I think the rest of my application is pretty solid so that's why I am still hopeful - applied to a ton of 4-year only programs. 3 externships (1 at my program), research (1 minor publication) including AADR and IADR posters, oral Surgery club, oral path club, etc.
I know Part I is what PD's actually care about, I just didn't know if they even let the Part II score enter into their thoughts. Based on your replies, I'm leaning towards just taking it late winter/early spring and not worrying much about it and getting a pass. I know having a Pass won't hurt me, the only reason I'd take Part II is if it would actually help me at all...