Ok,
Guys relax. Let me address the points sequentially:
1) These states don't have caps, because this is the first time they are facing any of these issues. California made caps as soon as the issue arose. If you don't it doesn't become feasible for anyone to practice (though the increase in the cost of living, and the emergence of managed care were two things they didn't consider).
2) Insurace companies don't want doctors to leave. They make their money in widespread premium. They recognize that by jacking up the premium they reduce the number of physicians who can pay (by attrition). They will lobby just as badly as anyone else to put caps.
3) The majority of states not the minority provide malpractice caps. There are certain states that haven't because the monetary payouts had never been that high, until now.
4) DOCTORS...MAKING A HUNDRED THOUSAND. Dude, if you honestly believe that...you need to get out now. Don't even look back...just get out. Do anything else...if you are making a 100,000 and malpractice is 50,000...then you are equivalently a school teacher. Teaching people is as rewarding as saving their lives, with far less stress. I would be a school teacher, and at least give yourself an extra ten years of income. Look at it this way...if you make 50,000 net...and you have 90,000 in loans...NO ONE WILL GO INTO THAT FIELD....PERIOD. There will be such a shortage, they'll be giving scalpels to orphans to start cutting.
5) Despite managed care, the average salary for a medical resident in the US is 36,000. In 1980 that number was 18,000. The adjustments are for cost of living. My belief is that not only will physicians maintain their current standard of living (which by pure economic forces will happen), it might actually increase. Unionization is one option, the other is direct contracting with employers. There are many group practices that provide that service (they basically obviate the middle man, and go right to the employers and give the employees direct, uninterrupted care). The reality is the future will just be more empowered individual choices. More of the cost of health care will fall on individuals, and when that happens they will definately be more careful about cost and savings, etc. Insurance companies are already starting to offer market force plans. Trust me, getting directly reimbursed for services is far better, than hoping you get something back when you file an insurance claim.
6) Doctors will always make good money, but we won't be aggregiously wealthy (unless we diversify into real estate or medical devices or bio tech, etc.). That was the past, so if you are expecting the future to be the same you are sorely mistaken. Internists won't make millions of dollars a year. But, you will have a good life, make a very good salary, have a relatively stable job, and in some cases, have a very entrepreneurial practice. And you have a disposable income to invest with...EVEN IN SOCIALIZED COUNTRIES, DOCTORS DON'T MAKE A 100,000 A YEAR (or the equivalent there of in their currency, and if they do...they don't have school loans or malpractice because the government covers and caps respectively).
Listen, I love this board. I think it's a great place to post concerns and questions...AND IN THE END YOU SHOULD BE A DOCTOR BECAUSE YOU LOVE IT. I know that sounds like rhetoric, but it's true. Unfortunately...IT IS HARD...REALLY HARD...to find justification to do anything IF THE SALARY LEVEL SHRINKS THAT MUCH AND YOUR DEBT LEVEL IS THAT HIGH. If that happens, it will become a fast cycle of departure for most physicians. They will not apply, and also leave in droves.
In closing, do I wish in the end that I hadn't become a physician? If I didn't like it...I suppose I would. I percieve that I would just state hatred for it all and never come back...but that isn't reality. I like medicine, I like what I do. I don't think in twenty years I'll be making 100,000 dollars (considering that the average american income will be fifty thousand...I highly doubt I will). I believe the system of medicine will be very different. I believe money will still pour into healthcare, because it is a universal problem. I don't think we will become as wealthy as our predecessors...but I also don't believe we'll be hurting. In the end, I think it's the best job you can have...outside of being an entrepreneur. If you believe medicine is dead or a dying field, get out... by the sheer fact that you have gotten this far, you are smart enough to do and be something else. It is naive to believe even if you love something, that you wouldn't want to be remediated somehow for it. Make the right decisions, and find another career. I just believe that in the end, I will do something I genuinely enjoy doing, get paid well to do it, and have the opportunity to do a lot of interesting things on the side.