For an academic career you firstly need somewhere that is prolific in their research AND puts out high quality research. Not all institutions are ideal for putting out high quality academic-ready graduates.
1. Ask them what the graduates of their program are doing now. I'm sure your POIs will be happy to answer that question.
2. Ensure the research is prolific and published in major journals such as the Journal of counseling psychology.
3. The most prolific counseling psych program in research is Iowa State; however, I do know that the University of Tennessee Knoxville has an amazing counseling psych program that is in the psych dept. The people there produce great quality research in the most prestigious journals. Also, there is a lot of collaboration with the clinical and experimental tracks.
4. Programs can be what you make of them. Not that I'm saying any program can put out a top ranked academic quality psychologist, BUT remember that many programs can be tailored to fit your needs.
For example, I know some people in counseling psych are interested in mostly practice and not much else; however some people there are very interested in research. Programs are great for tailoring to specific career interests.
Off the soap box