I read about Dakar and malaria, I want a better physical, visual, or tangible sense of your experience there. This is interesting and relevant; give it more life with details - what is Dakar like? You can add just a few words to give some idea. The same is true of other experiences you describe. Give a vignette about the indigent population you saw served by Swedish Medicine. Include yourself some more - a self-descriptive detail here or a thought that went through your head can go a long way.

This also involves using shorter sentences and more vivid language. Avoid wording that is rambling, imprecise, or may come across as overblown. Turn some of your "I" oriented sentence around and make them active and descriptive - make the subjects of more of your sentence a patient, a place, a though, etc. Also, words like "vowed", "unheard", and "persecuted", although bold, strike me a little oddly--they don't seem warranted by the story that surrounds them, at least in how it is being conveyed right now. Can you truly "blind" yourself to inner prejudices and thoughts or be a "haven" and "voice" for the "unheard" and "persecuted"? We can always strive towards that end, but flatly saying you will be and do these things in such literary language may come across as immature or unrealistic.

2) Clarify your thoughts - this will help you create a narrative structure, which seems a bit jumbled at this point. The transitions from one part of your essay are hard to pick out or not really there - think about ordering as a tool - why start with one aspect of your experience and interest in medicine and not another? For that matter, why have you done all this health-related volunteering and work? You say you knew you wanted to be a doctor at 5 and couldn't really explain it then, but you can probably explain it now - interweave that into your story some.

Clarifying your thoughts will also let you use more paragraphs (since you will group thoughts/experiences/ideas and transition among them). This, along with reducing unnecessary words and phrases that don't advance your story or relate a compelling detail or fact, will help readers comprehend the purpose and flow of your essay and the thoughts within it. Phrases like "my tolerance, empathy, and compassion" and "importance of continuity, perseverence, and a sense of humor" are too overloaded and end up being glossed over by readers without saying much.

I think a little more of hashing things out can make it really shine.
 
The ideas are there, but the flow is not. I suggest using an online editing service. Your syntax, diction, and grammar are--how can I put this nicely--terrible. My grammar is also quite awful, and I highly recommend using a professional editor. However, it is a good start. You have plenty of time to perfect it.
 
Fumoffu said:
I was about to flame you for using the word gay in a derogatory manner until I read the essay.

I think it's good, and very courageous of you to include THIS topic as a PS, especially since Med ADCOMS are well known to hate "gays"


Dude, what are you talking about?
 
periodic said:
To the OP:
Give your PS more impact (and make it more interesting) by

1) giving concrete examples with some details that make the experience more real to the reader. When I read about Dakar and malaria, I want a better physical, visual, or tangible sense of your experience there. This is interesting and relevant; give it more life with details - what is Dakar like?

I think a little more of hashing things out can make it really shine.

I totally agree with this. Perhaps you could include a vignette of an experience you had with a patient, a specific case.
 
Some thoughts...

The first sentence should grab the reader. Yours is much too common... everyone has wanted to be a doctor since they were 5 yo. I would start with a descriptive moment of an experience in Bangladesh or in the clinic where you worked that really helped you decide medicine was your passion and why.

Right now the segway to your discussionto being gay is a bit disjointed. I see where you are going with it but it needs some fine tuning. One thing you need to be careful with is implying that physicians discriminate against minorities and gay people. I would stay away from making negative statements about other physicians (even if they are true) in your statement. It makes it sound like "the people in the medical profession are doing a terrible job and I know I can do better" - might not sit well with an AdCom member. Describe how you wish to be a part of medicine as it "evolves to meet the challenges" of providing care to the special needs of minority and underserved communities. Describe your desire to be part of a continuing effort without criticizing the profession. Save that for the "What is the biggest problem facing medicine today" secondary questions.


Overall I think you will be able to pull together a very good essay.

Best of luck!

Deirdre
 
First of all I just want to say thank you so much to all of you for taking the time to make some very helpful comments. I'm taking them all into account and it'll improve my essay a lot. Secondly, I know a big problem with it is a lack of flow because I basically spent a week writing several short paragraphs on different aspects that I wanted to include. Then this week I kind of pasted them all together and added a few transition phrases, etc. I guess I see where you all are coming from. I'll try to be more clear about the gay issue and less critical of the med profession. also Periodic's ideas on creating a narrative and making it more interesting were great. Thanks again!
TD
 
beanbean said:
Some thoughts...

The first sentence should grab the reader. Yours is much too common... everyone has wanted to be a doctor since they were 5 yo. I would start with a descriptive moment of an experience in Bangladesh or in the clinic where you worked that really helped you decide medicine was your passion and why.

Right now the segway to your discussionto being gay is a bit disjointed. I see where you are going with it but it needs some fine tuning. One thing you need to be careful with is implying that physicians discriminate against minorities and gay people. I would stay away from making negative statements about other physicians (even if they are true) in your statement. It makes it sound like "the people in the medical profession are doing a terrible job and I know I can do better" - might not sit well with an AdCom member. Describe how you wish to be a part of medicine as it "evolves to meet the challenges" of providing care to the special needs of minority and underserved communities. Describe your desire to be part of a continuing effort without criticizing the profession. Save that for the "What is the biggest problem facing medicine today" secondary questions.


Overall I think you will be able to pull together a very good essay.

Best of luck!

Deirdre

I agree.

Make the intro more exciting, make it more of a narrative, and make it more conservative... remember not to challenge the way things are too much, medicine is a conservative field.
 
Gutsy statement. Good luck.
Some comments:
Your essay deserves a better first sentence. Something more positive that will grab attention. As another person has said, we have all wanted to be doctors since we were 5.
Change "ones" to "those" towards the start of your essay.
Some awkward, impossible to understand sentences in there, but others have addressed them. When in doubt, make it SIMPLE. Short sentences, direct and to the point. Remember that the adcoms zip through these, so a single confusing, convoluted sentence could lose them. They won't take the time to figure out what you mean.
 
TravellinDoc, if you go with this essay, be prepared to discuss your sexuality in interviews. It's probably illegal for them to ask about it, but who's going to stop them? Just don't put anything in your PS that you don't feel comfortable discussing in person.
 
I think you might be able to reword these to make your meaning clearer. You could probably take out the difficult phrase in the first one:

"When I finally accepted myself as being gay, I gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others."

Or maybe something like

"When I finally accepted my sexuality enough to expect others to accept it as well, I had gained a great appreciation for the importance of maintaining my integrity, in being true to myself as well as to others."

I agree with lorelei. You should change that sentence. It sounds like you were saying you expected other people to accept that they were gay and come out about because you decided to do so. I'm not sure how you should re-word it, but it seems like everyone misunderstood you.
Good luck.
 
I don't think it's a good idea to put your sexuality in your personal statement. The risks are much higher than the possible gains. For the most part, interviewers are the older, more conservative faculty members. No good can come of making a bad impression BEFORE your interview.
 
Two bad sentences:

TravellinDoc said:
While working as a nurse?s aid at an inner city hospital in Dakar, Senegal, I endured the patients? environment and their sicknesses including the ubiquitous and potentially devastating malaria.

Makes it sound like you can't stand to be around sick people or a hospital environment..........

TravellinDoc said:
I only hope that by being an outspoken and upstanding physician, that I may break the stereotypes and create a bridge between those who are intolerant and those who are intolerated..

I'm not aware of any stereotypes about gays being unable to become physicians ............. Sounds like you are calling physicians intolerant and I don't think intolerated is a word

In my opinion you should leave the gay thing out.........It should be a non-issue in terms of acceptance to med school according to school policies and it's possible some on the committee will resent your bringing it up on your application.........You could just say your interested in working with AIDs patients or something..........and then you could talk about it in the interview if it comes up in the course of conversation and it seems like the interviewer would be receptive to it
 
who cares if you're gay? this is gay to include being gay in a PS. cowboy up and let them know why you'll be a good doctor. Why will you be good? Why should they take you? Don't give a laundry list of beautiful crap you've done. It lacks emotion, lacks power and I'd throw it away if I was an adcom. It is crap now that I read it again.

Paraphrase the whole thing: I am gay. I work with poor people and gay homeless people. I like them. Other people don't. I will give everythign i got for these people. Great. So what???????????????? What do you got that some other guy doesn't? Everyone says this ****. V ery few people do it. When you got debts to pay, you'll take a more interesting job that pays a hell of lot more. This is a noble deal, it shows you are not an dingus and care about people but it is the same **** these people here all the time. Show them who you are, not a laundry list of textbook gay ass **** people do that makes tehm feel like they are special. You got to do more than care about people to be a good doctor and get into med school. Everyone cares.
 
viking said:
RANT, RANT, RANT...You got to do more than care about people to be a good doctor and get into med school. Everyone cares.

I disagree. It's my firm belief that all you really have to do to get into school is make a good impression on your interviewer. And not have horrible grades, but if you're being interviewed you've made it past that stage.

To the OP:
On the subject of your PS. I agree completely with what has been said before about the opening segment, "I've wanted to be a doctor since I was _____ years old." is so cliche it kills the rest of the statement. Dump it, it made me want to stop reading your statement right from the getgo and that is exactly the opposite of what you want to do. I'll edit this later if I think of a better way to start it out.
 
I also agree that your sexuality is irrelevent and should not be part of your PS. Instead, focus on your experiences you mentioned. IMO, sexuality is a private issue. I will not be mentioning that I am heterosexual. Also, ADCOMs do tend to be conservative, and while many conservatives are indeed tolerant of homosexuals, I think they may see your mentioning it negativly. don't ask, don't tell. Mentioniong being gay does not do a thing to help, and it could hurt if you come across ADCOM members who are less tolerant or whi simply see it as something that should remain private. Just focus on what you have done rather than what being gay has done for you.
 
I think the personal statement has potential, but needs a lot of work. Break it down into sentences (make a copy where it is just bulleted sentences)--and ask yourself if every single sentence makes someone more likely to admit you to medical school. At least a third of yours could go.

A few specific points--don't promise to come back to help the poor gay youth. You may learn to love Ob-gyn in medical school--or urology. You don't know what you will do, and you should be open to new experiences. You can talk about wanting to do something.

Also, I didn't really get a sense of what your travelling medical experiences were and why they mattered--they just seemed sprinkled in for fun.

Finally, don't talk about the dedication of residents. Residents are forced to provide care for the poor--most of them are counting the days until they get out. If there is a specific resident that inspired you, then talk about him/her.
 
rgporter said:
I disagree. It's my firm belief that all you really have to do to get into school is make a good impression on your interviewer. And not have horrible grades, but if you're being interviewed you've made it past that stage.

This just isn't true. Some schools just interview lots of candidates even though they have a good idea of who they really want. I had a friend who was flat out told she would be accepted after a fantastic interview and she was flat out rejected.

Don't say things like this, it spreads false optimism. Perhaps for you rgporter and your big mcat score you just need to make a decent impression, but for most this is not the case.
 
beanbean said:
Some thoughts...

The first sentence should grab the reader. Yours is much too common... everyone has wanted to be a doctor since they were 5 yo. I would start with a descriptive moment of an experience in Bangladesh or in the clinic where you worked that really helped you decide medicine was your passion and why.

Right now the segway to your discussionto being gay is a bit disjointed. I see where you are going with it but it needs some fine tuning. One thing you need to be careful with is implying that physicians discriminate against minorities and gay people. I would stay away from making negative statements about other physicians (even if they are true) in your statement. It makes it sound like "the people in the medical profession are doing a terrible job and I know I can do better" - might not sit well with an AdCom member. Describe how you wish to be a part of medicine as it "evolves to meet the challenges" of providing care to the special needs of minority and underserved communities. Describe your desire to be part of a continuing effort without criticizing the profession. Save that for the "What is the biggest problem facing medicine today" secondary questions.


Overall I think you will be able to pull together a very good essay.

Best of luck!

Deirdre

Not me! I didn't decide to become a doctor til I was 20 or so...

About the essay...well...I agree with the person who said the whole "gay" approach isn't going to help you. Admissions might interpret this as using your "gayness" to try and get an edge...although, who knows; perhaps you could say they didn't let you in cuz you were gay...

And with Rosie on your side, no AdCom would have the balls to stand up against you...

But you know what they say, getting in medschool is a crap-chute 🙂
 
You really should work on switching to the active voice. Just about every sentence contains is, are, was, have been, etc.
 
Peterock said:
This just isn't true. Some schools just interview lots of candidates even though they have a good idea of who they really want. I had a friend who was flat out told she would be accepted after a fantastic interview and she was flat out rejected.

I was just analyzing the results from my interviews. Also sometimes the interview isn't as impressive as the interviewee thought it was. And it is very easy to read too much into a courtesy comment from one of your interviewers.

Peterock said:
Don't say things like this, it spreads false optimism. Perhaps for you rgporter and your big mcat score you just need to make a decent impression, but for most this is not the case.

I didn't do that well. I would classify my score as above average but not spectacular. Especially on SDN where it seems like every third person scored a 38+ on the MCAT.
Also I don't think optimism is ever a bad thing. I swear it's the only thing that will keep you going sometimes during the more difficult portions of the application process. Even false optimism is a good thing as long as it leads to determination and not disillusionment, when it shows itself for what it is.
 
rgporter said:
I was just analyzing the results from my interviews. Also sometimes the interview isn't as impressive as the interviewee thought it was. And it is very easy to read too much into a courtesy comment from one of your interviewers.
I totally agree and I can't help but think many premeds are not hte most humble people, so how could their interview not be super fantastically awesome? I make my response on my friend's experiences... friends who are grounded and generally hard on themselves. I know so many people w/ mundane interviews... or interviews where they don't even get to talk and they gain an acceptance.

I didn't do that well. I would classify my score as above average but not spectacular. Especially on SDN where it seems like every third person scored a 38+ on the MCAT.
Also I don't think optimism is ever a bad thing. I swear it's the only thing that will keep you going sometimes during the more difficult portions of the application process. Even false optimism is a good thing as long as it leads to determination and not disillusionment, when it shows itself for what it is.

People on SDN lie and are definitely not representative of the average med. population, particurarly people who post their MCAT scores. You know what %ile your MCAT score is.... as far the optimism goes. <BEGRUDGINGLY> Yeah, I sort of agree with that, on a good day anyway. But sometimes, it's better to be realistically optimistic. 😳
 
I think it is an honest, heartfelt statement, which in *principle* is what the adcoms are looking for in the PS, no matter what you speak about.

However, as earlier posters mentioned, you need to work on your flow and some of your syntax, verb tenses, etc. Include more detail about your abroad experiences.

Get some help with the details, and make sure your grammer is perfect in the final draft.

good luck!
 
BaseballFan said:
I think it is an honest, heartfelt statement, which in *principle* is what the adcoms are looking for in the PS, no matter what you speak about.

However, as earlier posters mentioned, you need to work on your flow and some of your syntax, verb tenses, etc. Include more detail about your abroad experiences.

Get some help with the details, and make sure your grammer is perfect in the final draft.

good luck!


Yeah, make sure the "grammer" is perfect :laugh:.
 
I think you have a lot of great ideas but you could work on trying to smooth them out more. Like another op said, instead of saying generalized statements give specific examples. Also, I don't think your intro is strong enough and it doesn't really relate to the rest of your PS. I don't think that saying you've wanted to go into medicine ever since you were 5 is really that important or relevant. I think it would be more powerful to talk about your volunteer experiences more personally (with a few specific stories) and tell how that has shaped your interest in medicine....
I do think you have a great start though and just need to iron out a few things. Like others said about mentioning you are gay, I don't know if it's the best idea. I don't think it could help you and unfortunately, it may hurt you.
 
Zahri said:
I think you have a lot of great ideas but you could work on trying to smooth them out more. Like another op said, instead of saying generalized statements give specific examples. Also, I don't think your intro is strong enough and it doesn't really relate to the rest of your PS. I don't think that saying you've wanted to go into medicine ever since you were 5 is really that important or relevant. I think it would be more powerful to talk about your volunteer experiences more personally (with a few specific stories) and tell how that has shaped your interest in medicine....
I do think you have a great start though and just need to iron out a few things. Like others said about mentioning you are gay, I don't know if it's the best idea. I don't think it could help you and unfortunately, it may hurt you.

I don't think it hurts, I was offered about 20 interviews and 4 acceptances. If its there for a good reason, it will not hurt.
 
Traveling Doc,
I enjoyed reading your personal statement. It's great for a very rought draft! I think that if you want to "out" yourself than so be it. Just be warned that most medical school committees are comprised of old, white conservative men who are probably sick to their stomach about Mass weddings. I say "more power to you and all homosexuals out there" Live and let live. Your essay comes off as a bit hesistant. I felt as if you were trying to distance yourself from your reader.

You need to show not tell which I am sure you have been told. Start the PS with a eye catcher...some experience described in detail. Also, you mention a lot of clinical work you have done. That is wonderful. But who cares? Pick one or two of those meaningful experiences and elaborate in detail. It will make the reader want to read the essay and engage the reader into your life experiences. You also start the essay by stating your travels. You come off as a privileged Brat! Have you ever sat down with someone that just finished backpacking Europe? That person just wanted to talk about his/her experiences. And you are just like "Okay, I am glad you had a great time...Now shut up" Do you understand what I mean? You should also not state " I wanted to do medicine since I was five" Does a five year old really understand the rigors of practicing medicine? It is childish and immature. Moreover, it has been done sooo many times.

Important: you need to organize your thoughts, elaborate 1 or 2 experiences, and create connections through imagery. I think the experience you had with the homeless teens who were casted aside by their parents because of being gay is awesome. Now, use that experience to your advantage. And focus on that. Say something like you worked with these teens that were in need of counseling....which YOU offered to them and in that they helped you understand your own sexual orientation. (Pointer: don't use the word gay, use homosexual or sexual orientation...don't be so blatant) Do you understand what I mean? Something like that carries significance and meaning and is very mature. You not only teach patient about illnesses, diseases, or self-awarness but rather you also learn from your patients. And in that learning you become a better person and that that is the kind of physician you want to be...one that listens and learns not just expounds complicated medical terms (a physican = eternal student). NOW, This is the stuff that great PS are made of.

Alright, I hope my comments helped you. Now, go write.
 
I don't know if someone else pointed this out, but * they * might be watching and reading right now. :scared: Is it such a good idea to paste your PS into a forum?
 
I agree with the above poster, take the PS down after a while...
It may be read by some you dont want seeing it.
 
Just want to let those who are worried know that I don't really care if Adcomms are reading this PS, cuz it's not gonna look anything like this by the time I write my next draft 😀, thanks, of course, to all of you. Later!
TD
 
SDN = paranoia amplified for no reason. Who cares if the ad comms see it anyway? Life is too short to live your life in fear.
 
It seems to me that a personal statement should just make the reader want to meet you.
 
Do you think being gay will help you get into med school? I sincerely
doubt it. People need to keep their private lives.......uh, what's the word,
oh yeah...private. I am personally tired of gays and other groups saying they are mistreated when, in reality, they use it for their own purposes when it benefits them. I think personal statements should be about your heart not your _______.
 
Top