- Joined
- Dec 14, 2004
- Messages
- 3,904
- Reaction score
- 4
Worth it? How much would you pay? If money wasn't a factor, how effective do you think they are? Any recommendations, if anyone has used them?
Shredder said:Worth it? How much would you pay? If money wasn't a factor, how effective do you think they are? Any recommendations, if anyone has used them?
Oh, so people on SDN are MDs and have served on adcoms? How would they know insider information, everyone has to guess here, and the few exceptions wouldn't be willing to work with you personally for months on end. Come on man, you're dreaming if you think SDN can substitute for a personal consultant, at least put some thought into your postAStudent said:That's what SDN is for....
Shredder said:Oh, so people on SDN are MDs and have served on adcoms? How would they know insider information, everyone has to guess here, and the few exceptions wouldn't be willing to work with you personally for months on end. Come on man, you're dreaming if you think SDN can substitute for a personal consultant, at least put some thought into your post
just fine ha ha, like the ones who have stellar credentials and supreme confidence going into the process and end up having everything crash down on them? and they have no clue why it happened too? dont tell me this situation is uncommon. and the ones with sorry stats who get into great schools, leaving everyone else wondering? do you think there is a lottery system going on behind close doors with the adcoms? everyone convinces themselves that things turn out "just fine", and thats how the psychology works--denial, anger, rationalization, depression, and acceptanceAStudent said:Then I think you answered your own question *****. If you feel the need to blow the money, be my guest, but 99% of us haven't and turned out just fine.
money to burn, so youre saying perhaps 1000 (1% of med school debt) isnt worth the opportunity to converse on a regular basis with someone who has served on an adcom at a top school for years and can evaulate you personally as a candidate instead of spewing out generic information (good grades, good mcat, volunteer, research) like websites and school premed advisors? everyone has some sort of relative deficiencyCode Brown said:They're great if you have some sort of deficiency in your application that you need help with (i.e. bad GPA, low MCAT, no reserach, felony, disciplinary action from your school, no volunteering/community service, etc.) or if you are really trying for a specific school, can't write worth ****, or have money to burn.
thanks for the input, drmom. ill think about it, but information and assistance still tends to be generic due to the fact that it has to address many aspiring premeds. ill put it in terms of tennis; players have coaches who know their attitudes and playing styles. its tough to go from one coach to another seeking advice on how to win.DrMom said:I wouldn't waste money on these consultants. The information/assistance you need is readily available at little or no cost.
Shredder said:money to burn, so youre saying perhaps 1000 (1% of med school debt) isnt worth the opportunity to converse on a regular basis with someone who has served on an adcom at a top school for years and can evaulate you personally as a candidate instead of spewing out generic information (good grades, good mcat, volunteer, research) like websites and school premed advisors? everyone has some sort of relative deficiency
Shredder said:money to burn, so youre saying perhaps 1000 (1% of med school debt) isnt worth the opportunity to converse on a regular basis with someone who has served on an adcom at a top school for years and can evaulate you personally as a candidate instead of spewing out generic information (good grades, good mcat, volunteer, research) like websites and school premed advisors? everyone has some sort of relative deficiency
That's the same place I ran into recently and am considering. I also read there:fullefect1 said:http://www.admissionsconsultants.com/credentials.asp
Not to say that they are from top schools, but I still don't see why in the world they would be doing this job. Maybe this web site is lying.. haha
dude, you're like the kid that IMed me.... if people are offering advice to u, don't criticize them. chill out. the consulting services are, in my opinion, for people that aren't totally aware of all the factors that go into the application. the percentage of people that get in and use the service i bet is less than 1%. if u feel like you're not aware of all the aspects, u can use the service, but SDN is a great site to learn about all of that and ur pre-health advisor. but dude, more important than that advice... be respectful.Shredder said:thanks madame, i appreciate your refreshing post and advice therein. if only more could follow the example.
Shredder said:money to burn, so youre saying perhaps 1000 (1% of med school debt) isnt worth the opportunity to converse on a regular basis with someone who has served on an adcom at a top school for years and can evaulate you personally as a candidate instead of spewing out generic information (good grades, good mcat, volunteer, research) like websites and school premed advisors? everyone has some sort of relative deficiency
or you could just set up a free appointment with an admission director like the one at MCW is willing to do.Shredder said:money to burn, so youre saying perhaps 1000 (1% of med school debt) isnt worth the opportunity to converse on a regular basis with someone who has served on an adcom at a top school for years and can evaulate you personally as a candidate instead of spewing out generic information (good grades, good mcat, volunteer, research) like websites and school premed advisors? everyone has some sort of relative deficiency
interesting...one of the first posters that claims to be on the other side... hmmm....McDizzy said:I am a surgeon who has served on both medical school admissions boards and medical school interview committees. I feel that medical school admissions consulting services can be very helpful in polishing up applications. Even the best candidates present a picture of themselves with help.
Shredder said:im a sales rep now?