MyNameIsOtto

10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Jan 7, 2007
84
1
Earth
Status
Resident [Any Field]
I'm wondering how neurology programs work at other institutions. At our hospital, patient's with straight-up neuro signs and symptoms are routinely rejected by neurology as "toxic/metabolic causes" and admitted to us (medicine).

We routinely admit acute strokes, seizure disorders, etc. with no clear secondary etiology other than a "WBC of 11.5", which warrants admission to the hospitalist team for "further work-up". However, the neurology resident also recommends MRI Brain, CTA Head/Neck, etc., etc.

Why does neurology suck so much at our institution? :confused:
 

jdh71

epiphany at nine thousand six hundred feet
10+ Year Member
Dec 14, 2006
67,883
46,971
FEMA Camp, USA
Status
Attending Physician
I'm wondering how neurology programs work at other institutions. At our hospital, patient's with straight-up neuro signs and symptoms are routinely rejected by neurology as "toxic/metabolic causes" and admitted to us (medicine).

We routinely admit acute strokes, seizure disorders, etc. with no clear secondary etiology other than a "WBC of 11.5", which warrants admission to the hospitalist team for "further work-up". However, the neurology resident also recommends MRI Brain, CTA Head/Neck, etc., etc.

Why does neurology suck so much at our institution? :confused:
I've often asked myself, "When was the last time neurology was actually helpful?"
 

gutonc

No Meat, No Treat
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Mar 6, 2005
18,232
11,117
Status
Attending Physician
I've often asked myself, "When was the last time neurology was actually helpful?"
Meh...I give 'em a break most of the time. They have almost no useful therapies and basically function as organic MRI machines. I generally order an MRI brain/X-spine and call a neuro consult at the same time and let whoever gets there first make the diagnosis.

But my favorite neuro consult experience of my residency involved a patient being admitted to the MICU by a total douchecanoe of an ED attending. She had new onset seizures with no obvious etiology and was actively seizing when transported out of the ED. I got the signout as she was being rolled onto the unit. When I asked what Neuro thought of the new onset seizures, said douchebagel yelled into the phone "don't tell me how to practice medicine!" and hung up on me. 5 minutes later, the neuro resident on call showed up in the MICU while we were pushing ativan and took over management. Once the patient stopped seizing, she (the resident) rolled the patient down to the neuro ICU by herself. I got a non-apology apology page from the ED douchewad later that night saying "sorry about the miscommunication on Ms. Jones earlier."
 

flipmd

7+ Year Member
Jul 15, 2009
149
34
Status
Resident [Any Field]
A lot of times it's not so much that Neurology sucks, but that the ED docs are pushovers. The ED docs have power to admit to whoever they want to wherever they want. However, the moment Neuro (and surgery, and ortho, and psych, etc. etc.) says admit to Medicine, guess where the patient goes, regardless of what the ED doc thinks the REAL diagnosis is? It's the path of least resistance.
 

jdh71

epiphany at nine thousand six hundred feet
10+ Year Member
Dec 14, 2006
67,883
46,971
FEMA Camp, USA
Status
Attending Physician
Does ortho actually admit anything from the ED these days? :laugh:
 

gutonc

No Meat, No Treat
Staff member
Administrator
10+ Year Member
Mar 6, 2005
18,232
11,117
Status
Attending Physician
Does ortho actually admit anything from the ED these days? :laugh:
The occasional trauma requiring only operative bone repair without other issues. Otherwise, no. In fact, in our hospital they all go to the hospitalist service automatically.
 

LoudBark

5+ Year Member
Nov 14, 2011
300
65
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Does ortho actually admit anything from the ED these days? :laugh:
How did ortho get brought into this conversation? Ortho and neuro shouldn't even be mentioned in the same context of anything.....

Ortho fixes almost everything it touches, neuro fixes almost nothing it lays eyes on.....

That being said, back to neuro.....with my experience, this is what you get when you order a neuro consult......MRI / MRA, CTA head, EEG of course to r/o seizure, LP of course.....and then about $2 million later........the diagnosis of "toxic metabolic encephalopathy".......gee thanks neuro......
 

Gastrapathy

no longer apathetic
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Feb 27, 2007
5,017
4,127
Status
Attending Physician
when I attended on IM wards, there were three services that I didn't want my resident to consult without talking to me:

GI (mine)
ID (painful)
Neuro (useless)
 
Jul 29, 2011
2
0
India
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Oh my god the world works the same everywhere... I m a third yr IM resident in India..nd its the same here as welll.... lol neuro never takes the waste cva/stroke cases...which basically require a nurse and a physiotherapist... nd for nything we cant figure out..they cant either without like sumone said $2million investigations...hahaha @ i call an mri and neuro and let whoever comes first, make the diagnosis:-D :-D its such a relief to share the frustration....lol and true true IM is the path of least resistance... u know i have a case admitted under IM who was a diagnosed case of ckd was on maintainence HD, went in for renal transplant...during surgery suffered a cardiac arrest..hypoxic brain injury..nd seen by nephro/neuro/cardio/uro...but finally admitted under IM... :/ ;/
 

Doctor4Life1769

**tr0llin, ridin dirty**
10+ Year Member
Apr 28, 2008
34,255
901
Where the grass is always greener
Status
Resident [Any Field]
^^ lolwut
 

VA Hopeful Dr

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
Jul 28, 2004
19,920
25,046
Status
Attending Physician
Meh...I give 'em a break most of the time. They have almost no useful therapies and basically function as organic MRI machines. I generally order an MRI brain/X-spine and call a neuro consult at the same time and let whoever gets there first make the diagnosis.

But my favorite neuro consult experience of my residency involved a patient being admitted to the MICU by a total douchecanoe of an ED attending. She had new onset seizures with no obvious etiology and was actively seizing when transported out of the ED. I got the signout as she was being rolled onto the unit. When I asked what Neuro thought of the new onset seizures, said douchebagel yelled into the phone "don't tell me how to practice medicine!" and hung up on me. 5 minutes later, the neuro resident on call showed up in the MICU while we were pushing ativan and took over management. Once the patient stopped seizing, she (the resident) rolled the patient down to the neuro ICU by herself. I got a non-apology apology page from the ED douchewad later that night saying "sorry about the miscommunication on Ms. Jones earlier."
Pure poetry that only raw fury at another doctor can elicit.
 

Acherona

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
Nov 21, 2004
605
19
Status
Attending Physician
the most common cause of "altered mental status" in the hospital is actually toxic metabolic encephalopathy. if there are no focal signs, this is not likely to be a primary neurologic problem, and the eeg will show "slowing". now if you knew that already, why did you waste the neurology residents time? medicine residents in my experience have a poor basis of understanding of the nervous system, and are generally very confused about what neurologic signs/symtoms mean, or what the purpose of a test is. Every specialty has their own panoply of tests and wants imaging of their own organ. in medicine, it's cbc, chem7, cxr ,ekg...pretty much regardless of the chief complaint. would you dare to consult pulm without a CT first? i doubt it. also the most common diseases in internal medicine are equally incurable. I don't know about you but i've never seen anyone get cured of heart failure or copd. they degenerate and eventually die from their disease. lastly, if your hospital has a neurology ward, you probably have no idea how many "real" neuro cases are going there instead of medicine because all you see are what end up on your service.
 

jdh71

epiphany at nine thousand six hundred feet
10+ Year Member
Dec 14, 2006
67,883
46,971
FEMA Camp, USA
Status
Attending Physician
Y u mad brah??

the most common cause of "altered mental status" in the hospital is actually toxic metabolic encephalopathy. if there are no focal signs, this is not likely to be a primary neurologic problem, and the eeg will show "slowing". now if you knew that already, why did you waste the neurology residents time? medicine residents in my experience have a poor basis of understanding of the nervous system, and are generally very confused about what neurologic signs/symtoms mean, or what the purpose of a test is. Every specialty has their own panoply of tests and wants imaging of their own organ. in medicine, it's cbc, chem7, cxr ,ekg...pretty much regardless of the chief complaint. would you dare to consult pulm without a CT first? i doubt it. also the most common diseases in internal medicine are equally incurable. I don't know about you but i've never seen anyone get cured of heart failure or copd. they degenerate and eventually die from their disease. lastly, if your hospital has a neurology ward, you probably have no idea how many "real" neuro cases are going there instead of medicine because all you see are what end up on your service.
 

45408

aw buddy
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 14, 2004
16,976
47
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Does ortho actually admit anything from the ED these days? :laugh:
Isolated fractures in otherwise healthy patients. Everything else goes through a hospitalist or the trauma service.


I think I've only ever called one neuro consult in two years, and I thought it was a pretty soft call in a depressed/anxious/fibromyalgia bariatric patient, but my attending wanted it.
 

vistaril

5+ Year Member
Jun 10, 2012
3,752
304
Status
Resident [Any Field]
I'm wondering how neurology programs work at other institutions. At our hospital, patient's with straight-up neuro signs and symptoms are routinely rejected by neurology as "toxic/metabolic causes" and admitted to us (medicine).

We routinely admit acute strokes, seizure disorders, etc. with no clear secondary etiology other than a "WBC of 11.5", which warrants admission to the hospitalist team for "further work-up". However, the neurology resident also recommends MRI Brain, CTA Head/Neck, etc., etc.

Why does neurology suck so much at our institution? :confused:
yeah.....as a psych resident I recognize our service is equally useless as well, but at least we recommend lesser workups....also we occasionally function as a dispo for you guys.

also, sometimes neuro puts psych in a bind in the er. Obvious example- a psych pt comes in, but the psych person riduclously asked for a neuro consult in the er before accepting the pt. Well neuro comes by, and even though it's a psych pt recommended.....you guessed it....LP and imaging. For only god knows why. So then when psych saw that, they werent going to take the patient. After all, if neuro recommends an LP the person needs a medical workup right? So then the pt ended up being dumped on medicine for three reasons:

1) psych resident ridiculously asking for a neuro consult in er
2) neuro ridiculously recommending an LP
3) the er refusing to do the imaging and LP in the er, which required a quick dispo

what happened was the pt went to medicine of course. LP negative, imaging negative of course. Pt still psychotic as all get out. Psych comes by the next day and recommends inpatient, but there of course are no beds on psychiatry. Then psych put in their usual suggestions, mainly whatever antipsychotic was popular with that attending that month. Then the pt sat on medicine for 7 days while no bed opened up as pts coming from the ER always get preference.....then medicine finally discharged the pt when he was no longer very psychotic.......

and that bull**** happens all the time at some places. Psych is most to blame, but neuro and the er has to take some of the blame as well. And I don't see why you guys tolerate that nonsense.....stand up for yourselfs