Search
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Menu
Forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Search forums
Members
Articles
Interviews
Professions
Rehab Sciences
Dental
Medical
Pharmacy
Podiatry
Optometry
Psychology
Veterinary
Resources
Interview Feedback
Essay Workshop
Application Cost Calculator
MD Applicants
DDS Applicants
LizzyM Application Assistant
Moonlighting.org
About
About the Ads
Our History
How We Moderate
Vision, Values and Policies
Support for Black Lives Matter
Log in
Register
Search
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Forums
Popular Categories
Pre-medical
Medical Student
Dental (DDS/DMD)
Optometry
Pharmacy
Physical Therapy
Other Links
Members
New posts
trending
Search forums
Support SDN
Donate
Contact us
Main Links
Forums
Articles
Interviews
Professions
Fields
Dental
Medical
Optometry
Pharmacy
Podiatry
Psychology
Rehab Sciences
Veterinary
Support SDN
Donate
Contact us
Main Links
Forums
Articles
Interviews
Resources
Applicants
MD Applicants
DDS Applicants
LizzyM Application Assistant
Application Cost Calculator
Essay Workshop
Interview Feedback
SDN Wiki
Other Resources
Glossary
Medical Specialty Selector
Scutwork
StudySchedule
Review2
Support SDN
Donate
Contact us
Main Links
Forums
Articles
Interviews
About
Organization
Our History
Vision, Values and Policies
How We Moderate
Newsroom
About the Ads
Help
Support Us
Become a Partner
Sponsor SDN
Donate to SDN
Writing for SDN
Support SDN
Donate
Contact us
Main Links
Forums
Articles
Interviews
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Search forums
Members
Forums
Psychology Forums
Psychology [Psy.D. / Ph.D.]
Psychotherapy - How are you taught to "ask questions"?
Reply to thread
Search
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Search engine:
XenForo Search
Threadloom Search
Search titles only
By:
Install the app
Install
Hi Guest, check out the latest SDN article:
Let’s Talk About Your
Financial
Health
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Message
<blockquote data-quote="ClinicalTrainee" data-source="post: 8467205" data-attributes="member: 270904"><p>I think the process of learning to do clinical interviews and learning to do therapy are a bit different, though clearly related.</p><p></p><p>My university has an applied track for undergraduates headed toward the helping professions, and as such, we have an interviewing class for upper level undergraduates. I taught the class last year, and as part of the course the students had to interview subject pool students and write up what they learned and their process in a final paper. (Clearly, these were not real clinical interviews, as the population was primarily not a clinical population).</p><p></p><p>The question was about how we are taught to do clinical interviews, and as is clear from other responses, it varies across training programs. But some of the main skills are learning attending behaviors (non-verbals), different types of questions (open-ended, leading, etc) and how these types may elicit different responses, and how to reflect/paraphrase, both content and feeling.</p><p></p><p>A good intake clinician also needs to have a solid understanding of diagnosis and what content areas are important for a comprehensive understanding of the client and his/her issues. The above skills are to help facilitate information gathering and to help build the theraputic alliance.</p><p></p><p>The original poster said "After you have the understanding of psychology down, how exactly do you know what to ask the patient to get them where you want them to be?" The answer is.....I don't believe that anyone alive has psychology "down" because there is so much that we don't yet know, and everyone is different. Second, I also don't think you can ever *know* exactly what to ask the patient to get them where you want them to be. There have been moments when I've asked a question I thought was brilliant and received a vapid response, and other times I've said things without hardly thinking and seen a thoughtful change-producing response. There are studies that show discrepancies between what clients think is important compared to what therapists think. I find this work fascinating!</p><p></p><p>Basically, I feel that interviewing/therapy skills are taught by didactic instruction, by modeling (older students, supervisors, videos), through direct feedback (supervision) and through experience. The last two have been especially valuable for me, though I think many supervisors could use some lessons in how to give useful, constructive feedback. I still think I've learned the most from trusting myself and my training, and using my own internal barometer to realize when something I said didn't go over as planned. Self-awareness is, in my opinion, probably the most critical skill needed to be a good clinician.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="ClinicalTrainee, post: 8467205, member: 270904"] I think the process of learning to do clinical interviews and learning to do therapy are a bit different, though clearly related. My university has an applied track for undergraduates headed toward the helping professions, and as such, we have an interviewing class for upper level undergraduates. I taught the class last year, and as part of the course the students had to interview subject pool students and write up what they learned and their process in a final paper. (Clearly, these were not real clinical interviews, as the population was primarily not a clinical population). The question was about how we are taught to do clinical interviews, and as is clear from other responses, it varies across training programs. But some of the main skills are learning attending behaviors (non-verbals), different types of questions (open-ended, leading, etc) and how these types may elicit different responses, and how to reflect/paraphrase, both content and feeling. A good intake clinician also needs to have a solid understanding of diagnosis and what content areas are important for a comprehensive understanding of the client and his/her issues. The above skills are to help facilitate information gathering and to help build the theraputic alliance. The original poster said "After you have the understanding of psychology down, how exactly do you know what to ask the patient to get them where you want them to be?" The answer is.....I don't believe that anyone alive has psychology "down" because there is so much that we don't yet know, and everyone is different. Second, I also don't think you can ever *know* exactly what to ask the patient to get them where you want them to be. There have been moments when I've asked a question I thought was brilliant and received a vapid response, and other times I've said things without hardly thinking and seen a thoughtful change-producing response. There are studies that show discrepancies between what clients think is important compared to what therapists think. I find this work fascinating! Basically, I feel that interviewing/therapy skills are taught by didactic instruction, by modeling (older students, supervisors, videos), through direct feedback (supervision) and through experience. The last two have been especially valuable for me, though I think many supervisors could use some lessons in how to give useful, constructive feedback. I still think I've learned the most from trusting myself and my training, and using my own internal barometer to realize when something I said didn't go over as planned. Self-awareness is, in my opinion, probably the most critical skill needed to be a good clinician. [/QUOTE]
This thread is more than 11 years old.
Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:
Your new thread title is very short, and likely is unhelpful.
Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread.
Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread.
It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose.
Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers.
Your reply has occurred very quickly after a previous reply and likely does not add anything to the thread.
This thread is locked.
Insert quotes…
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Psychology Forums
Psychology [Psy.D. / Ph.D.]
Psychotherapy - How are you taught to "ask questions"?
Top
Bottom