I noticed this too! I had an M1 trying to give me career advice about choosing surgery as a specialty in the Surgery forums and it was an awkward and surreal experience. Had me wondering whether there was something so naive about me that it sounded even to M1's that I needed their input. I'm a little relieved to hear that it may be a recent SDN trend.
I feel like some people don't realize that your opinion on SDN isn't worth the paper it's printed on because the whole point of advice on SDN is to get plentiful anonymous advice from people who've got experience and real input on the matter.
Heck, if I wanted the input of random underclassmen about whether passion for surgery & medicine in general holds up in the face of the rigors and demands of the current climate of surgery residency and eventual practice, I'd probably go hang out in my school's anatomy lab, where I TA'ed as an M2 (not as a premed though, you notice) and glean the abundant wisdom therein.
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=580785
And realistically, the lamborghini guy should have to cite evidence that DO residencies
don't use the USMLE for selection criteria if he's requiring it out of people who say DO residencies
do use the USMLE to substantiate their claims.
To address the OP:
1) If you're asking if you have a shot at MD neurosurgery, the answer is an unequivocal "no" (rather, yes, your fate is sealed).
2) If you're asking if you have a shot at DO neurosurgery, the answer is "probably not", but I don't have any knowledge whatsoever about DO programs. Just keep in mind that there are very few MD residencies and far fewer DO residencies (someone can probably clarify how many spots etc.), so presumably you've got enough DO applicants with awesome scores matching into those spots, and lots who have good, not great scores going unmatched, lots who have so-so scores going unmatched, and probably 100% of people who failed going unmatched.
3) If you're asking if you can get
some residency, of course you can. Just do you research about the specifics (MD/DO, what fields, what programs, what geographical areas, etc.) for whatever field you're thinking about going into.
And not to be harsh, but I'm just surprised that someone would cite their "dream" as being neurosurgery, but then fail BOTH the USMLE and COMLEX. First off, if it was really your dream...how could you let that happen? Are you wholly unfamiliar with the requirements to get into the field and the standards that have to be met? Don't you think there should be some accountability for neurosurgeons to at least be able to pass licensing exams, especially when it's well established far and wide that the standard is for their performance to be exceptional? Don't you think neurosurgeons should be exceptional? It just sounds out of touch with reality. And then it's even more out of touch with reality to then wonder if you're still a candidate for a spot.
....alright I apologize for being harsh and rereading the above paragraph it it's a little overboard, but I'm not going to delete it because nonetheless I think it's pretty much true.