- Joined
- Apr 24, 2014
- Messages
- 6
- Reaction score
- 2
I’m an M4 in need of some advice about choosing a different specialty this late in the game (2 months before ERAS due :O). I don’t have a lot of great resources to go to at my school currently as I’d like to not damage my reputation with the department of the specialty I was planning to apply to. Here’s the scenario:
I worked as an ER scribe before med school which is where I first caught the EM bug. I love the variety and pace of EM – I can’t stand downtime while I’m at work. I love seeing a bunch of patients with different pathologies and hearing their crazy stories about how they ended up there, doing a few procedures here and there, and then going home and truly being done with responsibilities for the day (other than notes of course).
I just finished my home school sub-I in EM and am now having a lot of second thoughts. Nearly every resident or attending’s criticism for me was that I was doing a good job thinking through patients/DDx but was spending way too long trying to understand each patient’s case. The “just stabilize and disposition the patient” mentality really got to me after a while. A part of me does care what the actual diagnosis is, not just ruling out the life-threatening ones. It began to feel like every workup for each general ED chief complaint was the same without as much academic rigor as I would’ve liked. I like spending time educating patients, and I care what happens to them when they go upstairs or go home. I also started to find it exhausting to be meeting every single patient for the first time. Finally, I greatly underestimated the toll the shift work would take on my physical/mental wellbeing. Ultimately, I’m becoming highly concerned that I just don’t “fit” with the EM mentality.
I’m now having last-minute thoughts about jumping ship to family medicine as it seems to be a good balance of the pros and cons of EM for me. Breadth of medicine, some undifferentiated patients without it being every single encounter, opportunities for more focused patient education, continuity of care, and some flexibility in terms of shaping a practice to do a little more and less of what you like and don’t like as your interests evolve further in your career. I like seeing a little bit of MSK, peds, and OB and would primarily like to work in an outpatient setting if I were to do FM, which to me makes FM a better choice for me than IM. I’ve considered EM/FM programs, but everyone seems to state that it is very difficult to truly practice both (in terms of both working in a level 1 trauma center and having an outpatient clinic) and just adds extra years of training. I know FM docs can do EM at rural centers, but this is not really something I’m interested in.
The problem now is that it’s almost July of my M4 year, and my entire application has been prepped for EM. I’ve got 2 EM away rotations scheduled at “good” programs, and had been planning on getting SLOEs for EM and not really having to worry about individual physicians writing LORs. In order to apply to EM, I need one more SLOE at least. I have this slight hope that maybe just doing EM somewhere else will help me “fall back in love” so to speak, and then I would ensure I have the 2 SLOEs I need and the rest of this mess would go away. However, another part of me says I’m already 75% convinced against EM, so am I just wasting time verifying what I already know, and do I need to just get back to my home school and do a sub-I in FM earlier? I currently only have 1 potential FM LOR writer and would like to have a second plus one letter from an EM provider if I apply FM.
Thanks for reading this incredibly long post. I know the internet can’t tell me what to do, but I really value hearing others opinions - Maybe someone who was in a similar situation or can offer a different perspective. I never expected to be this conflicted this late in the game. It probably doesn’t matter for this scenario, but for what it’s worth: Step 1: 26X, honors on M3 rotations (not trolling here).
I worked as an ER scribe before med school which is where I first caught the EM bug. I love the variety and pace of EM – I can’t stand downtime while I’m at work. I love seeing a bunch of patients with different pathologies and hearing their crazy stories about how they ended up there, doing a few procedures here and there, and then going home and truly being done with responsibilities for the day (other than notes of course).
I just finished my home school sub-I in EM and am now having a lot of second thoughts. Nearly every resident or attending’s criticism for me was that I was doing a good job thinking through patients/DDx but was spending way too long trying to understand each patient’s case. The “just stabilize and disposition the patient” mentality really got to me after a while. A part of me does care what the actual diagnosis is, not just ruling out the life-threatening ones. It began to feel like every workup for each general ED chief complaint was the same without as much academic rigor as I would’ve liked. I like spending time educating patients, and I care what happens to them when they go upstairs or go home. I also started to find it exhausting to be meeting every single patient for the first time. Finally, I greatly underestimated the toll the shift work would take on my physical/mental wellbeing. Ultimately, I’m becoming highly concerned that I just don’t “fit” with the EM mentality.
I’m now having last-minute thoughts about jumping ship to family medicine as it seems to be a good balance of the pros and cons of EM for me. Breadth of medicine, some undifferentiated patients without it being every single encounter, opportunities for more focused patient education, continuity of care, and some flexibility in terms of shaping a practice to do a little more and less of what you like and don’t like as your interests evolve further in your career. I like seeing a little bit of MSK, peds, and OB and would primarily like to work in an outpatient setting if I were to do FM, which to me makes FM a better choice for me than IM. I’ve considered EM/FM programs, but everyone seems to state that it is very difficult to truly practice both (in terms of both working in a level 1 trauma center and having an outpatient clinic) and just adds extra years of training. I know FM docs can do EM at rural centers, but this is not really something I’m interested in.
The problem now is that it’s almost July of my M4 year, and my entire application has been prepped for EM. I’ve got 2 EM away rotations scheduled at “good” programs, and had been planning on getting SLOEs for EM and not really having to worry about individual physicians writing LORs. In order to apply to EM, I need one more SLOE at least. I have this slight hope that maybe just doing EM somewhere else will help me “fall back in love” so to speak, and then I would ensure I have the 2 SLOEs I need and the rest of this mess would go away. However, another part of me says I’m already 75% convinced against EM, so am I just wasting time verifying what I already know, and do I need to just get back to my home school and do a sub-I in FM earlier? I currently only have 1 potential FM LOR writer and would like to have a second plus one letter from an EM provider if I apply FM.
Thanks for reading this incredibly long post. I know the internet can’t tell me what to do, but I really value hearing others opinions - Maybe someone who was in a similar situation or can offer a different perspective. I never expected to be this conflicted this late in the game. It probably doesn’t matter for this scenario, but for what it’s worth: Step 1: 26X, honors on M3 rotations (not trolling here).
Last edited: