I decided to post this here (please dont move
) b/c the military forums..esp. mil. dentistry forum is always dead...If you check out the military medicine threads you will see nothing but guys trashing the hell out of military medicine, the hpsp, etc. Almost treating it as through you are selling your soul to the devil..that the hpsp isn't really a "scholarship" at all, that you actually dont get to see/do anything and it makes you a worse clinician. Even if some (or all) of this is true, does anyone here who has military dental experience have the same feelings? Do you feel that you actually got/are getting little to no valuable experience? Do you think your skills will not be improved once your time is up? Is it as bad as these military med. guys are making it out to be? I'd like to think there'd be a little more stability with the dentists in the military...that there really isn't the need to ship them around as much and put a stop on their progression as clinicians. any thoughts? thanks everyone!
I can understand why military physicians would say those things, but I disagree with a great deal in this post.
Really, saying that the hpsp isn't a scholarship is not true at all. Even if you borrow money while on hpsp, it will be significantly lower than what you would have had to borrow without it. The only people who want you to believe that the hpsp isn't a scholarship is Sallie Mae etc. which is why the student loan services is a billion dollar industry.
I agree with Squids: There are great short term gains in that you are given the environment to increase your skills before having to deal with the real world. A lot of associates who come right out of school are really "slow" clinically and thus don't make enough to deal with those aformentioned student loans, buy a decent home, car, etc.
It is not as easy as people think to come out dental school and start making big money. It takes time to accrue skill and build a client base all the time you have debtors breathing down your neck.
Most of the dentists I see in private practice are still paying off loans some 15years out of dental school, and I have never been comfortable with that sort of debt.
The military isn't for everyone, but living off of credit for years isn't for everyone either. You have to make the decision that is best for you, and let those who want out get out and move on with their lives.
No one who is complaining on either of these boards will help you pay those loans or gain clinical skill. That will be all on the individual.
Lastly, I don't think the military dental forum is dead at all. There is great deal of nonsense posting on the predental and dental forums further proving that is easy to talk a lot and say nothing. I would make the point that more of the posting in the military forum, while not as voluminous is more productive (e.g. quality vs. quantity). Having posted on all three of the forums, I can say that mood here has a great deal more comrarderie.
Just my two cents.