I'm writing up a review right now for my school's undergraduate science journal. For those of you who have been reviewers/ editors for your school's science journal: A. How hard is it to get published? (what general % of papers/ reviews are accepted?) B. What are the criteria used for reviewing? On what condition are papers usually accepted (i.e. what type of general edits are usually requested?) C. What constitutes a good/ bad paper? Any stories of personal experiences? I would really really appreciate any responses. I thought it'd be helpful for everyone who's thinking of submitting anywhere to have a general idea of what the review process is like. If anyone has insight, please share!