- Joined
- Sep 7, 2003
- Messages
- 6,526
- Reaction score
- 108
That is all.
2. Breasts are modified sweat glands, which is even more disappointing
This reminds me of the very excellent histopath prof I had in 1st year, who made the same statement in his lecture on mammary tissue. He was a great teacher, and unfortunately passed before his time.
Still brought a smile to my face.
BH
Gee, sounds complex.1. Intraobserver reproducibility is poor, which is disappointing
2. Breasts are modified sweat glands, which is even more disappointing
Undoubtly, the best pathologists will likely continue to be those can admit to challenges in the profession, and it's these folk from whom much can be learned.......For me, I think I have settled on breast path. The ADH vs DCIS differential drives me batty, and lobular lesions drive me batty, and microinvasive cases drive me batty. Plus, all these things on "is it atypical or not" drive me crazy. I almost feel like at least 25% of breast cases would make me wish I had an expert consultant if I was signing it out, and I don't get to this level with anything else.........Breast path I feel like I can get a gestalt after a second or two but even if I stare at it for an hour and read chapters in Rosen or Tavassoli I will still be clueless.............Breast path it seems like the criteria make no sense (or at least are not that readily applicable) yet experts tend to agree on more tough cases. And it also seems like the clinical issues if you are wrong in breast path are more immediate and dangerous.
Signed, A future Breast and GU Pathologist
Gee, sounds complex.
Pathologists struggle all the time on needle biopsies about whether something is ADH or low grade DCIS, but it doesn't really matter! If you reexcise there is something more substantial so you can make the diagnosis, or alternatively there is nothing left and it's already out at that point.
I was actually thinking the same thing. The clinical difference between those two is of limited importance...
T I have met patients who have "only" DCIS and call themselves cancer survivors, but you can't call yourself a cancer survivor if you have ADH.
Unless of course, you or someone you love is dealing with the diagnosis.I was actually thinking the same thing. The clinical difference between those two is of limited importance...
And I must say, that you don't know jack **** about breast path. You'd better get yourself a good malpractice lawyer NOW.I must say, your end of the discussion isn't being held up very well.
And I must say, that you don't know jack **** about breast path. You'd better get yourself a good malpractice lawyer NOW.
Unless of course, you or someone you love is dealing with the diagnosis.
And I must say, that you don't know jack **** about breast path. You'd better get yourself a good malpractice lawyer NOW.
Unless of course, you or someone you love is dealing with the diagnosis.
And I must say, that you don't know jack **** about breast path. You'd better get yourself a good malpractice lawyer NOW.
WTF are you talking about? I didn't say "people" don't know about breast path, I wa sreferrig ot Gun Shopt comment below. Unless of course, you all also agree with this statement too.And you claiming that other people don't know about breast path, is a little pot-kettle..
Maybe that idea of taking a statement of mine about DCIS and ADH to prove me wrong, didn't quite work as well at Gun Shot intended.I must say, your end of the discussion isn't being held up very well.
I beleive they call people have a natural propensity for things they haven't yet learned/practiced in great detail, naturally talented (although I did get an "A" in Medical Pathology).I've haven't been to med school yet? Gee, I'm glad you cleared that up for me. I haven't yet gone to med school however, I managed to learn enough from a few of the best paths in the US, to know that ADH versus DCIS differential IS complex. I don't judge who I can and cannot learn from. Too bad you do.You haven't even gone to medical school. And while I'm sure if your rese
arch involves looking at breast tissue, you may think you have a good handle on breast pathology........You aren't a pathologist or a pathology resident, your ability to judge people here is limited....
Given that I have only taken 1 path coure WITH med students and haven't yet completed a residency in path, of course not but trust me just like YOU learned it, I CAN TOO. Can you tell the difference between oncocytoma and renal cell carcinoma? Do you know the difference between tangles and plaques and I mean structurally, what proteins are involved, where they're located? I mean what's the purpsoe of this whole "do you know stuff"? Of course there are thing's you know that I don't. But guess what? I'm SURE there's plenty of stuff that I know that you don't just like there's a TON of stuff my Accountant knows that neither of us knows. So what't the point, really?But could you look at a lung cancer met to breast and identify it? How about Plasmacytoma?.
You're right, I'm actually a Buddist monk, who teaches belly dancing and yoga to Catholic priests in the evening. For relaxation, I take courses in Med Pharm, Med Biochem, Med Path, and Histology.And those breast cancer patients I see in the clinic keeps me from sipping Mimosa's all day with other SAHM's.ummm........sh'e not even in MEDICINE!!!!!!
WTF are you talking about? I didn't say "people" don't know about breast path, I was referring to Gun Shops comment below.
Unless of course, you all also agree with this statement too. Maybe that idea of taking a statement of mine about DCIS and ADH to prove me wrong, didn't quite work as well at Gun Shot intended.Gut Shot said:
1. Intraobserver reproducibility is poor, which is disappointing
2. Breasts are modified sweat glands, which is even more disappointing
But guess what? I'm SURE there's plenty of stuff that I know that you don't just like there's a TON of stuff my Accountant knows that neither of us knows. So what't the point, really?
Yaah, perhaps if your egotistical collegues had NOT resorted to personal attacks to make a point in the internet, I wouldn't need to be so confortational. MD's aside, I'll defend my point of view despite the asinine name calling.
Yaah, perhaps if your egotistical collegues had NOT resorted to personal attacks to make a point in the internet, I wouldn't need to be so confortational. MD's aside, I'll defend my point of view despite the asinine name calling.
First, I appreciate the mature response but then that has never been a problem between you and I no matter what we're debating/discussing in the internet.And since this entire thread has once again degenerated into you vs the world, I would question who the egotistical one is.........So try not to use your limited experience to claim to be an expert on so many things, or claim that your experiences are somehow more valid (either because of hearsay, your past experiences, or because of your future goals)
I also think that it's important to note that the purpose of starting this thread wasn't to have a real discussion about ADH versus DCIS yet I have seen NO reprimand sent that way. I understand you guys are collegues and I'm just a "lowly future doctor", but where I come from wrong is wrong no matter what letters you have behind your name.
So this only works one way, to those without an MD? Well then I must have struck gold twice because in my second experience with path residents, you don't need an MD to qualify for making a valid point.There was nothing false in Gut Shot's original statement...
" Education is the ability to listen to almost anything without losing your temper.".
If I have a question, then I'll ask and here's an example:http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=396625You said "But I am lucky that the path residents/faculty at the school I currently attend appreciate my questions/comments at in house path conferences"
Try asking questions here, and not telling us answers.
If I have a statement to make, then I'll make one. If you agree or if it's way off say that, but it isn't necessary to remind me of where I am in the educational process and make insulting comments to get your points acroos since doing so makes a person insecure IMHO.
1Path said:I'm curious, is residency going to be or already is your first "real" job?