The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I was gonna vote sleep since i think we need to learn more mechanics first

Don't do any more sleep until the overwhelming majority the thread decides that's the best option. Sleep delays information and that's why it's a late game tool for when death starts hurting more than helping.

 

[screamqueenbee]

Did/do you believe he has a strong chance of flipping scum?

That was my general vibe

 

[Animal Midwife]

That was my general vibe

So why did you say everyone is village hours after voting him?

 

[samac]

So why did you say everyone is village hours after voting him?

 

[screamqueenbee]

So why did you say everyone is village hours after voting him?

To be fair, I did also say everyone is village before too

 

[_rae_]

What's our thoughts on this whole soulmate business?

 

[Animal Midwife]

To be fair, I did also say everyone is village before too

Yeah, I saw. I'm trying to reconcile these mutually exclusive statements of "apop is a scapegoat to save Clem" and "it doesn't matter because there is no scum."

 

[screamqueenbee]

Yeah, I saw. I'm trying to reconcile these mutually exclusive statements of "apop is a scapegoat to save Clem" and "it doesn't matter because there is no scum."

I don't think I said that first thing, friend. I think I said Pop is an easy target.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't think I said that first thing, friend. I think I said Pop is an easy target.

Okay. Maybe you can walk me through what you do mean then. Is Clem not another easy target if we're purely talking about playstyle?

 

[screamqueenbee]

Okay. Maybe you can walk me through what you do mean then. Is Clem not another easy target if we're purely talking about playstyle?

Has their playstyle in this game been dramatically different than previous games?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Has their playstyle in this game been dramatically different than previous games?

He played all of the game you totted apop in.

 

[kitzsuna]

What's our thoughts on this whole soulmate business?

I forgot about that

 

[CeeGee14]

Don't do any more sleep until the overwhelming majority the thread decides that's the best option. Sleep delays information and that's why it's a late game tool for when death starts hurting more than helping.

Welp, wish that thought crossed my mind before I voted sleep lol.

 

[screamqueenbee]

He played all of the game you totted apop in.

What my logic is is that, ppl tend to suss people who change up their play style.
Pop's play style is totally different this game than others.
Could people have thought that was wolfy? Could people have thought she was being annoying? Could people be punishing her for the roleplay aspect of the game? I can't say.
I do know that multiple players in multiple games have said "X isn't acting like X typically acts when they're affiliated with Y, that seems suss" A player acting not typical tends to draw suspicion.

Does that make sense or is my brain broken?

 

[fruitsalad]

Does anyone regret how they voted?

not me

 

[_rae_]

Does anyone regret how they voted?

Yes, in the sense that apop was not on my sus list but no in that self-prezzing is always the right choice

 

[fruitsalad]

"I'm not a failed DJ. I'm pre-successful." Day 1 Vote - Final Tally

apop (6) - Zenge, PSV, DubZ, genny, samac, rae
rae (4) - AM, finn, barks, Clem
CeeGee (1) - fruit
fruit ()
PSV ()
samac ()
DubZ ()
Clem (2) - Spurs, screamqueenbee
AM ()
screamqueenbee ()
genny ()
finn ()
kitszuna ()
Barky ()
Zenge (1) - apoptosis
Spurs ()
Sleep/No Vote (1) - CeeGee

15/16 voting

Missing: @kitzsuna

CHECK YOUR VOTES.

@CeeGee14 why did you sleep/no vote?

 

[fruitsalad]

i can’t really do vote analysis with an unknown flip

 

[fruitsalad]

maybe indirectly

 

[fruitsalad]

i think rae is probably village

 

[Animal Midwife]

What my logic is is that, ppl tend to suss people who change up their play style.
Pop's play style is totally different this game than others.
Could people have thought that was wolfy? Could people have thought she was being annoying? Could people be punishing her for the roleplay aspect of the game? I can't say.
I do know that multiple players in multiple games have said "X isn't acting like X typically acts when they're affiliated with Y, that seems suss" A player acting not typical tends to draw suspicion.

Does that make sense or is my brain broken?

Somewhat. I appreciate the insight but I'm just left with more questions regarding how her being radically different than anything you've ever seen before (especially when she's only ever randed village) means she's clearly village here.

 

[Clem J]

No I haven’t watched more than the first couple yet. Life man. I’m watching the animated show tho!

Brennan and aabria and robbie roped me in, I've been watching it sporadically while doing schoolwork

 

[screamqueenbee]

Somewhat. I appreciate the insight but I'm just left with more questions regarding how her being radically different than anything you've ever seen before (especially when she's only ever randed village) means she's clearly village here.

Okay : )

 

[samac]

What's our thoughts on this whole soulmate business?

 

[samac]

Yes, in the sense that apop was not on my sus list but no in that self-prezzing is always the right choice

Didn’t you wolf apop in GTH?

 

[samac]

Somewhat. I appreciate the insight but I'm just left with more questions regarding how her being radically different than anything you've ever seen before (especially when she's only ever randed village) means she's clearly village here.

This feels like warm milk AM for some reason

 

[samac]

Brennan and aabria and robbie roped me in, I've been watching it sporadically while doing schoolwork

I love Brennan

 

[GoSpursGo]

I don't really have any particular legacy to leave if I'm dead tonight. My reads haven't changed much since the GTH yesterday, and for reference in case anyone doesn't want to open my spreadsheet from yesterday my W read list was:

Less wolfy
SQB/genny
CG/Apop
Clem
More wolfy

Only possible addition would be fruits, who as I've mentioned above, made me squint just a teeny bit. Not enough to formally add them, since i already have a pretty long POE list. However, if they did happen to roll W again, I suspect this time it would look different from the Halloween game.

The reason for all of them is just vibes. Hoping I'll still be here after 9p to give a more satisfying answer, with potentially more information to work from.

 

[GoSpursGo]

Didn’t you wolf apop in GTH?

Unless my spreadsheet is wrong, rae did not--they had apop as V, but put a vote there for self-prez.

This feels like warm milk AM for some reason

Is that a good thing or a bad thing?

 

[_rae_]

Didn’t you wolf apop in GTH?

Nope

V
V
V

 

[screamqueenbee]

This feels like warm milk AM for some reason

Cozy or curdled?

 

[_rae_]

Cozy or curdled?

Dislike

 

[samac]

my legacy is that spurs is village. I’ll die on that hill. Blocc status.

despite zenge leading the vote on apop I felt like it came from village zenge. Only way I see Zenge as wolf is is Rae is also wolf and it was a protection maneuver.

i am not sure about Rae. I felt resistance to both the wagons yesterday and neither felt smooth. But if Rae is wolf I’d re-evaluate Zenges. If she is village I think this is village zenge 8/10 times.

AM feels like warm vanilla milk.

With all the back and forth with Dubz I want to say she feels village but I am wary after the great pocket debacle of 2025. I don’t think anyone has ever pocketed me that hard so I won’t blocc her. But she feels good. If she hasn’t voted a wolf by D3 I’d probably scrutinize lol

I think genny needs scrutiny but I don’t feel sos strongly that it’s a if I die yeet Santy situation.

Clem is involved in a way I’m not used to and deserves scrutiny.

I will trust AM’s read on fruit.

The rest I don’t feel strongly about in either direction to leave thoughts on. All various shades of null.

 

[samac]

Unless my spreadsheet is wrong, rae did not--they had apop as V, but put a vote there for self-prez.

Is that a good thing or a bad thing?

Good

 

[CeeGee14]

@CeeGee14 why did you sleep/no vote?

Because I'm incredibly wishy-washy and indecisive. EVEYRONE is either V or N to me, which I know isn't helping. The thought didn't cross my mind that it might be a good idea to save my sleep vote.

 

[samac]

Nope

I don’t know if you being the only person to village read her makes me feel better or worse lol

 

[_rae_]

I don’t know if you being the only person to village read her makes me feel better or worse lol

I'm known for going against the grain *shrug*

 

[_rae_]

I don’t know if you being the only person to village read her makes me feel better or worse lol

Also it looks like CG village read her as well. And Finnick had her as "leans wolfy" but not a solid wolf read.

 

[samac]

Also it looks like CG village read her as well. And Finnick had her as "leans wolfy" but not a solid wolf read.

I’ve lost the spreadsheet but I was including leans in wolf reads.
Was CG not in the GTH? I don’t remember another green

 

[CeeGee14]

I’ve lost the spreadsheet but I was including leans in wolf reads.
Was CG not in the GTH? I don’t remember another green

I think AM put me in a GTH. And I'm also pretty sure most people said I was W.

As for Apop, I think I did put her as V.

 

[fruitsalad]

I will trust AM’s read on fruit.

wait what read? all i saw was a GTH?

 

[screamqueenbee]

I’ve lost the spreadsheet but I was including leans in wolf reads.
Was CG not in the GTH? I don’t remember another green

Psst

Alright have at it.

A couple of notes:

• @Clem J and @kitzsuna didn't participate at all; @screamqueenbee , @fruitsalad , @Zenge142 participated minimally; @finnickthedog and apoptosis appear to have missed a couple.
• A few of these weren't explicit GTH posts, but if it was close enough (for example, CG had a reads list) I substituted those reads for GTH. If there were reads further back in the posts I did not go digging for them.
• I also did not include posts that came after the thread lock/write up, but did include posts that came between vote close and thread lock.

ETA: added the 3rd bullet point above.

Edit: if you click the button that takes you to the post, the attachment is there

 

[fruitsalad]

are we implicitly treating GTH like they're reads? because i was viewing them as like gut instincts on the fly

 

[samac]

wait what read? all i saw was a GTH?

Whatever she gives. I think she is going to be very very good at reading you.

 

[WildZoo]

If she hasn’t voted a wolf by D3 I’d probably scrutinize lol

samac pls! Since when does village!Dubz vote wolves by D3???

I'm not here I'm just a narcissist

 

[samac]

samac pls! Since when does village!Dubz vote wolves by D3???

I'm not here I'm just a narcissist

ID SAY MOST OF THE TIME
I HAVE NO DATA
BUT FEELS RIGHT

 

[samac]

are we implicitly treating GTH like they're reads? because i was viewing them as like gut instincts on the fly

They’re not implicit I agree

 

[WildZoo]

ID SAY MOST OF THE TIME
I HAVE NO DATA
BUT FEELS RIGHT

DO I NEED BRING RECEIPTS??
I WILL NOT HAVE MY USELESS VILLAGER REPUTATION TARNISHED IN THIS WAY

 

[fruitsalad]

"I'm not a failed DJ. I'm pre-successful." Day 1 Vote - Final Tally

apop (6) - Zenge, PSV, DubZ, genny, samac, rae
rae (4) - AM, finn, barks, Clem
CeeGee (1) - fruit
fruit ()
PSV ()
samac ()
DubZ ()
Clem (2) - Spurs, screamqueenbee
AM ()
screamqueenbee ()
genny ()
finn ()
kitszuna ()
Barky ()
Zenge (1) - apoptosis
Spurs ()
Sleep/No Vote (1) - CeeGee

15/16 voting

Missing: @kitzsuna

CHECK YOUR VOTES.

genny, PSV, screams, barky, finn, CG +/- Clem (?) I think for possible wolves/bad factions/antivillage etc.

weakest on Clem

 

[fruitsalad]

primarily going by vibes and gut instincts, something feels really off to me