Finally got a chance to get on my computer and post my scores (was volunteering all day!)
In chronological order:
10/28/11 Kaplan Diagnostic- 34 (Was satisfied considering this was before I had begun to study)
12/5/11 AAMC 3- 38 (Was happy with my first FL)
12/10/11 AAMC 11- 39
12/26/11 AAMC 10- 38
1/8/12 AAMC 8- 40 (Nice, reached my target!)
1/16/12 AAMC 9- 40
1/21/12 AAMC 7- 41
1/22/12 AAMC 5- 40 (Looks like 40 is about my limit; would be fine with getting this score on the real thing)
1/26/12 Retake AAMC 11- 45 (Only missed a single question, for those of you wondering if retaking a test is meaningful or not
It's probably not)
1/27/12 AAMC 4- Incomplete, 14 PS 13 VR (Began taking this guy, then went to bed)
Average Score, First Take AAMC FLs 5 through 11: 39.4
Expected/Goal- 40R
1/28/12 Real MCAT- 41S (15 PS, 14 BS, 12 VR) !!!
The 38 on the first diagnostic kind of killed my motivation. I had my eyes set on a 40 from the beginning, but getting a 38 with almost 2 months left of time to prepare took some gas out of my study habits over winter break. (No, the difference between a 38, 40, 42, or even a 44 is not a deal-breaker, but I think everyone should have a target number in mind). Even as my scores in PS/BS improved, I slid a bit in the VR section. When I started scoring in the 40s, I had consistent 14/15 science scores while my VR was lagging behind at around 11/12, which worried me. I used the last week of studying almost exclusively for VR, and hopefully it paid off on the real thing. I didn't have nearly as much trouble focusing on the real MCAT, which partly compensated for the increased difficulty of the real deal. My impression after leaving the test was that I had (surprisingly) done very well on the verbal but not so well ~13 on each of the sciences. Of course, the OPPOSITE actually happened and I did well on the sciences but poorly on the VR. That's how it goes I guess!
All in all, I studied for an average of 2 hours a day for about 3 months, which comes out to just under 200 hours of time investment
Imagine that, working full time for almost 5 weeks!
I used EK, TPR, AAMC FLs, and some MCAT study sheets off the internet. I found this to be a pretty good system, and there's really nothing that can compare to how useful the AAMC-provided practice tests are. It's costly, but it's worth dishing out the money if you're serious about performing well on the test. I did NOT take a prep course and would strongly discourage anyone from taking one unless they know exactly why it would help them - i.e. they cannot stick to a schedule without a structured arrangement like a prep course.
If you have any other questions, just shoot me a PM, I'd be happy to help you out as much as possible!