Temple OR PITT?????????

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

jojo2280

Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know which of these Pennsylvanian schools would be best to commit 4 years of my life to? I can think of a lot of pros and cons to each school, but I would just like to get your opinions...
JOJO
 
TEMPLE

Bc Temple has Mark, and Cusp, EcoRI are also at Temple. With all due respect, I would avoid Dr. Meathead as much as I could.

Also, TEMPLE is the best clinical school. So, Temple is the way to go. :clap: :clap:
 
Originally posted by DesiDentist
TEMPLE!!

Do you want your classmate to be drmeathead?

'nuff said.


DesiDentist


Ahhhh! Don't remind me about meathead! I'm cringing. . .
You know, as much as some of us may disagree on somethings, I think that we tend to respectfully disagree. Meathead just attacked. . . I'm frightened.

In Pitt's defense, I'm a nice person and I met a lot of really nice people at my interview. . .
 
dragonfly9:

I was kidding! one bad apple, I mean very very bad apple cannot determine the class profile.

JoJo, let us know what you choose. you really can't go wrong with either, but remember like Tink said: Temple is the best clinical school in the country!

DesiDentist
 
Originally posted by DesiDentist
dragonfly9:

I was kidding! one bad apple, I mean very very bad apple cannot determine the class profile.

Much worse than a bad apple! Bad meat! Trust me, I have encountered some stinky cold cuts hiding in the back of my fridge. . .
 
Come on guys, let's give this person a little more helpful advice. I personally don't know much about Pitt but I do know that if you want it, Temple will give you the experience needed to become a great general practitioner (and specialist if you choose). Do what I did and sit down with a piece of paper and write out the pros and cons of each school next to each other(trust me, having them on paper side-to-side makes a huge difference than just having them in your head). Start with the most important factors at the top and include all factors including tuition, cost of living, opportunity for specializing, clinic opportunities, location, weather, social life, extracurricular activies, male/female ratio, sports team, etc.(you get the point)...everything. Go down the list and do an evaluation to see what matters to you most. See if this helps. If you still can't decide, it means that you like both schools equally and just go with your gut instinct. If that doesn't help, then flip a coin! If that doesn't work, then screw it, go to Temple and we will have a great time together and become excellent dentists😀 Remember to take everything on these posts with a grain of salt but I hope I was somewhat helpful.
 
As for which school is best for you, I would do as Laker Fan advised and sit down and make a list of pros and cons. I was impressed by both programs and know you will do well at either one.

As for the continued grilling of drmeathead, I think enough is enough. It's presumptuous at best to pass judgement on him as a person based on one misguided post.

If we can all sit back and consider his original comment, I think many would agree it was a valid one. I also think most would agree that he didnt choose the most effective way of expressing his thoughts. The point is, it would do us all well to realize that most people, at least at times, struggle in expressing their true agenda.

The way I interpreted his original post was that; One, this forum isnt for the discussion of race, creed, religion, politics, and and all other subjects that are more sensitive in nature, but that it is for the discusion of all-things-dental (granted, often times we are divided as to our opinions of all-things-dental, but healthy,respectful discussion of ALL-THINGS-DENTAL, is informative and insightful and provides great benefit to many of the readers of this forum). I also realize that things such as exercise, spring break, finances, and an infinite number of other topics are discussed herein, and are welcomed by all, but not the discussion of the aforementioned topics. Second, and this is where I think he really rubbed some people the wrong way, he was voicing his concern with what he caled a "double standard."

Specifically, that it's okay to organize an "ALL (fill in a minority group)" but that if someone were to organize an "ALL WHITE" group it would be heavily frowned upon, and the organizers thereof would be branded as racists, bigots, prejudiced, short-minded, etc...Again, while his way of expressing his opinion may have been misguided, I found it equally disturbing the way MANY were so quick to pass judgement on him, calling him a rascist and
bigot, and offering sorrow for anyone who has to have him in their program, and that someone called Rose Mangold, and so on. It seems as though those who were so quick to pass judgement (prejudge based on one poorly expressed post) were demonstrating the same frightening intolerance they claimed to be decrying.

The fact is none of us know drmeathead or his background, and we should give him the benefit of the doubt, or at least accept his explanation and accept that MAYBE we did infact misinterpret his original post, and overreact to it....after all, arent tolerance, forgiveness, love, and mutual respect vital to all of us? Let's give this guy a break and move on, enjoying where we are at in school (almost done w/ our undergraduate work!!!), and that we will be starting our professional schooling in a few months...think about it, chill out, and decide for yourself.
 
Originally posted by DesiDentist
TEMPLE!!

Do you want your classmate to be drmeathead?

'nuff said.


DesiDentist

haha
true true


Ashwin🙂
 
"remember like Tink said: Temple is the best clinical school in the country!"
That is serious bull ****, i have ever heard.... comeon, u people r talking as if u have been working in temple's clinic for a while and also have worked in other dentals school's clinic, comeon please give me a break, there is no way to find out if u have worked in every single clinic that which one is the best one, and what is best ot u may be worst to somebody else, so i guess u should not post comments like that....
Viraj
 
Jojo: Go to the school where you most feel comfortable. It would be a shame to study dentistry at a school feeling like you wish you were at the other school. If you're gonna be great it doesn't matter where you study, you'll just be.

Personally, I liked UPitt more than Temple. Just a personal feeling. If I had not been accepted to Penn I would've gone to UPitt without any second thoughts. Good luck with your decision.
 
It's very true that there is no way to find out which is the best school unless you can spend time at all of them. Every one can claim that their school is the best and no one can validate the claim. However, there are some criteria that ppl use to choose their school, also the same criteria the schools use to advertise themselves.

1) Board passing rate and average.

2) Especially for private schools in the east coast, they always brag how their students pass the CA board the first time. This is very important for out of state students. Since the CA board is so hard, every one brags their CA board passing rate. For example, UOP claims that they are a very good clinical school because their students pass the CA board 98%. I have personally known so many dentists from out of state coming here not passing the CA board for many times. My friends graduated from Tufts and BU don't pass the CA board until the third time. I probaly do not know all of Temple grads. But all my friends who graduated from Temple pass the board the first time. And that is very important. What's the point of going back to CA without a license?

Of course if you are so interested in the school, you can always call up the student affairs office to ask how their students do at the CA and Florida boards. They will tell you the truth. Both UPITT and Temple have tons of students from those states.

Passing the CA and Florida boards is the key to measure the clinical exposure of the students. That's why I said Temple is the best in clinical. Look at how many patients they have and how many cases their students get to do. The key in dentistry is not how perfect you do it (because you will never achieve perfection). The key here is to practice, practice, and practice and be comfortable with the procedure on test day. And you can only practice when you have tons of patients.

Jojo, you should figure out all the pros and cons, if you are still unsured, call the students affairs and ask how their students do, ask the name of their alumni in your area and go talk to their alumni. Temple is special in its own way and I think highly of the school. That's all I can tell you.

GOOD LUCK and make sure to tell us where you gonna be next year.
 
I really haven't seen very good advice given so far. Temple is an excellent clinical school, that is clear. But most of us are not from California and we are not concerned with passing the California boards.

I have visited both. Many of the Pennsylvanians I met except for those from the Philly region seemed to prefer Pitt. I met a student who was from State College, PA, which is righrt in the middle of the two. He was accepted at both and chose Pitt.

Temple:
1. Temple is an excellent clinical school bar none.
2. Philadelphia is a great city that does not cost significantly more than Pittsburgh. It has a cosmopoltan, big city atmosphere, but feels like an overgrown small town.
3. Location: 90 miles to NYC (daytripable), 120 to DC, 120 to the Shore and a long weekend to most of New England.
4. Temple's location will provide lots of great experiences/opportunities that Pitt will not.

Cons:
1. It is in a not so nice part of town. This is an especially valid concern if you are female.
2. You may be responsible for "runaway' patients and their fees.

About the same:
1. Cost of tuition
2. Reputation: Temple is better clinically, Pitt is a research powerhouse. Temple is a little better known. At Pitt, you will get more personal attention.
3. Cost of living. Temple is a bit more, but you get a big city and its advantages/disadvantages.

Pittsburgh:
1. It is right in the middle of a major undergrad campus. If you want to relive your undergrad years, go here. Pitt's other grad programs (med, law, pharm, etc are right there too.
2. Pittsburgh is a vibrant, cheap, friendly yet cultural place to live. There is lots to do and most importantly, it can be done cheaply. The entire city bus system is free for pitt students.
3. Pitt has a smaller more cohesive class, a more "collegiate" atmosphere than Temple's rough big city experience.

Cons:
1. The weather in Pittsburgh will be colder than Philly.
2. Pittsburgh is more isolated than Philly. Some may find it to be a gloomy, boring town.
 
Top