Which impromptu survey is this? The one conducted at your program by you? Why would a survery include a question about whether or not PM&R residents have problem with English?
Anyway, I do agree that some programs (mainly in New York) do have a large percentage of FMGs. I think your perception of PM&R residents is skewed by this fact and that many of the things you describe are exaggerated.
By your own reasoning (good programs do not have FMGs who can't speak English), Columbia/Cornell would be at the top of the programs in New York and Mt. Sinai would be close to the bottom. I know that Sinai does attract quite a bit of FMGs because I know PM&R residents that interviewed there or attended medical school there. Having a TBI and SCI model system does not necessarily translate into a good residency program.
With regards to the Steps, again, this may be true for yourself and your program, but I've never heard of such a survey elsewhere. Plus, if so many PM&R residents did fail Step 1 and Step 2, and were such lousy clinicians, then I guess the Internship programs are to blame for letting them sneak through and get a license to practice medicine.
Also, if these PM&R residents are so deficient, why does a prestigious hospital such as HSS allow two PM&R residents to do their Fellowships there?
I completely disagree with your rankings of New York programs. If you are a quailty applicant who is getting multiple interviews in the New York area, the programs I would consider are:
1) Kessler
2) Columbia/Cornell
I realize that the Columbia/Cornell program probably will have growing pains, but there are better opportunities there and the name certainly won't hurt you. Kessler is a great program too, with great teaching, quality residents, and excellent attendings.
By the way, Spaulding has never had a Ca
ri
bbean (you weren't included in that 50% were you?) graduate in its residency program (not that I would be opposed to it). The last four classes (including the class of 2006) have all been AMGs. In fact, the only FMGs have been the ones who have also wound up getting an advanced degree (such as a PhD) in the U.S. Our resident list hasn't been updated for a couple of years, but here's a listing of residents and faculty:
http://www.hmcnet.harvard.edu/pmr/resident.html
http://spauldingrehab.org/body.cfm?id=71
I'm guessing that all of them have a good command of the English language. Instead of being part of the problem, why don't you try doing something constructive that will attract better applicants to your program. Since you seem to know so much about the residency programs in New York, tell me where the residents from your program and Columbia/Cornell are from?