Random said:
Okay, here it is: Upstate has a rather traditional curriculum and everything that means. In other words, one of the major problems is that the required clinical experience in the first two years is relatively small so people don't have many reminders why they're here. In the clinical years (and this is from what I hear - I'm not there yet), the biggest problem is that people aren't as free to play an active role in the treatment team, mainly in terms of doing procedures. I know they're trying to fix this so that people have much more hands-on experience during their clerkships but that'll probably take a couple of years. This also tends to be less of a problem at Binghamton since there are less residents wanting to do procedures than in Syracuse. The facilities are in the process of going through a major upgrade for the first time since University hospital was built in the 1960s. The renovations should be largely done by the time the class of 2010 goes into their clerkships but it's occasionally an issue now.
What I will say is basically that the faculty and administration know what problems they have and are taking affirmative steps to fix the problems. Since we have a number of good professors and a fairly laid back atmosphere, there is a lot to like about this place but it's not for everyone.
Hope this helps. Good luck with your decisions.
**********************************
The following is an excerpt from an email sent to the entire class of 2008. I tried to help you guys, but of course, no one listens to me. Enjoy vermont, suckers.
***********************************
Hi Class,
I know you are all busy studying and this email probably will not solve
anything, but it is something that has been bothering me and severely
affecting several of our classmates. I just was wondering if anyone had any
ideas or thinks there is a way that we could possibly make a difference.
As a lot of you are aware, the class of 2008 broke a record in the number of
students who failed pharmacology. The grand total is 12. Five of those 12
will be taking the shelf exam on the 30th (you had to be within a few points
of passing to have this as an option) and the remaining 7 (or 8...Dr. Grassl
said 7, but students that are in this position said 8) are required to go to
Vermont, accompanied by anyone who does not pass the shelf. The consequeces
of either procedure affects when these students can take the USMLEs, when
these students will start their third year clerkships, and expenses of
approximately $2500 for the class, room, and board if Vermont is in the
future. This does not include the psychological strain that has been placed
on these students during this already stressful time. I would also like to
point out that at least TWO of the students taking the shelf have grades of
69.3% and needed only ONE more question correct to not be in this situation.
Now, an almost 10% failure rate seems a little on the high side and it's
really hard for me to sit back and watch our classmates suffer. This
morning I ran into Dr. Grassl and causually mentioned this and his response
was that "Dr. Jalife and the pharmacology department pride themselves on
these high standards, unlike some of the other departments." It is
respectable to have high standards for your students, and if material is not
mastered remediation is necessary, but when such a high percentage of
students do not meet these expectations perhaps the system has failed these
students and not the other way around. I could very easily see myself in
their situation if I had guessed wrong on a few more questions this year,
and I think a lot of students would agree that the pharm tests didn't always
test our knowledge of pharmacology.
I don't know if there is a way to change what has been determined, but I
really feel that the pharm department should either provide support here at
Upstate for these students or accomadate them otherwise. If your standards
are high your teaching should be just as high and there is an obvious
discordance here.
Thank you for listening and if anyone has ideas if there is something we can
do as a class that wouldn't get us all expelled, please feel free to share.
We've written letters as a group before to get someplace...do you think this
is another time to give that a try?
********************************