Jul 30, 2017
3
1
Status
  1. Pre-Medical
Hello,

So I just finished my mcat and got my scores a few weeks ago. Not so great.. this is my second time taking it, last year 484 (yes I know, horrible, took the worst approach), this year 496 (125,121,126,124) :/ My grades went from a sGPA (Bioengineering) of 2.8 after freshmen year to now a 3.673, so good upward trend and in the ballpark now. Just graduated a few months ago. EC: Very solid, done many hours of volunteer/clinic work, co-facilitate support groups, tutor in math, scribe, crisis counselor, clinical research, 1 publication as first author, and now during my gap years I have a job as an ophthalmic assistant and basically doing the same work as the technicians at the clinic. LOR: Very solid, physics, tissue engineering, math, Ophthalmologist, DO, read/edited the physics/tissue/MD LOR and they are superb and I know that the other two are very strong as well.

So my question is, should I apply now and most likely have to reapply, or wait to get a better mcat score and then apply for my first time? The doctor I work with was on the admission committee for his medical school, and he told me to wait to get a better mcat score and make my 1st application the strongest. But I was thinking, wouldn't medical schools think highly of someone who first applies with an okay mcat score, then comes back the next year with an even better score which shows great commitment into this career? I'm seriously at a loss, any input would be great!!
 

Dr. Stalker

5+ Year Member
Sep 11, 2014
1,609
1,728
Itchy and Scratchy Land
Status
  1. Medical Student
Hello,

So I just finished my mcat and got my scores a few weeks ago. Not so great.. this is my second time taking it, last year 484 (yes I know, horrible, took the worst approach), this year 496 (125,121,126,124) :/ My grades went from a sGPA (Bioengineering) of 2.8 after freshmen year to now a 3.673, so good upward trend and in the ballpark now. Just graduated a few months ago. EC: Very solid, done many hours of volunteer, co-facilitate support groups, tutor in math, scribe, crisis counselor, clinical research, 1 publication as first author, and now during my gap years I have a job as an ophthalmic assistant and basically doing the same work as the technicians at the clinic. LOR: Very solid, physics, tissue engineering, math, Ophthalmologist, DO, read/edited the physics/tissue/MD LOR and they are superb and I know that the other two are very strong as well.

So my question is, should I apply now and most likely reapply, or wait to get a better mcat score and then apply for my first time? The doctor I work with was on the admission committee for his medical school, and he told me to wait to get a better mcat score and make my 1st application the strongest. But I was thinking, wouldn't medical schools think highly of someone who first applies with an okay mcat score, then comes back the next year with an even better score which shows great commitment into this career? I'm seriously at a loss, any input would be great!!
Wait to get a better MCAT score. Congratulations on the massive improvement from 484 to 496. While I know your 496 isn't ideal, it shows me you're doing this right and will certainly earn a higher score in the future.

The best advice is to apply ONCE with your BEST application. The issue with reapplying is every single medical school (md and do) will compare you to your prior application. While certain schools claim they'll look at a reapp favorably, if you've applied once before, they have all your information, and they will certainly officially or unofficially take a glance at your prior application. Unless you've increased your academic metrics drastically, gotten incredible new achievements, or a phenomenal new job, when they compare your two applications, you'll be viewed as negatively, solely because you've applied twice.

Medical schools aren't going anywhere, give yourself another chance on your MCAT, boost your ECs, if you can crack 505-510, you'll be in better standing for DO.
 
Jul 30, 2017
3
1
Status
  1. Pre-Medical
I was so close of voiding because 3 weeks out: AAMC FL 1 - 492. 5 days out: AAMC FL 2 - 493, I was absolutely destroyed afterwards, but my friends who took in multiple times and got in said to just submit it because I'll do better than last year no matter what, so I just F it and submitted lol. Okay I see your point, so if you are a reapplicant only showing that you improved your mcat score and that's it, this is not much of an impact in making your second application stronger unless you've done a ton of more stuff like what you listed. Thank you for your advise, I needed this because I was so 50/50 on whether I should be a reapplicant or just wait.
 
About the Ads

PreMedMissteps

The Great West Coast
2+ Year Member
Jan 27, 2017
1,674
1,785
wouldn't medical schools think highly of someone who first applies with an okay mcat score, then comes back the next year with an even better score which shows great commitment into this career? I'm seriously at a loss, any input would be great!!


Oh gawd, no!

Instead they're more likely to think, "this applicant showed foolishness applying last year with those MCAT scores, doubtful that all that foolishness has washed away."
 
  • Like
Reactions: sh.h

Dr. Stalker

5+ Year Member
Sep 11, 2014
1,609
1,728
Itchy and Scratchy Land
Status
  1. Medical Student
I hoping that my strong words will pull him away from the submit button.
Perhaps I'm overly sensitive on that topic as I'm a multi time MCAT taker and multi time low scorer, I never got anything out of people attacking me/myscore lol. However, I do see your point. We're both trying to steer OP towards a perhaps better pathway than applying rn.
 
Jul 30, 2017
3
1
Status
  1. Pre-Medical
Lol sorry I should be more careful with my words. Of course I know where 496 stands, that it's not an "okay score". Be as cut throat as possible to me, I need it and take it all the time from people so it's nothing new. But what you said makes sense about foolishness. And my finger has been pulled away from the submit button after talking to the doctor that I work with, I guess I just wanted some more clarification is all. Thanks for the input, I needed it!
 
  • Like
Reactions: PreMedMissteps

Dr. Stalker

5+ Year Member
Sep 11, 2014
1,609
1,728
Itchy and Scratchy Land
Status
  1. Medical Student
Lol sorry I should be more careful with my words. Of course I know where 496 stands, that it's not an "okay score". Be as cut throat as possible to me, I need it and take it all the time from people so it's nothing new. But what you said makes sense about foolishness. And my finger has been pulled away from the submit button after talking to the doctor that I work with, I guess I just wanted some more clarification is all. Thanks for the input, I needed it!
If the only issue with applying and then reapplying was you losing your money, I wouldn't chime in at all. But, if you're studying and improving your stats that much coupled with your amazing BME gpa, awesome ECs, and amazing volunteer work, me, @PreMedMissteps, along with others, know you have a chance at something better than a 496. Unfortunately, the big issue with the reapplication is what I mentioned above, and that's why we're all concerned. If you weren't going to be compared to your prior app go crazy and apply lol. But, in this case, we can stop you before making a relatively bad decision lol.
 
Apr 23, 2015
386
448
Status
  1. Medical Student
Why is it so bad to be a reapplicant?

Read this. People like Goro, gyngyn, LizzyM, Catalystik, gonnif have explained why it's so important to apply once and do it right. Being a re-applicant puts you at a disadvantage. Take the MCAT again, but PLEASE not before taking the time to figure out the flaws in your approach to the questions, your study methods, etc.

Edit: Congrats on the huge improvement!! But don't stop there. Go for more. We know you can!! You're clearly bright, as the other aspects of your app show.
 
This thread is more than 3 years old.

Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

  1. Your new thread title is very short, and likely is unhelpful.
  2. Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  3. Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  4. It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose.
  5. Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers.
  6. Your reply has occurred very quickly after a previous reply and likely does not add anything to the thread.
  7. This thread is locked.
About the Ads