- Joined
- Nov 16, 2005
- Messages
- 19
- Reaction score
- 0
I was wondering if it is easier to become a plastic surgeon or a dermatologist through D.O. school or caribbean school? and is caribbean school like ten times harder to become those specialties?
totoro723 said:I was wondering if it is easier to become a plastic surgeon or a dermatologist through D.O. school or caribbean school? and is caribbean school like ten times harder to become those specialties?
totoro723 said:I was wondering if it is easier to become a plastic surgeon or a dermatologist through D.O. school or caribbean school? and is caribbean school like ten times harder to become those specialties?
totoro723 said:I was wondering if it is easier to become a plastic surgeon or a dermatologist through D.O. school or caribbean school? and is caribbean school like ten times harder to become those specialties?
Dr. MAXY said:Plastic Surg or Derm via DO or USFMG? Good Luck. DO will be the best out of the two.
totoro723 said:I was wondering if it is easier to become a plastic surgeon or a dermatologist through D.O. school or caribbean school? and is caribbean school like ten times harder to become those specialties?
(nicedream) said:This is a pretty easy one - for plastics do Caribbean (but you'd have to DESTROY the USMLE), for derm do DO (there are a fair # of AOA derm spots, but only about 3 plastic spots/year).
UNLESS you want to do Facial Plastic (ENT) - then go DO because there are a bunch of those programs.
(nicedream) said:This is a pretty easy one - for plastics do Caribbean (but you'd have to DESTROY the USMLE), for derm do DO (there are a fair # of AOA derm spots, but only about 3 plastic spots/year).
UNLESS you want to do Facial Plastic (ENT) - then go DO because there are a bunch of those programs.
(nicedream) said:This is a pretty easy one - for plastics do Caribbean (but you'd have to DESTROY the USMLE), for derm do DO (there are a fair # of AOA derm spots, but only about 3 plastic spots/year).
UNLESS you want to do Facial Plastic (ENT) - then go DO because there are a bunch of those programs.
(nicedream) said:This is a pretty easy one - for plastics do Caribbean (but you'd have to DESTROY the USMLE), for derm do DO (there are a fair # of AOA derm spots, but only about 3 plastic spots/year).
UNLESS you want to do Facial Plastic (ENT) - then go DO because there are a bunch of those programs.
why the thumb down?OSUdoc08 said:
Rendar5 said:why the thumb down?
NRAI2001 said:Just wondering why do you think carribean grads have a better shot at plastics?
Is plastics harder to get than ortho?
OSUdoc08 said:Ortho is much easier to get into as a DO, because there are many AOA orthopedic residencies, and very few plastics.
However, most ACGME residencies would much rather take an American DO than a Caribbean MD, for obvious reasons.
NRAI2001 said:What are these obvious reasons?
Rendar5 said:and a lot of those people fail at those schools. I"m still not understanding why the thumbs down. was the guy lying when he implied that there are more plastics residency spots for FMGs than for DO's? I'm just confused cause he seemed to be backing up his opinion with some facts and i haven't seen anything counter to what he said.
Rendar5 said:so there are more than 3 plastics spots / year for DO? I konw that poster mentioned that ENT plastics was easier for DO and didn't seem to be including that in his stats (personally, i would assume that it's easier to do DO overall and that's the advice i also give out, but that poster seemed to be very specific in his advice. I hate assuming something that can be proven)
OSUdoc08 said:Anyone can be admitted to a caribbean school. They have no standards.
People are actually rejected from DO schools, believe it or not.
OSUdoc08 said:Since it is well known that relatively anyone can get into Caribbean schools, and that they have substandard education (since they do not have any US medical educational regulatory agency watching what they teach), it is no surprise that a majority of residencies would gladly choose a DO over a Caribbean grad with equivalent stats.
NRAI2001 said:I know that to be a licensed physician in the US you must do a residency in this country. So lets say you did a IM residency in the US and you still werent able to match into some fellowship (or residency in this case = derm), could you go train in this field in some other country for some time and then come back and practice it in the US? Since you were a licensed IM physician you can legally practice in the US, but could u practice lets say cardio or derm? I know that any physician can perform any procedure they are comfortable with (obviously a FP will not be comfortable practicing CT or neurosurgery).
Same with plastics. Lets say you did general surgery here for 5 years, didnt get a plstics fellowship. Could you go to mexico, south america, europe...etc do plastics fellowship there and then return to US to practice?
(nicedream) said:You would not be board certified in those fields. That may introduce billing complications as well as turn off patients.
(nicedream) said:My post regarding plastic surgery, derm, and facial plastic/ENT was absolutely correct. As someone suggested, it is based on statistics and not hearsay.
As for plastic surgery, yes, it is preferable to go caribbean. Along with radiation oncology, this is is one of the fields that is essentially closed to DOs. Of the 576 current ACGME slots, 1 is filled by a DO while 38 are filled with FMGs. If you want to count on being that 0.2%, go ahead - you're a fool. There are only 3 AOA slots per year - that's what you'd be banking on. It could not be clearer.
.
NRAI2001 said:Would it be illegal though? Lets say you are board certified in IM, but do cardio in a foreign country, could u practice cardio here then? I know that you may have difficulty getting a job or joining another practice, but what if you started your own private practice?
NRAI2001 said:Are those 38 spots that were filled intergrated spots or fellowships post residency? Were those 38 students true IMGs or US kids from off shore schools?
NRAI2001 said:Why would this equate to such an obvious factor? Everyone knows that both carribean and DO schools are peoples 2nd choices. I would think that your performance in med school would matter more.
PS: I would rather go to a DO school (applying to them right now)(not applying to carrib. schools), but I am not one to bash carribean schools, and ignore the draw backs of DO schools. Both schools train good physicians and the top carribean schools provide good clinical years.
stookie said:Is there a huge difference between allopathic and osteopathic residencies?
OSUdoc08 said:This is a very ignorant statement, but it's not surprising that you made such a comment, based on your previous posts.
DO was a first choice for many at my school.
OSUdoc08 said:This is a very ignorant statement, but it's not surprising that you made such a comment, based on your previous posts.
DO was a first choice for many at my school.
NRAI2001 said:Yea, your not the most unbiased person either.
(nicedream) said:Still not good to make generalizations man. There are many reasons people sometimes choose DO schools over MD ones.
OSUdoc08 said:Be careful with making blanket statements.
Statements that discuss the average or majority are much different than those that use all or none.
When you speak of plastics spots, are you referring to integrated plastics residencies or plastics fellowship. If someone wanted to go the DO route, couldn't they just do Gen Surg residency followed by plastics fellowship??? From what I understand, this was the route for a long time anyway and integrated plastics residencies are somewhat new.(nicedream) said:My post regarding plastic surgery, derm, and facial plastic/ENT was absolutely correct. As someone suggested, it is based on statistics and not hearsay.
As I said in my other post, the moderate # of AOA derm and facial/ENT slots which are available to DOs (about 20/year) makes going the osteopathic route much preferrable to caribbean, as the caribbeans will be competing against top US MDs. As a DO applying to AOA spots, you are on equal footing with all applicants.
As for plastic surgery, yes, it is preferable to go caribbean. Along with radiation oncology, this is is one of the fields that is essentially closed to DOs. Of the 576 current ACGME slots, 1 is filled by a DO while 38 are filled with FMGs. If you want to count on being that 0.2%, go ahead - you're a fool. There are only 3 AOA slots per year - that's what you'd be banking on. It could not be clearer.
Someone asked what Facial Plastic/ENT is. ENT (Ear Nose Throat) is otolaryngology, and the training is also called Facial Plastic Surgery. It is essentialy Head/Neck Surgery. You can focus your practice on the ENT part (sinusitis etc) or facial plastic surgery. Residency programs also have different focus' on each.
PlasticMan said:When you speak of plastics spots, are you referring to integrated plastics residencies or plastics fellowship. If someone wanted to go the DO route, couldn't they just do Gen Surg residency followed by plastics fellowship??? From what I understand, this was the route for a long time anyway and integrated plastics residencies are somewhat new.
Rendar5 said:and a lot of those people fail at those schools. I"m still not understanding why the thumbs down. was the guy lying when he implied that there are more plastics residency spots for FMGs than for DO's? I'm just confused cause he seemed to be backing up his opinion with some facts and i haven't seen anything counter to what he said.
PlasticMan said:When you speak of plastics spots, are you referring to integrated plastics residencies or plastics fellowship. If someone wanted to go the DO route, couldn't they just do Gen Surg residency followed by plastics fellowship??? From what I understand, this was the route for a long time anyway and integrated plastics residencies are somewhat new.
How was I speaking of FMG and USFMG? LOL.Dr. MAXY said:I can't believe all you guys keep confusing FMG and USFMG. The former are graduates from foreign countries like England, India, China, etc. Some of these FMGs have completed residencies, and were top in the fields in their various countries. Some of them were even candidates for noble prize, others were program directors. Hence programs love these guys and they have a greater chance of getting into competitive fields. When I was at Hopkins on rotation, I saw a bunch of these guys. One guy was among China's best physicians.
However, USFMG, are US applicants who couldn't get into US schools and then traveled out of the country to attend med school (usually Caribbean). Hence these ones have decreased chances of getting into US residencies.
Come on guys get you facts straight. FMG is NOT THE SAME AS USFMG ( Caribbean grad)
Shinken said:I have a book about choosing medical specialties (published last year, 2004) and it has NRMP data on it.
For dermatology, it states that foreign-trained physicians and osteopathic physicians both had the same rate of successful applicants (3%).
For plastic surgery, it states that both groups also (!) had the same success rate (1.3%).
If the book's data is accurate, there's really no difference. Also, Dr. Maxy has a good point. There are foreign medical graduates and then there are foreign medical graduates.
PlasticMan said:When you speak of plastics spots, are you referring to integrated plastics residencies or plastics fellowship. If someone wanted to go the DO route, couldn't they just do Gen Surg residency followed by plastics fellowship??? From what I understand, this was the route for a long time anyway and integrated plastics residencies are somewhat new.