- Joined
- Feb 18, 2004
- Messages
- 100
- Reaction score
- 0
JPaikman said:The fact that the benefactor after which the NYU hospital is named, Tisch, is a major owner in a tobacco company, may have something to do with the loss in reputation of the hospital and its associated medical school, at least among physicians in New York.
JPaikman said:The fact that the benefactor after which the NYU hospital is named, Tisch, is a major owner in a tobacco company, may have something to do with the loss in reputation of the hospital and its associated medical school, at least among physicians in New York.
JPaikman said:The fact that the benefactor after which the NYU hospital is named, Tisch, is a major owner in a tobacco company, may have something to do with the loss in reputation of the hospital and its associated medical school, at least among physicians in New York.
BioMedResearch said:
FYI "Tisch," Robert Tisch not Preston Tisch, his brother, made his millions through his family's ownership of Loews Movie Theaters and Hotels as well as through some masterfully minded real estate ventures. The Tisch family has supported NYU for years with the Tisch College of Arts, School of Professional Education, and countless buildings downtown on NYUs main campus.
You have to be careful when spewing BS because the more you throw the more that will land on you.
scootad. said:As you know, rankings are heavily weighted towards NIH $$ which NYU seems to lack for some reason.
I wanna add that U of Chicago also fell in ranking over the years, just like NYU. However, U of Chicago still has strong reputation scores, and people in the academia (Notably biological sciences) certainly find U of Chicago to be a big name regardless of its drop in rankingjaycee said:I have a theory that, in an effort to market itself nationally, USNews has made an effort to rid its rankings of the appearance of an east coast bias. Top schools in the south and midwest have shot up over the past decade, displacing schools like NYU and Yale.
The irony of this year's NYU slip is that the administration was apparently very excited about the release of the rankings, as they were expecting a nice rise after two straight "best ever" match years and some targeted investments.
exmike said:I have a feeling that NYU will rise a bit next year using AMCAS. I wonder how much of the shift to AMCAS was BECAUSE of the USNews rankings (and knowing it would boost their selectivity score). Hm...
I wanna add that U of Chicago also fell in ranking over the years, just like NYU. However, U of Chicago still has strong reputation scores, and people in the academia (Notably biological sciences) certainly find U of Chicago to be a big name regardless of its drop in ranking
It's interesting cause I'm on the waitlist for both U Chicago and Northwestern, and some people told me not to bother because they're "not as good" as the school I already got into. However, in terms of reputation score, the three schools will be very similar.JD428 said:I think that UChicago is the ultimate example of the flaws in US News' rankings algorithm. The school is truly amazing, and other medical professionals recognize it as such (hence its high reputation scores).
Ironically, one of the things that makes the school so great is also what seems to most hurt it in the rankings: by making a committment to admit the "best students", not simply the students with the best scores, their selectivity rank falls (10.3 avg MCAT, pretty low for a top school). I don't know much about NYU, but it seems like their situation is reversed: high selectivity (b/c of desirable location in NYC), but relatively low reputation numbers.
I think the only part of the rankings worth paying attention to are the reputation scores (and the price tag...) - the other numbers, especially those related to selectivity, can be influenced by cynical admissions committies. I just wish I had recognized that last year when I was picking schools.
CalBeE said:It's interesting cause I'm on the waitlist for both U Chicago and Northwestern, and some people told me not to bother because they're "not as good" as the school I already got into. However, in terms of reputation score, the three schools will be very similar.
jaycee said:I have a theory that, in an effort to market itself nationally, USNews has made an effort to rid its rankings of the appearance of an east coast bias. Top schools in the south and midwest have shot up over the past decade, displacing schools like NYU and Yale.
The irony of this year's NYU slip is that the administration was apparently very excited about the release of the rankings, as they were expecting a nice rise after two straight "best ever" match years and some targeted investments.
JPaikman said:The fact that the benefactor after which the NYU hospital is named, Tisch, is a major owner in a tobacco company, may have something to do with the loss in reputation of the hospital and its associated medical school, at least among physicians in New York.
JPaikman said:The fact that the benefactor after which the NYU hospital is named, Tisch, is a major owner in a tobacco company, may have something to do with the loss in reputation of the hospital and its associated medical school, at least among physicians in New York.
elias514 said:Well, NYU's match list certainly does not correspond to its US News ranking. The match list this year is incredibly good.
I think it's worth the price.
Yea it's a regional thing, I think the people around me at UCLA who gave me the advice certainly has a California biasexmike said:Definitely a regional variation. I think UChic and NU probably have a better reputation in the great lakes region than UCLA. Which makes complete sense. UCLA IS a research powerhouse though, that cant be denied.
scootad. said:Its been more than 2 years. THey have had identical stats (3.70, 11.0) for at least 5 consecutive years.