Hi Everyone,
Well, application season is almost here and I have a few questions regarding Psychiatry overall. First of all, I am a 4th year DO student who only took COMLEX and scored a 500+ on the Level 1. I also took the Level 2 and am awaiting my scores. I know not taking the USMLE is a detractor on my application but seeing as that Psychiatry is not yet too competitive I hope I still have opportunities to be accepted into a good University program. I remember Splik mentioning in one thread that the nature of Psychiatry makes it so that in most programs residents can become competent and, dare I say it, even superb Psychiatrists provided they are motivated to seek out and fill the gaps in their education. Conversely, I remember in another of his postings, he remarked that most psychiatry residencies are horrible. So, which is true?
The most important factor for me in the residency search would be a supportive faculty, PD, and co-residents in a friendly environment where there is a lot of input on training, constructive criticism, and support for motivated, hard-working individuals. I want to absolutely avoid a malignant atmosphere and avoid any programs that terminate residents(the thread by koikisi really frightened me). The next most important aspects are good training at a university program with a wide breadth and depth of exposure to all aspects of Psychiatry. Although I don't have much of a research background, I would like to have some research experience during residency. Ideally I would like to stay in the northeast near a major city(NYC, Boston, Philadelphia, D.C.) but will be applying all over the country and am not completely opposed to moving. Are there any such programs that fit my criteria(most importantly having a benign, supportive atmosphere) in the northeast that would accept someone with my stats?
I actually was able to speak with the PD of a program at length about applying and I was informed to include my MCAT and SAT scores(both of which were high), after he heard what they were, on my application to that particular program. This seems like it would be a faux pas to me but he stated that the scores would help give me leverage since I did not take the USMLE. His tone was not facetious when he mentioned this to me. What does everyone here think?
Lastly, I wanted to ask about the practice of Psychiatry in general. It seems there have been numerous comments on this forum about how bad psychiatrists out in the community put patients on random drug cocktails and such with nary a thought and how others like yourselves have to fix the poor job bad psychiatrists have done. However, I remember there was a comment on how it's not that there are just all these lazy psychiatrists happy to be doing the bare minimum and not caring about their patients enough so they put them on whatever drugs they please, but that the practice of Psychiatry itself is so varied and problematic at times that there are no 'real' rules so that what one Psychiatrist may think is a good treatment or drug regimen, another would see as egregiously wrong or piss-poor work. That can't be true, right? How do I make sure that I become a great Psychiatrist and not a bad one?
I appreciate the time you took to reading and any and all advice that comes my way regarding these topics! Thanks!
Well, application season is almost here and I have a few questions regarding Psychiatry overall. First of all, I am a 4th year DO student who only took COMLEX and scored a 500+ on the Level 1. I also took the Level 2 and am awaiting my scores. I know not taking the USMLE is a detractor on my application but seeing as that Psychiatry is not yet too competitive I hope I still have opportunities to be accepted into a good University program. I remember Splik mentioning in one thread that the nature of Psychiatry makes it so that in most programs residents can become competent and, dare I say it, even superb Psychiatrists provided they are motivated to seek out and fill the gaps in their education. Conversely, I remember in another of his postings, he remarked that most psychiatry residencies are horrible. So, which is true?
The most important factor for me in the residency search would be a supportive faculty, PD, and co-residents in a friendly environment where there is a lot of input on training, constructive criticism, and support for motivated, hard-working individuals. I want to absolutely avoid a malignant atmosphere and avoid any programs that terminate residents(the thread by koikisi really frightened me). The next most important aspects are good training at a university program with a wide breadth and depth of exposure to all aspects of Psychiatry. Although I don't have much of a research background, I would like to have some research experience during residency. Ideally I would like to stay in the northeast near a major city(NYC, Boston, Philadelphia, D.C.) but will be applying all over the country and am not completely opposed to moving. Are there any such programs that fit my criteria(most importantly having a benign, supportive atmosphere) in the northeast that would accept someone with my stats?
I actually was able to speak with the PD of a program at length about applying and I was informed to include my MCAT and SAT scores(both of which were high), after he heard what they were, on my application to that particular program. This seems like it would be a faux pas to me but he stated that the scores would help give me leverage since I did not take the USMLE. His tone was not facetious when he mentioned this to me. What does everyone here think?
Lastly, I wanted to ask about the practice of Psychiatry in general. It seems there have been numerous comments on this forum about how bad psychiatrists out in the community put patients on random drug cocktails and such with nary a thought and how others like yourselves have to fix the poor job bad psychiatrists have done. However, I remember there was a comment on how it's not that there are just all these lazy psychiatrists happy to be doing the bare minimum and not caring about their patients enough so they put them on whatever drugs they please, but that the practice of Psychiatry itself is so varied and problematic at times that there are no 'real' rules so that what one Psychiatrist may think is a good treatment or drug regimen, another would see as egregiously wrong or piss-poor work. That can't be true, right? How do I make sure that I become a great Psychiatrist and not a bad one?
I appreciate the time you took to reading and any and all advice that comes my way regarding these topics! Thanks!
Last edited: