My WWittle Pony: Friendship is MMagic Game Thread

[bluestoat]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Cray/Trilt is kinda compatible to me but I need to read a bit over again. It did feel that, as time went on, Trilt suddenly came out of the left with her MJ vote.

 

[Trilt]

It's not

Saying something ambiguous about wolf perspective is hardly the same, imo.

With the context of my role and that flipped one, I agree a mane six claim is further kind of questionable. Spitfire is reaching a bit into side characters and this is... not a big game.

 

[Trilt]

Cray/Trilt is kinda compatible to me but I need to read a bit over again. It did feel that, as time went on, Trilt suddenly came out of the left with her MJ vote.

I literally was asked who I would flip mid-thread and said Cray or MJ, and have an eternal dislike of players who don't contribute. We haven't played together but I promise getting a silent player killed is very on brand for me, lol. It's false to say that came out of nowhere.

 

[Santygrass]

@Santygrass What changed your vote?

Votes and interactions, plus what tbey claimed and their thoughts on it adding up with previous post that they did.

As in, the stuff about 3p, and them saying that they liked my posts about the setup discussion

 

[bluestoat]

Votes and interactions, plus what tbey claimed and their thoughts on it adding up with previous post that they did.

As in, the stuff about 3p, and them saying that they liked my posts about the setup discussion

I REALLY wish I had been more present when that was going down because that is exactly the kind of discussion that brings out my "make me believe you, cause I don't" mindset

 

[Santygrass]

Now I am conflicted cuz I am V reading Stoat reaction to the yeet too.

So now I am looking at Trilt/Dubz in the lower part of my PoE, with a slight paranoia on misclearing someone like AM nyeh

 

[Santygrass]

Like, Stoat WolfHunting energy rn its very real I think and thats a pretty good look regardless of Cray alignment

 

[WildZoo]

Saying something ambiguous about wolf perspective is hardly the same, imo.

With the context of my role and that flipped one, I agree a mane six claim is further kind of questionable. Spitfire is reaching a bit into side characters and this is... not a big game.

How was what I said ambiguous? I thought the interpretation of her ability was coming from a wolf perspective.

 

[WildZoo]

Now I am conflicted cuz I am V reading Stoat reaction to the yeet too.

So now I am looking at Trilt/Dubz in the lower part of my PoE, with a slight paranoia on misclearing someone like AM nyeh

I don't understand why I'm so low

 

[alissa14]

I was kinda leaning alissa wolfy, but then she points out that voting Zenge D1 is getting her negative energy, so now I'm thinking maybe it is a town move, whether we like it or not. But then there's the WIFOM on that too. Trying to digest all this.

Hmmm. If I were not me I’d almost lean my action wolfy

WOW I don't like this post. I can't figure out why but it's like licorice on a hotdog. It clashes. I'll muse on that.

Yah same

Why are you like this? Of all the examples you could have used, you decided to ruin perfectly good food? Smh.

Spoiler

Honestly I'm just waiting for whatever big fakeclaim stoat pulls. That always injects spice into the game.

A woman of my own heart🥰

Good lord, finals already??

Spoiler

No just a final for this one class. We have a blocked schedule. We are tested roughly every 7-10 days (though almost all vet schools have this testing frequency). But it’s nice to not have a ton of finals at once at the end of each semester.

I see what you did there

Why the sad react sporty 🙁

Oho. I haven't heard from you in a bit.

Hi I was studying with my study group

 

[bluestoat]

Like, Stoat WolfHunting energy rn its very real I think and thats a pretty good look regardless of Cray alignment

You seem to have completely stepped away from Cray and I don't see what you're seeing there, so I need you to help me understand why she seems to have left the POE when multiple others have said this flip is a bad look for Cray.

 

[Trilt]

How was what I said ambiguous? I thought the interpretation of her ability was coming from a wolf perspective.

You really don't see a significant level of difference between:

That was, usually I give at least day to PR claims. But like... the interpretation feels like a wolf perspective.

and

Still felt like a wolf seer claim to me if we take the role bit out of the equation

?

 

[bluestoat]

Like, Stoat WolfHunting energy rn its very real I think and thats a pretty good look regardless of Cray alignment

As the salmiakki convo shows, I like bitter things, like the taste of disappointment

Gives me something to push against

 

[WildZoo]

You really don't see a significant level of difference between:


and

?

Nope. Maybe because I know that in my head when I said her interpretation seemed like a wolfy perspective that was what I meant (which is why I said it *still* felt like a wolf seer claim later), but I don't really know how else you could take that statement. What did you think I was saying?

 

[bluestoat]

You really don't see a significant level of difference between:


and

?

I don't either :/

 

[Trilt]

Nope. Maybe because I know that in my head when I said her interpretation seemed like a wolfy perspective that was what I meant (which is why I said it *still* felt like a wolf seer claim later), but I don't really know how else you could take that statement. What did you think I was saying?

I wasn't tracking, which is why I went ughhh when you were a lot more specific a couple posts later haha.

 

[WildZoo]

I wasn't tracking, which is why I went ughhh when you were a lot more specific a couple posts later haha.

Sorry. Sometimes my stream of consciousness word vomitus is lacking in clarity lol

 

[Animal Midwife]

I wasn't tracking, which is why I went ughhh when you were a lot more specific a couple posts later haha.

Did you see any of my posts where I though it was a weird claim too? Also, why would dubz continue to sit on seer!Cray in a world where she's doing anything but wolfread her?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I'm still mostly bothered by the phrasing. If she said she believes it hunt scum, rather than just wolves, it'd still be weird but more realistic. Specifically saying it only helps with 3p though seems like something that'd benefit a faction unconcerned with wolves.

 

[Trilt]

Did you see any of my posts where I though it was a weird claim too? Also, why would dubz continue to sit on seer!Cray in a world where she's doing anything but wolfread her?

You mean this single post?

Also, flavor means nothing to me before we yeet a wolf and without confirmation that mods didn't provide covers.

Because otherwise you asked questions of the role... like you do for literally everything. Hardly a strong statement.

And the counterwagon for Cray was someone who Dubz repeatedly said she won't vote for d1 like that, and there was minimal time to move things. Don't act like this was a well discussed thing with many options and significant time.

 

[bluestoat]

I'm still mostly bothered by the phrasing. If she said she believes it hunt scum, rather than just wolves, it'd still be weird but more realistic. Specifically saying it only helps with 3p though seems like something that'd benefit a faction unconcerned with wolves.

Sudden feelings about vetgame where wolf Cray was talking about the 3P and she had just a little more information because she was a wolf.

 

[Mad Jack]

...has it ever worked?

*************
It literally hasn't once ever and I haven't been a wolf in years. AM, killing MJ for no reason every time he plays and literally the reason he doesn't play anymore. Thanks for reminding my why. I'm retiring for good and it's because you won't leave me alone, thanks for ruining the game for me.
*************

 

[Trilt]

I'm still mostly bothered by the phrasing. If she said she believes it hunt scum, rather than just wolves, it'd still be weird but more realistic. Specifically saying it only helps with 3p though seems like something that'd benefit a faction unconcerned with wolves.

I don't disagree with this at all, though. I think another role flip overnight will continue to help us pare down whether that was a reasonable claim or just the informed minority being able to gamble successfully.

 

[Trilt]

*************
It literally hasn't once ever and I haven't been a wolf in years. AM, killing MJ for no reason every time he plays and literally the reason he doesn't play anymore. Thanks for reminding my why. I'm retiring for good and it's because you won't leave me alone, thanks for ruining the game for me.
*************

She didn't even vote for you, calm your tits and redirect your anger appropriately.

 

[bluestoat]

She didn't even vote for you, calm your tits and redirect your anger appropriately.

It's true, she voted for her charming and thread-absent (until lateTuesday) granddaughter

 

[Animal Midwife]

You mean this single post?

No. I mean these posts.

I would never assume I'm a 3p seer, unless that is explicitly said, when there's no mechanical evidence that 3p even exists.

I find both wagons quite interesting.

Wait, why'd you ask after unyeeting her?

Also, flavor means nothing to me before we yeet a wolf and without confirmation that mods didn't provide covers.

Because otherwise you asked questions of the role... like you do for literally everything. Hardly a strong statement.

No.

And the counterwagon for Cray was someone who Dubz repeatedly said she won't vote for d1 like that, and there was minimal time to move things. Don't act like this was a well discussed thing with many options and significant time.

That would be a warp of the situation. She never said she was staying on Cray to save MJ. In fact, she even resigned to the fact that he could be wolfing given his inability to play.

To say Cray wasn't discussed for hours is undermining previous effort.

 

[Mad Jack]

She didn't even vote for you, calm your tits and redirect your anger appropriately.

************
She's the one who got eyes on me. She always starts poking at me and never stops so the second she starts I just gave up. I've never survived a night once she starts and it makes me hate the game. I waited to even put in my vote because I literally can't vote without becoming suspect number one every game I play. It makes the game suck. Whether I defend myself or not, I always die. That's why I quit playing and it's as true today as ever.
**************

 

[Trilt]

That would be a warp of the situation. She never said she was staying on Cray to save MJ. In fact, she even resigned to the fact that he could be wolfing given his inability to play.

To say Cray wasn't discussed for hours is undermining previous effort.

I find both wagons quite interesting.

ah yes, a detail filled post definitely expressing your concerns with the claim.

Cray was discussed - somewhat; with a lot of "waiting for more info from her," but the role claim was not, which is what I was specifying.

 

[Santygrass]

You seem to have completely stepped away from Cray and I don't see what you're seeing there, so I need you to help me understand why she seems to have left the POE when multiple others have said this flip is a bad look for Cray.

Kinda busy rn, I think my reasoning is there near when Cray claimed if you want a reference. I saw that Cray had 5 votes and unvoted there and put my thoughts on why I did see them unlikely as a wolf

 

[Santygrass]

************
She's the one who got eyes on me. She always starts poking at me and never stops so the second she starts I just gave up. I've never survived a night once she starts and it makes me hate the game. I waited to even put in my vote because I literally can't vote without becoming suspect number one every game I play. It makes the game suck. Whether I defend myself or not, I always die. That's why I quit playing and it's as true today as ever.
**************

If you were yeeted it wasnt thanks to AM IMO.

She didnt do much to get you yeeted. Other peoole contributed more to that.
A piece of advice is that going under the radar or 'waiting to do stuff' is antitowny in general, and you made yourself harder to find as town olaying that way.

A shame that you had a bad experience tho, take care and hopefully no hard feelings, this is a game after all!

 

[bluestoat]

Kinda busy rn, I think my reasoning is there near when Cray claimed if you want a reference. I saw that Cray had 5 votes and unvoted there and put my thoughts on why I did see them unlikely as a wolf

Thoughts on Cray now?

Thoughts on the interaction between Trilt and AM?

 

[Trilt]

************
She's the one who got eyes on me. She always starts poking at me and never stops so the second she starts I just gave up. I've never survived a night once she starts and it makes me hate the game. I waited to even put in my vote because I literally can't vote without becoming suspect number one every game I play. It makes the game suck. Whether I defend myself or not, I always die. That's why I quit playing and it's as true today as ever.
**************

This is a serious revisionist history of how the lynch progressed and I'm happy to discuss further post-game, but I think pushing outside of what you really should be doing as a dead player. IMO it is absolutely unfair to blame AM.

 

[bluestoat]

@Crayola227 why didn't you vote within your POE? I need to go back and look at your vote switch

Cray still looks bad though.

Seems like AM got more attn from Trilt after this.

 

[bluestoat]

I literally was asked who I would flip mid-thread and said Cray or MJ, and have an eternal dislike of players who don't contribute. We haven't played together but I promise getting a silent player killed is very on brand for me, lol. It's false to say that came out of nowhere.

I read this after my latest posts

Voting out lowposters is familiar to me. I know certain players who feel very strongly about this. I'll make a note to add you to that pile.

 

[Animal Midwife]

ah yes, a detail filled post definitely expressing your concerns with the claim.

Cray was discussed - somewhat; with a lot of "waiting for more info from her," but the role claim was not, which is what I was specifying.

Oh, well, at least for me, I generally don't keep expressing distaste with a claim unless something doesn't feel right to me. I probably should have moved to Cray based on those feelings.

 

[Mad Jack]

If you were yeeted it wasnt thanks to AM IMO.

She didnt do much to get you yeeted. Other peoole contributed more to that.
A piece of advice is that going under the radar or 'waiting to do stuff' is antitowny in general, and you made yourself harder to find as town olaying that way.

A shame that you had a bad experience tho, take care and hopefully no hard feelings, this is a game after all!

***************
I'm just tired from getting home very late and studying for boards next Tuesday. I wish someone would have even let me know I was up to die because I would have defended myself, but I guess it's my fault for not checking after AM started the questions. I'm too old and busy for this game and playing, as always, was a mistake, because I just don't have time for it.
***************

 

[potentialsheltervet]

How was what I said ambiguous? I thought the interpretation of her ability was coming from a wolf perspective.

Have you elaborated on this anywhere? I'm getting lost in how the wording of Cray's claim feels more wolfy than villagey.
I'm assuming she paraphrased her role PM to avoid mod wrath.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

In any case, I'm assuming at least some aspects of that will be self-resolving.

 

[WildZoo]

Have you elaborated on this anywhere? I'm getting lost in how the wording of Cray's claim feels more wolfy than villagey.
I'm assuming she paraphrased her role PM to avoid mod wrath.

Not the wording, her interpretation of it.

 

[Crayola227]

I'm still mostly bothered by the phrasing. If she said she believes it hunt scum, rather than just wolves, it'd still be weird but more realistic. Specifically saying it only helps with 3p though seems like something that'd benefit a faction unconcerned with wolves.

What happened is I asked the mods if it would help me find out who was villager and who was a wolf, and they basically said back, "what makes you think it does either and that this isn't multiball?"

I mean, they could just be screwing with me. Couple that with the responses about 3P in the thread... I would be very very surprised if I was able to seer wolves but I guess we'll find out if I live the night.

 

[Truenamer]

*************
It literally hasn't once ever and I haven't been a wolf in years. AM, killing MJ for no reason every time he plays and literally the reason he doesn't play anymore. Thanks for reminding my why. I'm retiring for good and it's because you won't leave me alone, thanks for ruining the game for me.
*************

************
She's the one who got eyes on me. She always starts poking at me and never stops so the second she starts I just gave up. I've never survived a night once she starts and it makes me hate the game. I waited to even put in my vote because I literally can't vote without becoming suspect number one every game I play. It makes the game suck. Whether I defend myself or not, I always die. That's why I quit playing and it's as true today as ever.
**************

***************
I'm just tired from getting home very late and studying for boards next Tuesday. I wish someone would have even let me know I was up to die because I would have defended myself, but I guess it's my fault for not checking after AM started the questions. I'm too old and busy for this game and playing, as always, was a mistake, because I just don't have time for it.
***************

I am really sorry, and I know misyeets are frustrating, but they are a core part of the game and we're pushing the borders of appropriate talk here, for a dead player or a living one.

We will make a dead chat soon, until then maybe a little cooling-off and distance from the thread might be good?

 

[Animal Midwife]

What happened is I asked the mods if it would help me find out who was villager and who was a wolf, and they basically said back, "what makes you think it does either and that this isn't multiball?"

I mean, they could just be screwing with me. Couple that with the responses about 3P in the thread... I would be very very surprised if I was able to seer wolves but I guess we'll find out if I live the night.

So you don't even know if you're a seer?

 

[Mad Jack]

This is a serious revisionist history of how the lynch progressed and I'm happy to discuss further post-game, but I think pushing outside of what you really should be doing as a dead player. IMO it is absolutely unfair to blame AM.

*************
I haven't ready any of the thread after I stopped posting and up until my death, I stopped reading after AM questioned me and I provided my very clear answer, because there was nothing else to say. I don't have time to with my certification boards next week. That's just why I stopped posting. And I'm just letting people know why I'm done with WW, because clearly it's a very busy thing I just can't do. Not that anyone cares, but it's just a pain in the ass for low time availability players and that may be why player counts are so low these days. You basically have to live the game and people just can't do that. I didn't even *know* I was dead until wayyyy after and I'm just so frustrated by that even if it's my fault (though I'm shocked no one reached out to me elsewhere). WW needs to be lower investment or it will die because it's endlessly frustrating for those of us that can't reply 50 times a day. You end up feeling like a disappointment for even signing up because the active players swing things too quickly to even know what is going on, and people don't take straightforward answers for what they are without a bunch of follow-up questions that take more time you don't have.

I suppose this is more of just my rant about the WW state of play than anything. It's high investment, high frustration, and low payoff for all but the most dedicated players. I don't know when things changed, or maybe I just changed, but it makes me quite sad that the magic isn't there anymore.
**************

 

[potentialsheltervet]

"Each night, I may choose someone and learn something about their affiliation."
I'm super curious to know what the "learn something about their affiliation" part was paraphrased from because I feel like that is really crucial information.

 

[bluestoat]

What happened is I asked the mods if it would help me find out who was villager and who was a wolf, and they basically said back, "what makes you think it does either and that this isn't multiball?"

I mean, they could just be screwing with me. Couple that with the responses about 3P in the thread... I would be very very surprised if I was able to seer wolves but I guess we'll find out if I live the night.

See this doesn't sell me on it. Why wouldn't the mods just say "you are an affiliation seer" or some variant thereof

 

[WildZoo]

I'd love to do a vote progression thingy but I don't have that kind of time. Just interested in how the MJ wagon formed and whatnot. Relative to a 36 hour day, it did happen fairly quickly. More informative if we knew Cray's aff of course.

 

[bluestoat]

I'd love to do a vote progression thingy but I don't have that kind of time. Just interested in how the MJ wagon formed and whatnot. Relative to a 36 hour day, it did happen fairly quickly. More informative if we knew Cray's aff of course.

This is relatable

 

[Truenamer]

It would endear you to the mod team to have all your actions submitted, sonnets written, TikToks edited, and eyebrows plucked by 6am.

 

[WildZoo]

It would endear you to the mod team to have all your actions submitted, sonnets written, TikToks edited, and eyebrows plucked by 6am.

I make no promises on the eyebrows

 

[WildZoo]

This is relatable

Like I know Zenge was the first vote there, which means it couldn't have started before like, 2 hours to close. Just not sure on the timing of the rest. Some were after Cray's claim...

Head hurty so I should really go to bed anyway. Tomorrow!Dubz problem.