Dr. Jeff, the fact that GPR's allow their residents to take children to the O.R. is absolutely WRONG ! ! ! ! In a GPR you will spend a short amount of time in the O.R. compared to a Pedo. resident...AND No matter what your state allows you to do... A GP SHOULD NEVER EVER TAKE A CHILD TO THE O.R. If anything were to happen that GP would not have a leg to stand on. Same thing goes for GP's sedating kids. Not that I have an attitude, but If a GP could do Pedo. as well as I, then what the heck AM I doing????? The fact that you have taken children to the O.R. saddens me......You have a limited knowledge base of Pedo. to draw from and you may have done those children a disservice by not referring them. How do you know your treatment is up to the standard of care ??? Are you a member of the AAPD ? Do you go to the annual meetings ?? The continuing education on Pedo. in the GP circuit is very very limited. GP's must see kids....I agree with that. There are not enough Pedo. out there, but under no circumstances should a GP take a child to the O.R. nor should they sedate them. The Pedo. experience at most dental schools is poor at best, and the amount of Pedo. experience you gain from a GPR is minute. Lastly, I am curious where people get the idea that Pedo. is a referral based specialty. Pedo. should be viewed as a service. I do not need ANY referrals. IN FACT ! GP referrals are the worst. GP's usually NEVER refer "good" patients, GP's usually Bill for an Exam on the patient, then the GP takes X-rays and charges for them even though they are not of diagnostic quality, does the prophy and then decides they don't want to do the restorative and they refer the child out leaving the pedo. with nothing to bill for. So, we do the exam for free, re-take the x-rays FOR FREE !!!! There is a waiting list at both of my offices of 4 plus months.. I do not need referrals. I am not trying to upset anyone or take an arrogant attitude, but I have yet to see a GP do Pedo. as good or better than I. AND THIS IS AS IT SHOULD BE....I would not try to do veneers, or RPD's or even Endo. cuz I don't do that day in day out and there are plenty of GP's or specialists to refer that to, but PEDO. is what I do EVERYDAY. If I need a crown done or a Root Canal you can bet I will be seeing a GP or Endo. Most GP's are excellent dentists, but they are not specialty trained in any one facet. Same as GPR trained GP's...they just tend to be more complete GP's. Again, You are correct in that a few GP's that did GPR's can obtain privileges at hospitals, but why does a GP need privileges at a hospital. They should never take kids to the O.R. So, maybe they will take their adult CP patients, or adult Down's patients, etc. to the O.R., but again Pedo. covers the disabled and handicapped. So why does a GP need hosp. privileges and Especially why do you need privileges at so many hosp. I can't imagine that you go to the O.R. so much that you would need to be credentialed at so many places. How much primary pulp research did you do in your GPR ?? Can you describe the dynamics of the systemic distribution of Formocresol ??? The differences and success rates of Formocresol pulpotomies vs. ferric sulfate vs. CaOH2 vs. laser vs. electrofulguration etc. etc. when to do a pulp. vs. IPC. What is the actual mechanism of CaOH2 ? What happens under the layer of coagulation necrosis in a DPC after application of CaOH2 ?? How long is too long to do a Cvek pulp. after a traumatic exposure on a perm. tooth. What should be done to a primary tooth with internal resorp. What is anachoresis ?? When to do serial extraction ? When does canine to canine width stop increasing ? etc. etc. Hopefully, the only children you treated in the O.R. were the ones during your residency while you were under the supervision of a faculty member (hopefully trained in Pedo.) It would amaze me if you have taken kids to the O.R. on your own. I would never attempt something on another person's child that I was not absolutely 100% confident and FULLY and COMPLETELY trained to do. The fact that you would take a risk with another person's child staggers me. I have nothing against GP's, but I see their work day in day out. I REPLACE their work DAY IN DAY OUT. Pedo experience in most dental schools is like ortho. ya just don't get enough !!!! GP's try their best, but they don't know enough. Most are wise enough to refer, but others don't. Who has done the disservice when the child comes to me and I have to work on a "baby" tooth for a SECOND time, because someone did not do the proper treatment, or I open up a pulp to find that the GP has left the formo pellet in the primary tooth. Enough of me being a LOUD MOUTH (no pun intended). I have opinions just like everyone else. If you took offense to what I said that was not my intent. I wasn't aiming to offend anyone, but to let the people on the thread know why Pedo. exists, and that contrary to what their experience was like in dental school....Most Pedo. residents gain more medical expertise than GP's, even GPR trained GP's. I was also letting them know that treating kids is not just treating little adults, etc. etc. Primary teeth are different than adult teeth in many more ways than many GP's realize. Perhaps, I have been less candid on this subject, but I am not trying to cop an attitude, or demean GP's in ANY WAY!!!! I have great respect for GP's ESPECIALLY those that do truly practice everything.