I took the PCAT in October for the first time after taking the Kaplan study course. I am a recent graduate so I took organic/inorganic and calculus 4 years ago and needed a refresher. The Kaplan course was pretty good; the best part was the 3 practice exams. I scored <70 on the first two and >80 on the final. My overall goal was to score a composite around 80. I felt that this was a reachable goal since I could do very well on Biology, Writing, Reading Comp, and Verbal. I knew I would not do so well on Chem and Math since I took the courses so long ago.
Test day: I felt I performed as well on my Kaplan final (the >80 score). The chem was what I expected (hard) and the math was extremely difficult. I felt that I did well on the other sections (verbal was my strongest, followed by Bio). Overall, I felt that I may have scored an 80 composite.
Scores Arrive: Well, I was very close to the 80s composite goal... 78. I did not score below a 60 on any section, which made me very happy. The ONLY section score that I was upset about was the verbal score (78). On all 3 Kaplan exams, I scored >90. If my verbal score on the actual PCAT had been 80-90, I would have met my goal or even exceeded it.
Assessment: I decided not to take the January PCAT because I work full time and have to take some more prereqs. I feel that if I had more time and studied chem and math some more, I could def. improve my score. However, I feel that I have good stats to outshine my "average but competitive" PCAT score.
Just remember, the PCAT score is not the most important aspect of your application. It shows aptitude and understanding, but it cannot show professionalism, experience, and work ethic.