This whole thing about the PharmD is a doctorate is really fascinating to me. To me, a doctorate degree means that a degree awarded to a person who went and successfully obtained / finished an educational program that stressed / included research and thesis defense as the requirements for the degree. This would be certainly at a higher level than just taking / learning new facts and regurgitating them.
To that, I think a PhD is qualified as a doctorate. An MD is also qualified as MD programs require some sorts of research and thesis defense for the MD degree.
A PharmD in the old day (of the 80's and 90's) would be qualified as a doctorate as it did require research and thesis defense (
Doctor of Pharmacy (PharmD) · USC School of Pharmacy). The current PharmD curriculum and requirements for the degrees, from what I see, do not include any research or thesis defense as the degree's requirement. Most is like the BS Pharm degree of the old time but stretches out to 4 years by adding / taking some more classes and doing more presentations. IMHO it is more like a non-thesis Master degree than a doctorate.
The reason, I think, we see PharmD is the degree mandated for pharmacy practice is probably the result from people's desire for becoming a "doctor" and working as a "doctor" without going to medical schools (note that it is hard to get in med school and it takes a long time to become a MD) and school's greed and also some fantasies that dreamed up by some at top of the pharmacy's leadership (echoed and supported by pharm schools). The whole thing is really an artificial inflation of the required Pharmacy degree for practicing as a pharmacist.
In fact, one question I keep asking myself is that, if there is anything that, as a practicing pharmacist, that a BS Pharm cannot do vs a PharmD degree produced from the current PharmD curriculum?
Per my observation, this inflation has also happened to many other professions, e.g. dentistry, optometry, nursing, physician therapy, etc. I think, this benefits no one except schools as students have to spend more and more tuition and time in school.
Yes, if you earned a doctorate, you should be proud and earned the right to be called a doctor BUT in appropriate conditions / places. For the most part, society mostly identifies and associates the word "doctor" with one being a medical doctor. So I think, we should let the other person decides if they want to call you a doctor or not, and not demand to be called as one. For example, even a real PhD or MD, from what I see out there, does not walk around and demand people to call them a "doctor" and get upset if people fail to comply.
Again, the current PharmD degree, to me, is not really a doctorate since it lacks research and thesis defense requirements for the degree. A "fake" doctor degree, if you will, which happens as the result of school's greed and people's vanity. I guess this is probably the opinions of many too because I see many pharmacists would avoid calling themselves "doctor". Because they do know what currently is required for the degree.
Dang, I have just realized I am writing a novel here! So sorry
TLDR ::: even if you are a doctorate, please do not demand people to call you "doctor". The current PharmD that is required for the current practice of pharmacy is not a real doctorate imho.