- Joined
- Feb 18, 2015
- Messages
- 47
- Reaction score
- 178
I think derm is sort of a special case. From what I gather, it's basically a necessity to "know someone" in order to match into derm nowadays. That said, even in the lofty world of derm, the brute force route is still possible, albeit quite improbable. In other words, there is a combination of stats achievable through pure effort/aptitude that essentially guarantees you a spot even if you did zero networking (i.e. no one is going to turn down a 270+ step 1, #1 class rank, and pubs regardless of their absence of networking)...of course, this limit is beyond the capacity of 99% of medical students, which brings us back to the original point that yes, knowing someone is basically a necessity for matching derm nowadays...
But for most specialties, I still stand by my point that you can score an excellent match with no networking if you're the type that simply prefers to go it alone.
Actually, this is false. It's true that there are step 1 scores at a certain level which will basically guarantee you interviews at top programs in competitive specialties. The scores get you in the door. What keeps you there is whether the programs like you/think you fit with them. These people want to know "am I going to want to murder this person after spending 100 hours/week with them?" "Is this person going to be a team player?" "What makes them different from the other 20+ applicants with 260+ Step 1 scores?" These are questions that are not answered by stats alone; personality plays a big role here.
Also, you seem to be forgetting that a lot of M3-M4 is subjective. Study all damn day if you want to, if your attending hates your presentations or you annoy the residents by trying to always show how smart you are or patients just don't like you, there goes your honors. Try getting to the top of the class without great attending evals. How much info you crammed into your head isn't going to matter.
As someone who hasn't even started medical school yet, you really should work on displaying some humility. Telling people who've been through it that you know better is exactly the kind of stuff that is going to get you ****ty evaluations.