PsyDRxPnow said:
The issue that psychiatrists are having regarding psychologists prescribing is the fact that it invades their turf. The arguments that they use have no valid basis. The patients health is never jeopardized at any point since the psychologists who prescribe exceed the training that is given to all PAs, NPs, and most of all general medical practitioners when it comes to psychotropic and expertise on mental illness. Referral to the DOD reports
http://www.apa.org/divisions/div55/ACNPrpt.html
There are empirical studies showing that non-physician practitioners harm and in some cases, kill people when compared with their physician counterparts. I don't have the citations handy...do a search on pubmed for "nurse anesthesists, adverse outcome, physician assistant," and the like.
Don't say the patient's health is never jeopardized. When anyone prescribes a medication, the potential exists, especially in one who is not medically trained, which nurses and PAs are. Nurses and PAs at least have a broad background in disease states, and recognize sick people when they see them. Psychologists have not proven they can. Why should they? They are not trained to do so, are not trained to do so in the weekend master's courses, and don't operate in that capacity.
Please stop referring to the DoD paper if you can't assimilate the full results and make the appropriate extrapolations (or lack thereof). Tell me the only medications they prescribed and to what populations, and with what supervision, and with what exact training. It's quite different from what is currently being offered in non-medically affiliated psychopharm master's institutions across the US. And it's extremely different in light of psychologists' want for a FULL formulary with NO oversight. There is no possible way to explain this other than ego needs. Please answer that question....what possible need does a psychologist have to carry a full formulary with no oversight? I look forward to the response.
As a prescribing psychologist, would you ever prescribe an antibiotic, ever? What about a harmless medication refill for your patient who's out of atenolol? Would you ever prescribe cleocin for your son's acne? Ever? Be honest. If you answer no, I know you're lying.
PsyDRxPnow said:
You have said it medical school. They do not want anyone to prescribe unless that someone has an MD and maybe a DO because from what I understand Louisiana was the last state to allow DO to practice as physician until 2 years ago (took 50 yrs to gain power in all 50 states) but I digress, perhaps if they cared primary for the patients safety then they should answer your questions in a realistic and rational way, because the fact of the matter is that you dont need to go to medical school to prescribe competently.
.....Their motto is protecting the turf at all cost. This is not a motto or a philosophy that has been working.
Wrong again. The last state to license DOs was in 1973 in Mississippi.
On what basis do you claim that physician's motto is to "protect turf at all costs," and that it "is not a motto or a philosophy that has been working?" We arguably have the best healthcare available anywhere in the world. We didn't get that way by giving practicing rights to everyone that demanded them. Looks like it's working to me.
you may not be able to get your answer from psychiatrists at the time being due to the fact that they are still in denial. However you will get the answer from other psychologists who are already prescribing and the MD/DOs who are providing them with supervision for the time being. These individuals are open minded and are not defensive or insecure about their turf which makes them more open and sincere in answering your questions.
Or perhaps it's because psychiatrists and residents don't often have the time to sit in front of the computer all day long responding to posts within seconds of them being written. For God's sake. We're out seeing sick patients....not pontificating in group settings about the agenda for the next diversity workshop.
...the fact of the matter is that you dont need to go to medical school to prescribe competently.
What about ECT? Answer it. What about DM or HTN management? What about emergency psychiatry (please research the medical complexities of it before you answer a blanket "Yes!"). What about addiction psychiatry? Again, look into it. Will you confidently treat the SSRI syndrome you caused in your office or the NMS? You won't learn this in your measly 100 patient practicum, and will be embarrassed and shamed when you're on the phone calling the ambulance or dialing the psychiatrists in the hospital clinic because you don't know what to do, since you didn't do a psychiatry residency, and missed out on 2-3 years of general practical medical training as a medical student.
Want to become truly competent and confident in what you're doing? Want to do it RIGHT? Want to know that you've given the sick patient all the best care that can reasonably be offered by your knowledge base in the best practice of medicine? Go to medical school and stop fooling yourself. Other psychologists have. Talk to them.
You reek of inexperience and naivete, and clearly have a dearth of knowledge regarding the workings of healthcare in general, and the practice of medicine and psychiatry in particular. If you ever received rx privilages, and moved to a state where it was allowed, and somehow came to practice this way without supervision, I pray for your patients.