- Joined
- Nov 16, 2005
- Messages
- 95
- Reaction score
- 0
I'm stumped for clinical experiences: should I volunteer in the ER or become an EMT/Paramedic. I'm worried b/c isn't EMT a dangerous job?
any other good clinical ECs?
any other good clinical ECs?
dz88 said:I'm stumped for clinical experiences: should I volunteer in the ER or become an EMT/Paramedic. I'm worried b/c isn't EMT a dangerous job?
any other good clinical ECs?
Praetorian said:The biggest risk in EMS is finding out that it's nothing like what you probably expect. Check out www.traumacentral.com/forums to talk to some veteran EMT's and medics to find out what it is really like. Basically, as a former EMS clinical instructor, I recommend AGAINST people becoming EMT's for reasons than true dedication to prehospital care.
If you want a good "clinical" job, I would suggest phlebotomy. The pay is better than EMS, and the schooling (in places where it is required) is far shorter than EMS. Not to mention if you become proficient with a needle, your patients once you get into medical school will appreciate it!
ASDIC said:I strongly disagree that pre-hospital cannot be used to gain valuable clinical experience. The experience that the premed wud want is to understand medicine as a provider and being an EMT is the best possible choice. Furthermore, as an EMT you being to understand the patient and be confident in skills, something that medical schools teach students.
the job situation can also play into this - some places are easy to get jobs, and others are never hiring. See if you can get a job in your field before you waste your time in the training. Some places will hire you as an ER tech if you're an EMT/CNA, which is going to be more interesting than phlebotomy. Praetorian makes some good points, but I'm an EMT, and I love my job, clinical experience or no clinical experience. Basically, your mileage will vary.Praetorian said:I agree Bruinfan, well said, but I still do not believe EMS is really the best way to gain medical experience for a premed.
Praetorian said:where most of us live, you are not going to see any situation where you are challenged by your patient. Most BLS providers wind up doing non-emergent transfers and never see a critical or even serious patient unless there is something really major going on- i.e. plane crash, terrorist attack, etc.
Praetorian said:I agree Bruinfan, well said, but I still do not believe EMS is really the best way to gain medical experience for a premed.
for sure, I doubt that many med schools even consider it, I just thought the hands on stuff at any level would be beneficial once you are there. I totally agree, please only do it if you truly want to, not just for experience.Praetorian said:I've been in the field for 8 years, five as a supervisor (both paid and volunteer) and an instructor, and I agree that ALS level practice is a good experience, but to say that EMT-B is a good choice simply to pad your app is not a good idea. That we really do need to keep in mind that honestly medical schools could care less about our little stint as an EMT during college- part of this being the ease with which one can become an EMT.
But as I said, if you have an honest interest in EMS, go for it. We need good EMT's and medics, but we also need people who will eventually become the next generation of medical directors and advocates for improved prehospital care. But please, please, please only do it if your heart is in it. That is all I am asking.
I'm pretty sure med schools are fully aware that they're only looking at less than three years of most applicants' lives. There can only be so much in their applications. By the time I submitted the AMCAS, I had almost nothing in my app over a year and a half long.Praetorian said:That we really do need to keep in mind that honestly medical schools could care less about our little stint as an EMT during college- part of this being the ease with which one can become an EMT.
Praetorian said:I've been in the field for 8 years, five as a supervisor (both paid and volunteer) and an instructor, and I agree that ALS level practice is a good experience, but to say that EMT-B is a good choice simply to pad your app is not a good idea. That we really do need to keep in mind that honestly medical schools could care less about our little stint as an EMT during college- part of this being the ease with which one can become an EMT.
Med01 said:I have another suggestion: volunteer in a Free clinic for the uninsured. This was recommended to me by an advisor. It was really fun, I learned a lot from the nurses, and got to do stuff (like take histories, give flu shots, take blood glucose tests), and you feel like you're doing something useful for people who can't afford care. The nurses and staff who volunteered were really very generous people and great to learn from.
N1DERL& said:Med01, how'd you find your clinic? I'm interested in volunteering at a clinic but have been unable to find one. Any tips?
Praetorian said:"I'm an EMT, isn't that cool" approach to things giving the appearance that persons are only interested in the flashy and exciting side of medicine. Just passing along what I was told.