Hi all, hope the application season is going well! I have a question that I thought would be better posted here than GradCafe since there are way more people here who are involved in the application process from the inside. Hoping to get some insight (if any is possible) and I apologize for the long post!
I applied last cycle for the first time, and received two interview invites. One of the places I interviewed at was a virtual perfect fit for my interests and experience, and even had a research connection with someone who had worked with one of my POIs at the school, who put in a good word for me. I interviewed for two PIs at this program. I felt that the interview went extremely well and got a call a few weeks later from one of the PIs (who was also the DCT) saying that I was their top choice, but ultimately they was not able to take on a new student because a grant they were waiting to hear back about didn't end up getting funded.
I applied again this year after strengthening my application (had no pubs last year, this year I have 2 first author and one 2nd author, with a couple more in prep/under review; more poster presentations, and an independent research project underway). I reached out to both PIs of interest at this program again and got a very positive response from one (albeit, the one who said I was their "top choice" last year didn't respond at all...) However, interview invites for this program went out yesterday and I did not receive one. I haven't received a formal rejection yet, but it seems pretty final.
My question is - what would be the reasons I haven't been invited back this year? This is a dream program for me and I'm trying to rationalize but I'm just at a loss as to why they are no longer interested in my application despite it being objectively stronger than last year. Any insight would be really appreciated.