•You do the math. First of all, what person with an MBA can start at age 23 to 24? Most business schools want their students to have 4 to 5 years of business experience before applying. Secondly, a doctor is going to be making WELL over 100,000 dollars a year and will therefore be able to put the max (roughly $11,000) into a 403(b) each year which means more tax-deferred dollars (the most important) than someone who makes a lesser salary. The doc will also be able to contribute the max each year to an IRA, also tax-deferred, whereas someone with a lesser salary can't make the same promise.•
I'm not going to argue with you on this because you clearly know more about it than I. However, I do have a problem with some of your other points.
•Don't kid yourself. MBA's aren't going to beat docs on average. Lawyers aren't going to beat docs on average.•
This is COMPLETELY determined by how hard you want to work. Want to just sort of screw around? Become a public defender. Sure, you won't be making as much as a doc, but you won't be sacrificing much either. This all comes back to my initial point - docs sacrifice a LOT. What lawyer or PhD has to work on Christmas? At night? On birthdays? I won't go into the point about superfluous lawsuits again, because I think my point is well made.
•Maybe docs don't like it when it's pointed out that they really didn't make that great a sacrifice.•
I don't get it - are you even applying to or in medical school? I find it almost shameful that you would go into this career without understanding the sacrifices you are or will be making. There are few careers where one has to sacrifice as much. Trial lawyers, who may have someone's freedom (or life) in their hands, are as well paid as docs. National politicians, who are responsible for the well being of the society, often make upwards of $200K. What links all of these careers is that they sacrifice a great deal to do what they do. When you are in surgery 12 hours on your kid's birthday trying to save someone and they don't make, and THEN you get hit with a mutlimillion dollar lawsuit because you weren't "good enough" (even though you did more than most docs might have been able to do), come back and tell me how little doctors sacrifice.
•Medicine is the surest road to wealth in the United States and smart people know this.•
Yes, but not by any means the easiest.