I don't know too much about Rochester so I can't give you anything on them. As for NYMC, I have to agree with you about the grading system. The miniboards counting toward the final grade in the class sucks too. The location is nice and the chance to go to St. Vincents is hard to pass up. The students at NYMC are really worked the first year and its my opinion that is not necessary. Another thing about NYMC I did not like was the fact there is 8 people per cadaver in Gross lab and that anatomy is compressed into 3 months, but the new lab itself is incredible. I'm happy that I have the chance to go to NYMC and I will be able to overlook those negatives because what school does not have negatives, but if I get off the waitlist at University of South Florida, University of Cincinnati, or Saint Louis, I would withdraw from NYMC in a heartbeat because I think I would fit in and excel at those other schools because things are much more relaxed and simply better schools overall.