Been out of it for a while but yeah Cincinnati is definitely awesome. I don't know anything about the other programs that you got accepted to (I'm going to assume that they all provide an equally excellent education) but one of the big reasons why I decided on Cincinnati was because the in-state thing and the tuition deal.
It's pretty easy to attain in-state residency status in Ohio if you stay here and live on loans for a year. That definitely helps with getting admitted (there are 5 state medical schools in OH that heavily favors in-staters, 6 if you count Ohio University, which is DO). Besides that, if you're in-state, you stand to save $60,000-$80,000 over 4 years. I'm not sure if you can get the same deal with EVMS or Tufts, but I feel that in the long run, you stand to save money by being in-state.
Asides from that, the educational quality here is nothing less than excellent. Don't let the number of courses fool you, the 3 core courses are spread out over 4 blocks, so you definitely get all the medical school experience that you would ever want. The location of the school is pretty good, it's close to the Cincinnati undergrad campus so it's relatively safe. As long as you don't go into a dark alley at 3:00 am, I don't think antyhing bad will happen.