Official Doctor Who WW Redux Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Can't decide if I want to let the (maybe trustworthy, maybe not) hint of a dead player swing my vote. Although it doesn't seem like there is anything else to go off of at this point in time. If there's no wolf in that group, the wolves are surely laughing at us! But for now, unless more information comes out, I'll lynch devyn
 
It appears that both (active) dead players have been throwing hints, though. Which is enough for me at this point.
That doesn't necessarily make them valid though, could just be a distraction meant to lead us astray
 
Official Lynch Tally

Lupin 1 - Wildcat
Dwin 0
Samoa 1 - FFM
Devyn 6 - TRH, FS, LIS, WS, FH, allie
Hedgie 1 - devyn
Cyndia 1 - FF
Wildcat 1 - Hedgie
Swings 1 - Dwin
cuit 1 - EC
WS 2 - dyachei, Samoa
EC 1 - SOV
Allie 1 - cuit
WTF 1 - Cyndia
TRH 1 - swings

19/23 votes. Roll call: @jdh71 @WhtsThFrequency @AlorsOnDanse @Lupin21

Deadline 8 PM EST
 
Last edited:
While I agree that it would have been stupid of the wolves to target someone who had role revealed in their group, and then immediately kill another group member, Dom's hint clearly points at someone in the group. And by both him and Chillbo suggesting a weeping angel, I'm guessing mods may have had a hand in creating their hints?

As for lynching Devyn, my gut is telling me she's a villager, based on how she tried to lynch dyachei in d2 after discovering she was inhuman from the sonic screwdriver. As I don't think she knows the show well, that suggests she received a human role, hence her quick assumption of dyachei being bad upon discovery of her being inhuman. And I buy devyn being sick/away due to the timezone (since I'm in the same timezone, and I haven't been able to stay awake for deadlines). Also the fact that people are bandwagoning on to her after dyachei mentioned she might not be able to defend herself, makes me suspicious of the people voting for her..

But back to focusing on the rest of the group since at least I think there's a reasonable hint pointing at them. As I'm ignoring devyn for now due to my instincts and till I hear a defense, that leaves SOV and dyachei of the original time group. However Doms hint specifically pointing at the group didn't go up until well after WTF was moved into the group... And since SOV and dya have both given semi believable aliases (and I have no idea if either is lying) lynch WTF for now. Would certainly be sneaky of the mods to give us a hint towards that group via a dead person, but wait till someone new had moved in! I'm not willing to put anything past escalla and rojo after the sneaky wording on voting in the beginning! 😛

This is total conjecture on my part after a quick reread of everything, so I may have missed stuff or made stupid conclusions, and I'll happily waffle if someone else has better ideas/evidence. I'm just leaving work and I've got friends over tonight so I'll be busy but I'll check in on my phone.
 
^ wolf up there can't even be bothered to watch the episode that would tell exactly who I am.

Which episoded would that be? (obviously you can PM it 😉 ) Or did I miss some obvious hint, somewhere?
 
The fact that Dyachei is so willing to go "eh, she's not around to defend herself" so casually, but hasn't voted for her yet, makes me uneasy. If Devyn took the time to PM Dyachei, and not write on the thread, wouldn't Devyn have taken the time to role reveal to her? Or would she really just say, "I'm in Paris, won't be on to defend myself"? Did Devyn actually role reveal to her and she's letting Devyn take the fall this lynch? I'm wondering if I voted for the wrong person.
 
While I agree that it would have been stupid of the wolves to target someone who had role revealed in their group, and then immediately kill another group member, Dom's hint clearly points at someone in the group. And by both him and Chillbo suggesting a weeping angel, I'm guessing mods may have had a hand in creating their hints?

As for lynching Devyn, my gut is telling me she's a villager, based on how she tried to lynch dyachei in d2 after discovering she was inhuman from the sonic screwdriver. As I don't think she knows the show well, that suggests she received a human role, hence her quick assumption of dyachei being bad upon discovery of her being inhuman. And I buy devyn being sick/away due to the timezone (since I'm in the same timezone, and I haven't been able to stay awake for deadlines). Also the fact that people are bandwagoning on to her after dyachei mentioned she might not be able to defend herself, makes me suspicious of the people voting for her..

But back to focusing on the rest of the group since at least I think there's a reasonable hint pointing at them. As I'm ignoring devyn for now due to my instincts and till I hear a defense, that leaves SOV and dyachei of the original time group. However Doms hint specifically pointing at the group didn't go up until well after WTF was moved into the group... And since SOV and dya have both given semi believable aliases (and I have no idea if either is lying) lynch WTF for now. Would certainly be sneaky of the mods to give us a hint towards that group via a dead person, but wait till someone new had moved in! I'm not willing to put anything past escalla and rojo after the sneaky wording on voting in the beginning! 😛

This is total conjecture on my part after a quick reread of everything, so I may have missed stuff or made stupid conclusions, and I'll happily waffle if someone else has better ideas/evidence. I'm just leaving work and I've got friends over tonight so I'll be busy but I'll check in on my phone.
No, devyn is quite conversant with the show. I can tell because she was the only one who laughed at my first post. Which is entirely an inside-Whoniverse joke.
 
While I agree that it would have been stupid of the wolves to target someone who had role revealed in their group, and then immediately kill another group member, Dom's hint clearly points at someone in the group. And by both him and Chillbo suggesting a weeping angel, I'm guessing mods may have had a hand in creating their hints?

What post # was this? He posted something about the Weeping Angels but I don't recall this?
 
The fact that Dyachei is so willing to go "eh, she's not around to defend herself" so casually, but hasn't voted for her yet, makes me uneasy. If Devyn took the time to PM Dyachei, and not write on the thread, wouldn't Devyn have taken the time to role reveal to her? Or would she really just say, "I'm in Paris, won't be on to defend myself"? Did Devyn actually role reveal to her and she's letting Devyn take the fall this lynch? I'm wondering if I voted for the wrong person.
She PMed me on FB early morning before I woke up. Not through sdn
 
If Devyn took the time to PM Dyachei, and not write on the thread, wouldn't Devyn have taken the time to role reveal to her? Or would she really just say, "I'm in Paris, won't be on to defend myself"? Did Devyn actually role reveal to her and she's letting Devyn take the fall this lynch? I'm wondering if I voted for the wrong person.

If devyn did indeed not given any further information to dyachei with which to offer a defense, that's suspicious in my mind. It essentially leads us all to say, "Okay, we'll wait til Devyn can post and defend herself" giving her more time to cook up an alibi. By the time she's able to come on, we'd likely be on some other goose chase and over look her longer, anyway.

And yeah, maybe the dead people stuff isn't worth anything but it's pretty much the only clue we've got to go off so far.
 
While I agree that it would have been stupid of the wolves to target someone who had role revealed in their group, and then immediately kill another group member, Dom's hint clearly points at someone in the group. And by both him and Chillbo suggesting a weeping angel, I'm guessing mods may have had a hand in creating their hints?

As for lynching Devyn, my gut is telling me she's a villager, based on how she tried to lynch dyachei in d2 after discovering she was inhuman from the sonic screwdriver. As I don't think she knows the show well, that suggests she received a human role, hence her quick assumption of dyachei being bad upon discovery of her being inhuman. And I buy devyn being sick/away due to the timezone (since I'm in the same timezone, and I haven't been able to stay awake for deadlines). Also the fact that people are bandwagoning on to her after dyachei mentioned she might not be able to defend herself, makes me suspicious of the people voting for her..

But back to focusing on the rest of the group since at least I think there's a reasonable hint pointing at them. As I'm ignoring devyn for now due to my instincts and till I hear a defense, that leaves SOV and dyachei of the original time group. However Doms hint specifically pointing at the group didn't go up until well after WTF was moved into the group... And since SOV and dya have both given semi believable aliases (and I have no idea if either is lying) lynch WTF for now. Would certainly be sneaky of the mods to give us a hint towards that group via a dead person, but wait till someone new had moved in! I'm not willing to put anything past escalla and rojo after the sneaky wording on voting in the beginning! 😛

This is total conjecture on my part after a quick reread of everything, so I may have missed stuff or made stupid conclusions, and I'll happily waffle if someone else has better ideas/evidence. I'm just leaving work and I've got friends over tonight so I'll be busy but I'll check in on my phone.


Dom died the same night WTF moved. So, of course he would drop phrases after she had moved.

It could also be that the Mods gave Dom some info and he is reading it wrong. There is always that chance. But, right now, I'm willing to take the word of both
 
If Devyn took the time to PM Dyachei, and not write on the thread, wouldn't Devyn have taken the time to role reveal to her? Or would she really just say, "I'm in Paris, won't be on to defend myself"? Did Devyn actually role reveal to her and she's letting Devyn take the fall this lynch? I'm wondering if I voted for the wrong person.

If devyn did indeed not given any further information to dyachei with which to offer a defense, that's suspicious in my mind. It essentially leads us all to say, "Okay, we'll wait til Devyn can post and defend herself" giving her more time to cook up an alibi. By the time she's able to come on, we'd likely be on some other goose chase and over look her longer, anyway.

And yeah, maybe the dead people stuff isn't worth anything but it's pretty much the only clue we've got to go off so far.
 
Final Lynch Tally

Lupin 1 - Wildcat
Dwin 0
Samoa 1 - FFM
Devyn 7 - TRH, FS, LIS, WS, FH, allie, Samoa
Hedgie 1 - devyn
Cyndia 1 - FF
Wildcat 1 - Hedgie
Swings 1 - Dwin
cuit 1 - EC
WS 2 - dyachei, Samoa
EC 1 - SOV
Allie 1 - cuit
WTF 1 - Cyndia
TRH 1 - swings

LIS Rule has been suspended, so if you didn't get a vote in, don't worry.
 
She PMed me on FB early morning before I woke up. Not through sdn

Ohhh, well you didn't say that. Just "pm'd me". Of course I assumed through SDN.

WS is doing her best to convince me to keep my vote with her, I seesee

How so? I actually am curious to know. Did Devyn PM you her role, or not? Do you believe it or not?
 
What post # was this? He posted something about the Weeping Angels but I don't recall this?

Just tried scrolling through but can't find it on my phone. It was his last post that was bolder and starred, he said something about evil lurks in his time? Along with a don't blink reference to the angels.
 
She didn't tell me the details of her role just that she couldn't defend herself. At the time, she was not the vote leader.

You adamantly believing that makes her a wolf makes you suspicious to me
 
She didn't tell me the details of her role just that she couldn't defend herself. At the time, she was not the vote leader.

You adamantly believing that makes her a wolf makes you suspicious to me

It's either you or Devyn. Are you saying the wolf is you, then? And in that post you quoted, I was saying if Devyn had role revealed to you and you were letting her rack up votes, that made me more suspicious of YOU. Not Deyvn.
 
It's either you or Devyn. Are you saying the wolf is you, then? And in that post you quoted, I was saying if Devyn had role revealed to you and you were letting her rack up votes, that made me more suspicious of YOU. Not Deyvn.
Umm there are other people in our time. And I've already role revealed. Drugs must be a little strong for you
 
If Dyachei turns out to be a wolf, I'm going to grumble at whoever closed lynch early. I was going to waffle! If you saved me from waffling to the wrong person, then thank you!
 
This is the ONLY Dr Who in my humble opinion.

And I had him first!!
**********
I went with him because of this gif that I've laughed heartily to.

tom-baker-i-can-fap-to-this.gif


**********
 
Umm there are other people in our time. And I've already role revealed. Drugs must be a little strong for you

Not currently on drugs, but thanks! I believe SOV is who he says he is. You, I don't. And I don't know who Devyn is. And WTF isn't in the equation.
 
After continued mass confusion and chaos surrounding the 1940s....a leader has emerged in votes.

"Devyn is in Paris! She cannot defend herself right now!" dyachei exclaims.

But that is not enough...the dead have been up to something, right? What the heck is going on with them anyway?

No matter, lynch has been been closed abruptly.

You have sentenced devyn, aka Donna Noble, companion to the Doctor, to death. It's unfortunate that she will no longer be able to snoop around.



It is now Night 3. Deadline is currently set for 8 PM EST. If actions are received earlier, we will close.

Roster:
1940s Europe
1. @dyachei
2. @Chillbo Baggins Novice Hame
3. @devyn Donna Noble
4. @Domenic Adolf Hitler
5. @fancymylotus Winston Churchill

5b. @StartingoverVet
12. @WhtsThFrequency

1870s-1890s
6. @wolfspeaker
7. @hedgiehog
8. @FantasyFlyer
9. @jdh71
10. @Samoa

Present Day
11. @Foxhunter
13. @Flim Flam Man
14. @LetItSnow
15. @Dwindlin
17. @allieh8607

Sometime in the Future
16. @Cyndia
18. @equineconstant
19. @swingnsave
20. @AlorsOnDanse

The End of the Universe
21. @Frozenshades
22. @wildcatj
23. @cuitlamiztli
24. @Lupin21
25. @that redhead
 
I figured as much with an early lynch close.

So....does anyone think that perhaps Dom just wants us to kill off that group because he's....well...Hitler? And went around wanting to kill a bunch of shyte in the 1940s?

Because I dunno about SOV but I'm pretty sure dyachei ain't wolfy.
 
I assume whoever closed early knew devyn wasn't a wolf and wanted to catch us before we could waffle off.

I feel pretty certain that dom was not a wolf despite his sketchy name. I don't think it's dyachei or SOV, frankly, although if I had to choose I'd go for dyachei over SOV. There is also you in that group, and if we want to assume that everyone in that group wouldn't lynch those who role-revealed, you'd fit the bill pretty well.
 
😡 to whomever closed lynch early.

I assume whoever closed early knew devyn wasn't a wolf and wanted to catch us before we could waffle off.

I feel pretty certain that dom was not a wolf despite his sketchy name. I don't think it's dyachei or SOV, frankly, although if I had to choose I'd go for dyachei over SOV. There is also you in that group, and if we want to assume that everyone in that group wouldn't lynch those who role-revealed, you'd fit the bill pretty well.

Who is the "you" referring to? WTF? She wasn't part of the group originally.


I figured as much with an early lynch close.

So....does anyone think that perhaps Dom just wants us to kill off that group because he's....well...Hitler? And went around wanting to kill a bunch of shyte in the 1940s?

Because I dunno about SOV but I'm pretty sure dyachei ain't wolfy.

Chillbo was dropping phrases about there being Weeping Angels and then Dom said there was evil in "his time". Which makes me think one of them in that group is a Weeping Angel.

How certain are you of Dyachei not being a wolf? Or is it just a feeling because she said she was Ood?
 
Top