State Medical schools?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

styphon

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2001
Messages
723
Reaction score
294
Points
5,171
Location
New york
  1. Attending Physician
I have a chance to get into a state run Medical School by early acceptance, specifically SUNY Upstate Medical School in NY.
Now my question is..What would Residencys think about that?Do places look down on the fact that a person went to a state Medical School instead of one in the top 10?
 
Styphon my dear,

If that was the case , then all the other one hundred and something allopathic schools plus the osteopathic schools would be out of business...I think. Why would they look down on a state school? , in fact residencies are government related to the point that producing a physician becomes official* business - why would the governemnet self-defeat itself by allowing a non-negilgible bias against its own state* schools? , in other words...I don't think so 🙂


Dr.Perez
 
If you are talking about applying early decision to a medical school, I would not recommend that. If your numbers are good enough to get in off of ED, you should be applying to a number of schools as sometimes your state school or that one state school may not be the best school for you or may not offer you the best financial aid package (many private schools offer scholarships or grants). If you are talking about going to a state school in general and still getting into a competetive residency, it's very doable. Most state schools send a few students into the most competetive residencies every year, such as neurosurgery, urology, opthamology, every year. The only difference is that whereas a state school may have 3 students going into urology, a private top ten school may have 6 students going into urology. Out of 150 students at both classes, this difference could be accounted for by less people wanting to do urology at the state school as state schools tend to be more primary care oriented, or the caliber of students at the respective schools, as a top 10 school has a more careful screening process and may just accept a higher percentage of students that are completely dedicated towards their medicine, are better test takers, or show more leadership in medical school. Note that none of these reasons reflects on the medical school, just on the individual student and how the individual student chooses to live their lives. I go to a state medical school and many of my classmates (mainly female classmates), want medicine to be a part-time career so they don't do as much in terms of building up their resume because they don't want to go to a competetive residency and are happy with an MD. Also notice that the most competetive residencies still accept a number of students that went to foreign medical schools (the fellowships do as well). This is because residency programs care primarily about the caliber of the applicant, going to a good school can help your resume but it is by no means necessary to do what you want.
 
I have to respectfully disagree with CKent...

If you have good enough stats to get into your state school EDP then why not go for it?
If you are talking finances there is no comparison in some instances.

My state schools tuition is just over 10,000/year!!! ALL PRIVATES ARE GOING TO RUN ANYWHERE FROM 25,000-35,000/YEAR!! major financial difference no matter how much they give in aid.

Don't blow off EDP. If that school is truly where you want to go then consider it. Only one application cost. No travel expenses and while the rest of your peers are nervous the rest of the year waiting for acceptances you will now around late september/early october!!

later
 
I would have to agree w/ "12r..." In Florida, University of South Florida has an EDP (the only one in the state) and the requirements are 3.7 OGPA and 30 MCAT. These stats seem pretty noble to me. In state tuition is $12,000 and the greatest benefit is that you know you're in by like october 15th. THAT IS AWESOME!!!! And from what the Director of Admissions of USF has told me is that the interview is basically a gimme and as long as you can talk you're in. EDP shows maturity and responsibility because you A)turned your app in somewhat early and B) got all your shnit together
 
I know someone who went to University of Louisville & just finished a residency at Hopkins. Now he's in New York to do a cardio res at Beth Israel. It's the doctor, not state v. private school, that they care about.
 
Hi drintraining-

2 other florida schools have EDP also. Best wishes!

Dr.Perez
 
Top Bottom