CONGRATULATIONS on some incredible acceptances! What a great position to be in.
I had a similar decisions to make last year and I went with the big name, big city school. Shop around - see what they give you for financial aid. You pretty much know what you're going to get from UMASS already, and if you're interested in doing primary care in-state... I don't need to say any more. If you graduate with a degree from Columbia, you will be able to do whatever you want. As your advisor would say, "The sky is the limit."
The good news is that you're not trying to choose between traditional and pbl. Big difference - very tough call. I guess your decision comes down to whether or not you think your school will have the opportunities you want as a med student, whether or not it will set you up for the sort of life you want after graduation, location, and financial aid.
Don't know much about Pitt. NYU was a great place - location, Bellevue, lots of academic tracks and well organized student groups. I've said location twice now: what's really important about location is that it gives you access to the sort of lifestyle and patient populations that you are interested in. It's taken me a long time to get used to the big city after spending five years at a place called "Puffer's Pond."
One thing I love about the big city is that there is a huge variety of people and many opportunities to pursue whatever you are interested in academically and socially.
I have a friend at Columbia who loves it. I also work with an alumnus. Great school. Consider it carefully. I'm surprised you didn't apply to the rest of the NYC schools. Don't know much about Pitt. Obviously a great school. UMASS is a gem and the price is right. If you are not particularly interested in primary care, and unless you have a particular attachment to it, I would consider other schools. And that's my incredibly biased opinion.
----------------------------
Go UMASS!
msafain said:
Hey guys, Im an incoming first year and I need to decide which school to go to. Ive been accepted at a bunch of different schools including Columbia, Upitt, NYU, and Umass Med. If any of you could help me out be telling me how you chose your own school, and secondly if any of you go to the schools listed above could you give me what you think is best about that school. Thanks I would really appreciate it.