JerseyGirl is right.
It also depends on how competitive your application is. Good application, they are going to want to get you in the door as soon as possible.
I chose another school over NYCOM for several reasons. I was partial to PCOM prior to my interview at NYCOM, but I went to New York with an open mind.
First of all, I didn't like the area. Suburbs which seemed a little top pricey for me.
The facilities were ok, but I didn't like the campus. I wasn't impressed with the anatomy lab or the library and the overall look of the campus. Lecture halls and OMM lab were awesome. No recreation area (NYCOM students may argue, but come on guys...I've seen the "room" you have)
Also, I got a feeling from several NYCOM students that they weren't happy.
I was interviewing on a day when the 2nd year class was voting on whether to keep a particular exam in the current exam block or to move it. The class seemed pretty divided and they basically argued amongst eachother like a bunch of 5 year olds.
It looked like a meeting of British Parliament, without all the funny wigs. I, personally, would expect more from a group of adults.
I felt more at home at PCOM and felt very welcome by all the students. At one point, I forgot I was there for an interview...it seemed like I was already at orientation by the way the other students were treating us. They basically had the attitude "welcome to PCOM, can't wait to see you around next year, let me know if you have any questions."
NYCOM attitude was more "enjoy your summer, that's all I can say, don't come here".
Don't get me wrong. NYCOM has amazing clinical affiliations and arguably the toughest (= best ?) osteopathic curriculum going. But, in order to have this type of progam, unfortunately you would have to put up with some other things.
I have heard that 3rd & 4th year NYCOM students are VERY happy and I have never met a NYCOM grad who has had anything bad to say about the school or the position they are in now. It just seems like you need to "pay your dues" for the first 2 years at NYCOM.
All in all, its a good school. It was my second choice after PCOM. If I didn't want to stay in Philadelphia and was interested in a higher profile specialty, I may have given NYCOM more consideration, but I'm not 100% sure about that.
I just know I will be happier at PCOM and I think I will do better in school because of that.
You need to make the choice that's best for you. Go to the interview and look around for yourself.
Just be careful of the carpet in NYCOMs library.
JPH