D
deleted647690
I got this answer correct, but I'm not sure why C isn't also correct. Here is my reasoning for each option.
A was wrong because if you increase the input of fluid, it will increase the hydrostatic pressure in the dialysis chamber, thus increasing outflow.
D was wrong because if there is increased pressure in the dialysis unit, there will be higher pressure pushing against the walls, thus there will be more fluid flow out into the drainage pipe, carrying toxins and thus filtering to a greater extent
I figured B was the answer, because if hydrostatic pressure in the dialysis chamber is increased, and more fluid volume is flowing out into the drainage pipe/dialysate fluid pipe (see figure), that will decrease the concentration of proteins because the amount of solute is remaining the same while the amount of solvent is increasing. Thus B is the option that is not true.
For C, wouldn't the concentration of proteins in the outflow decrease due to the fact that A is true? If there is higher fluid outflow, that would decrease the concentration of proteins, thus, why isn't C also correct?
Their reasoning for why C wasn't the option was that proteins are too large to pass through the membrane, and thus the osmotic concentration wouldn't change. But still, wouldn't the increased fluid volume passing into the outflow still decrease the osmotic concentration, even if the amount of protein isn't changing? The amount of solvent is changing, thus the concentration should change in my opinion.
A was wrong because if you increase the input of fluid, it will increase the hydrostatic pressure in the dialysis chamber, thus increasing outflow.
D was wrong because if there is increased pressure in the dialysis unit, there will be higher pressure pushing against the walls, thus there will be more fluid flow out into the drainage pipe, carrying toxins and thus filtering to a greater extent
I figured B was the answer, because if hydrostatic pressure in the dialysis chamber is increased, and more fluid volume is flowing out into the drainage pipe/dialysate fluid pipe (see figure), that will decrease the concentration of proteins because the amount of solute is remaining the same while the amount of solvent is increasing. Thus B is the option that is not true.
For C, wouldn't the concentration of proteins in the outflow decrease due to the fact that A is true? If there is higher fluid outflow, that would decrease the concentration of proteins, thus, why isn't C also correct?
Their reasoning for why C wasn't the option was that proteins are too large to pass through the membrane, and thus the osmotic concentration wouldn't change. But still, wouldn't the increased fluid volume passing into the outflow still decrease the osmotic concentration, even if the amount of protein isn't changing? The amount of solvent is changing, thus the concentration should change in my opinion.