one more question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

silver_eyes

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2001
Messages
506
Reaction score
1
hi guys,
one more question. i was surfing the net at www.medicalschoool.com and i came up on this,
This means that approximately 2/3 of the entering class had a GPA of between 3.22 and 3.90. I have always been a proponent of challenging oneself. I always take classes beyond my reach, struggle a bit, but in the end learn a lot more than I would have taking an easier class. Of course, in these situations my grades suffer more often than not. While if I had to do it all over again, I would still do it this way, realize this: medical schools would rather see great grades in easy classes than good grades in harder ones. That is the sad reality of medical school admissions. Grades are used to determine GPA, and this is one of the only concrete rankings, so medical schools use them. They have no idea what the difference between Physics 160 and Physics 1 is, or what makes Bio 225 so different from Bio 11 at your school. But, they do know that an A is better than a B. Medical schools are not going to try and weigh if Bob's B in graduate level physics indicates a better student than Bill's A in physics for lobotomized mice. retrieved from http://medicalschool.com/Premedclasses.htm

is that true?

thanks again guys!:clap:
 
Well, from what I've read, it actually depends upon the reputation of your undergrad school, but for the most part, it is true. But, then again, I'd stay on the safe side...if your school isn't as well-known, then I'd take physics-major class instead of GE Physics 101. On the other hand, if you go to say, Harvard, then I'd think that the school's rep would allow one to pull off the GE class.

Anybody else got any suggestions?
 
no no..not physics...classes in general. i go to the univeristy of the pacific, in sotckton, ca. www.uop.edu
 
I would say that reputation may be the key as well but for a different reason. A school like Harvard sends a ton of students to the top medical schools every year. Every year each school gets a ton of applications from Harvard. So they have a pretty good idea of what courses the more ambitious premed takes, and what the bare minimum is. I would imagine they could scan a harvard transcript with a "lower" gpa and be able to tell pretty quickly whether the lower grades were due to an inability to compete with harvard premeds or a really tough course load.
This is specifically why many schools have "regional based adcoms" who review all the students from a specific school together to make an accurate comparison.

I would imagine that the above statement is more true when the school isn't as well known. It would be difficult for the school to know what is hard and what is not because they simply don't see that many applicants from that school and don't know the school's curriculum that well and what the different numbers might mean. If I see Physics 160 and I am the admissions person, unless in the title it specifically says advanced or graduate or whatever, it would be pretty hard to know whether that was the easiest physics course you could take or the hardest.


anyone agree/disagree?
 
This really depends. I think if you go to a no-name state school med schools might want to see more of the upper division classes. But I'm just guessing here.

Upper division and honors classes aren't always harder either. In a lot of my upper division classes there was a lot more oppertunity to get extra points with class participation or extra homework assignments. You got a lot more personal attention... and were usually taught by full professors (not TAs). In most of those big lecture classes... you just have a few big tests and that's it.
 
I got into several great med schools with good (not great) grades in hard (graduate) science courses that I took as an undergrad combined with great grades in humanities courses.

I think undergrad reputation matters also - I went to a college that is well-known in the medical community for its rigor.

Cheers,
doepug
 
Top