One of my friends is a MS-1 at NYMC and he absolutlely loves it. But, he did tell me that they work very hard b/c most of the students didn't get into their other safety schools and want residencies in either NYC or CA. So, he studies all the time and it's practically forced on them by the administration to concentrate on their board scores. Also, he told me that while they do go out a lot, it's not as easy to get to the city as the schools says. (Many on SDN will complain about Einstein being out of the city and only having an express bus or subway, but think about having to take a bus to a train station and then waiting for a train that takes 50 minutes and only runs every hour.) He told me that many just go to bars in White Plains.
I got the same impression when I talked to students on my interview day. I'd ask them how they decided on NYMC and they'd say, "it was b/w there and MCP or they didn't get in anywhere else."
It was a really pretty school and if I wanted more of a medical school campus with trees in a suburb, I'd totally look into the school despite all of the negatives I experienced, but it really wasn't what I wanted in a school.