So airborne and other unit designations do stay with the combat patch. SF and Ranger tabs are individual achievements and only belong to the individual.
This is exactly right. Under no circumstance can one whom has not completed Ranger School wear the Ranger Tab. Likewise, under no circumstance can one whom has not completed Q-course wear the Long Tab (SF tab.) In the enlisted world, completing Ranger School changes the SQI (special qualification 5th digit) of the MOS to victor. For instance, an SPC infantryman with no special qualifications is an 11B1O, one whom has completed Airborne School is then 11B1P, with Ranger School it becomes 11B1V.
To expand upon the right shoulder unit patches vs. Ranger Tabs. You will never see a Ranger Tab on the right shoulder...and if you do you need hog-tie the individual for being a soup sandwich. What you will see however, is a Ranger
Scroll on the right shoulder. My Avatar is an example of the Ranger Scroll, particularly for 1st Ranger Battalion. The three Battalions of the 75th Ranger Regiment are the actual USASOC Ranger Units. Rangers in a Ranger Battalion deploy with their Ranger Battalion just as conventional infantrymen deploy with their conventional infantry unit. After coming home they get to wear their deploying unit's patch on the right shoulder. If that unit is the 82nd they wear the patch of the 82nd (which does automatically include an Airborne rocker as core0 implied.) If that unit is one of the battalions of the 75th Ranger Regiment, they wear the Ranger Scroll of their respective Battalion.
Ranger School (where you get the Tab, not the Scroll) however, is a school that soldiers from
any unit can attend for three months to gain unconventional leadership skills...very effective leadership skills that is. But actually being assigned to a Ranger Battalion is how one earns the Scroll and Tan Beret. Ranger School makes one Ranger qualified, but after school they go back to their regular unit. Graduating RIP (the Ranger selection program for the 75th) is how one goes to a Ranger Batt and gets to call themselves Ranger. Rangers in Ranger Batt have to go to Ranger School in order to make it past the rank of E4, but are deemed Rangers by having graduated RIP and subsequently serve in a Ranger Batt, regardless of having gone to school or not. Some say we (Rangers) are picky about whom gets to be called Ranger and whom simply is Ranger Qualified, but that is because we do the Ranger job every single day, not for only three months. We are expected to live up to the Ranger Creed regardless of where we are or what we are doing, if we are at home or deployed. I say "we" loosely as I have been out for a few years. However, I still have that creed tattooed to my ilium (humor of the Hippocrates variety), so I still say "we". By the way, let me point out that I am not in any way trying to diminish anyone's accomplishments in earning the Tab...it is a very hard thing to get, and by no means is it not EARNED.
Now, to clarify the role of physicians in a Ranger Batt or SF group: Each Ranger Battalion has its own Surgeon, PA (or two) and a whole lot of high speed medics. Beyond that, one man of every eight man squad is selected annually to become NREMT-I (I was blessed to be selected for this, which is why I am so effing nuts about becoming a physician.) This is to increase the number of medically trained Rangers in operation. It is because of the Battalion Surgeon and his crew that every single Ranger can start a line in the dark...with or without NODS. His job is not only to keep us well, but to keep us alive by keeping us trained. In turn, he trains and fights with us, as he went through the same exact training and selection factors to get there that we did. Whats more, he's our own personal FP doc for our families when we are home. It is very similar in SF groups. Most Batt surgeons for the 75th that I know, had their Tabs before medical school, which was why they were allowed to go to ROP (RIP for O's) as a physician.
So, to sum up my rediculously long post. No, you cannot have a Tab without graduating Ranger School. That's synonymous with wearing a Bird as a butter-bar. No, you cannot wear a Scroll without being in or having been deployed with the 75th Ranger Regiment. And yes, you can be a Ranger physician. Therefore, by sheer implication from this gentleman's uniform, he did complete both Q-Course and Ranger School. My Battalion PA had both his Long Tab and Ranger Tab because he served as an 18D (SF medic) in an SF unit before becoming commissioned as a PA.
I hope my jibber-jabbering has brought some enlightenment as to the the way it works with Tabs and patches. If not, maybe I have provided you with a decent sleep-aid in the form of rambling so you can yawn your way to a nice slumber. Either way, take care.
RLTW!