UF vs FIU vs... OSU?!

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Where would you go?

  • UF

    Votes: 9 36.0%
  • FIU

    Votes: 1 4.0%
  • OSU

    Votes: 15 60.0%

  • Total voters
    25
Status
Not open for further replies.

gtoblobf

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
27
Reaction score
0
So I am having a small crisis because I thought I'd come to a decision and suddenly I do not know WTF to do. HALP!

FIU
Cost: I've been offered a full tuition scholarship (worth about $128,000 over four years), but this does not cover $8,500/yr in "fees" and the cost of living in Miami is high.
Program: Difficult to gauge, because the program is very new, having only graduated its first class of MDs this year. First and second years are A/B/C/D/F (not so nice), and anatomy is all prosection (sounds good to me). I like their community outreach program, students are very positive about the curriculum, and all of their graduates successfully matched this year (a few really well). They only graduated 33 students although they matriculated 40 in their first year; not sure if that represents a worrying rate of attrition or what became of the other students [EDIT: but see below, all but 2 expected to graduate next year].
Location/convenience: Already mentioned the higher cost of living. Miami is also farther from where we are currently living and working (over 3 hours away vs under 2 for Gainesville). My husband could probably find work in Miami, but it might not be as good as his current job, and we would probably live apart during the week until he does. Also, the widely-scattered hospitals through which FIU students rotate, as well as South Florida traffic, make me worry about third year.

UF
Cost: Kind of an unknown quantity... I'm guaranteed $7500/yr recurring aid, and I'm told (after explaining the situation) that they can find about $25k more for my first year, but after that it's hard to say how much I'll get-- probably something. I figure the cost difference could be anywhere from $40k-$80k more than other options.
Program: UF is a top-50 school and the best in FL (IMO). Pass-fail, teaching hospital on campus, more research, they graduate 95% of their students within 4 years (98% in 5 years), and for whatever it's worth, UF is the school that "feels right".
Location/Convenience: Gainesville is closer. It might be feasible for my husband to stay at his current workplace for all four years if we find a good place to live around midway between.

Ohio State
Cost: This was the bombshell-- I got an email a couple days ago telling me I'd been awarded a scholarship covering full in-state tuition. I'd have the cover the difference between IS and OOS ($17.5k/yr) with loans... but it's easy to get residency in OH, especially with my husband working, so after a year (maybe two pessimistically) I'd be fully covered. Even with moving costs and lost wages while my husband looks for work, this could actually be my cheapest option.
Program: OSU is a great school (ranked a little higher than UF), and I really like everything I know about the school's new curriculum (which is also pass/fail), clinical training, and culture. I haven't pictured myself here as much because I had decided a while back that the cost was too much more, but I have no doubt I'd get a great education... for, as it turns out, not a lot.
Location/convenience: Far from both our families, have to move and disrupt my husband's work life, and I hear they have something called "winter" up there.

Thoughts? This is hard!
 
Last edited:
So I am having a small crisis because I thought I'd come to a decision and suddenly I do not know WTF to do. HALP!

FIU
Cost: I've been offered a full tuition scholarship (worth about $128,000 over four years), but this does not cover $8,500/yr in "fees" and the cost of living in Miami is high.
Program: Difficult to gauge, because the program is very new, having only graduated its first class of MDs this year. First and second years are A/B/C/D/F (not so nice), and anatomy is all prosection (sounds good to me). I like their community outreach program, students are very positive about the curriculum, and all of their graduates successfully matched this year (a few really well). They only graduated 33 students although they matriculated 40 in their first year; not sure if that represents a worrying rate of attrition or what became of the other students.
Location/convenience: Already mentioned the higher cost of living. Miami is also farther from where we are currently living and working (over 3 hours away vs under 2 for Gainesville). My husband could probably find work in Miami, but it might not be as good as his current job, and we would probably live apart during the week until he does. Also, the widely-scattered hospitals through which FIU students rotate, as well as South Florida traffic, make me worry about third year.

UF
Cost: Kind of an unknown quantity... I'm guaranteed $7500/yr recurring aid, and I'm told (after explaining the situation) that they can find about $25k more for my first year, but after that it's hard to say how much I'll get-- probably something. I figure the cost difference could be anywhere from $40k-$80k more than other options.
Program: UF is a top-50 school and the best in FL (IMO). Pass-fail, teaching hospital on campus, more research, they graduate 95% of their students within 4 years (98% in 5 years), and for whatever it's worth, UF is the school that "feels right".
Location/Convenience: Gainesville is closer. It might be feasible for my husband to stay at his current workplace for all four years if we find a good place to live around midway between.

Ohio State
Cost: This was the bombshell-- I got an email a couple days ago telling me I'd been awarded a scholarship covering full in-state tuition. I'd have the cover the difference between IS and OOS ($17.5k/yr) with loans... but it's easy to get residency in OH, especially with my husband working, so after a year (maybe two pessimistically) I'd be fully covered. Even with moving costs and lost wages while my husband looks for work, this could actually be my cheapest option.
Program: OSU is a great school (ranked a little higher than UF), and I really like everything I know about the school's new curriculum (which is also pass/fail), clinical training, and culture. I haven't pictured myself here as much because I had decided a while back that the cost was too much more, but I have no doubt I'd get a great education... for, as it turns out, not a lot.
Location/convenience: Far from both our families, have to move and disrupt my husband's work life, and I hear they have something called "winter" up there.

Thoughts? This is hard!

I chose OSU initially after reviewing the offers you have been given. Take my info with a grain of salt because only you will best know the answer to your current situation.

But after reviewing what you have stated about your husband, it sounds like UF may be the best option for the two of you. He may not have to leave his job and you will be able to find a middle ground in living arrangements. I am in similar situations. I am still debating but I almost certain I will choose the program near my significant other because she has a job (which can hopefully reduce the need for extra loans) and it will make it easier for us and where my wife is happy I will be happy. As I said previously you will be the best person to answer this question but I figure hopefully my current situation can help you out. Good luck
 
It sounds like if you choose UF, then you and your husband could both potentially have an hour commute each way? Or someone has a 2 hour commute. This definitely doesn't sound ideal to me, so I would choose OSU since it looks like your husband will have to change jobs anyway to be with you in Gainesville. I am wary of FIU's 40--> 33 attrition rate, plus it sounds like it's not a good option for your family anyway.
 
It sounds like if you choose UF, then you and your husband could both potentially have an hour commute each way? Or someone has a 2 hour commute. This definitely doesn't sound ideal to me, so I would choose OSU since it looks like your husband will have to change jobs anyway to be with you in Gainesville.

You make a valid point. Long commutes suck, and I am probably underestimating how difficult it will be. But if nothing else, it will be viable in the short-term (he can stay with my parents if necessary to be closer to work, and I could probably crash with friends if I had to get up early to avoid the drive). And that's pretty valuable, because he has only a high school diploma and would probably have a difficult time finding a job in Columbus, especially one that pays as well as what he does now. If, for example, he takes a $5000 a year pay cut, that's another $20k cost to going to OSU, and it could even continue to hurt his earnings all through his career. I have counted transportation as an additional cost of going to UF, though, and I was a bit shocked at how much it added up to over four years.

Anyway, thanks for helping me think this through.
 
It sounds like if you choose UF, then you and your husband could both potentially have an hour commute each way? Or someone has a 2 hour commute. This definitely doesn't sound ideal to me, so I would choose OSU since it looks like your husband will have to change jobs anyway to be with you in Gainesville. I am wary of FIU's 40--> 33 attrition rate, plus it sounds like it's not a good option for your family anyway.

For someone who has been out in the workplace for a few years, an hour commute is not unheard of and is actually the norm. It does tack on added cost but it shouldn't be a complete deal breaker.

Edit because it didn't make sense.
 
No love for FSU?

I have several friends at UF - great program. They're all pretty happy and they've all matched very well.
 
No love for FSU?

I have several friends at UF - great program. They're all pretty happy and they've all matched very well.

Nothing but love for FSU-- since my anonymity is nil at this point I don't mind telling you that I did my undergrad there. 😉 But by April 15 I already had the scholarship offer from FIU, and I couldn't see giving it up.

BTW, in fairness to FIU, I should mention that I've since learned that all but 2 of the students missing from that 33 will be graduating next year for various reasons.
 
Fair enough.

Man, I never knew about how many scholarships med schools gave out until I go onto these boards...... In retrospect, I probably should have applied to more than 2 schools, lol.
 
If you husband can find a decent job up there, I'd go to OSU.

The winters aren't that bad in central Ohio, plus you'll be inside studying most of the time.

OSU is a great school and you shouldn't have any trouble going back to FL (or elsewhere) for residency.
 
If you husband can find a decent job up there, I'd go to OSU.

The winters aren't that bad in central Ohio, plus you'll be inside studying most of the time.

OSU is a great school and you shouldn't have any trouble going back to FL (or elsewhere) for residency.

The winters aren't bad in central Ohio is a bit relative. Coming from Florida, a bad winter is a couple of days below 30 degrees lol
 
You make a valid point. Long commutes suck, and I am probably underestimating how difficult it will be. But if nothing else, it will be viable in the short-term (he can stay with my parents if necessary to be closer to work, and I could probably crash with friends if I had to get up early to avoid the drive). And that's pretty valuable, because he has only a high school diploma and would probably have a difficult time finding a job in Columbus, especially one that pays as well as what he does now. If, for example, he takes a $5000 a year pay cut, that's another $20k cost to going to OSU, and it could even continue to hurt his earnings all through his career. I have counted transportation as an additional cost of going to UF, though, and I was a bit shocked at how much it added up to over four years.

Anyway, thanks for helping me think this through.

In that case I guess I would go with UF as the known quantity and since I personally would not want to give up FL weather for Ohio haha.

Does UF do a lot of mandatory rotations elsewhere in FL during 3rd/4th year? If so, you might be able to swing a few months closer to your husband, but I know nothing about UF so this may be a shot in the dark.
 
Raised in North Central Florida and went to UF for UG.

I don't recommend commuting since you would rather allocate that time for studying or other pleasures, such as spending time with your husband. Gainesville traffic gets worse every year and parking is absolutely horrendous on campus. Finding a good job in these parts is pretty scarce given the state of the economy. I'd goto OSU if I was in your boat. Good sized city. Great school. Great residency programs near by or you could just come back to Florida. Just my opinion though.
 
OSU sounds like the best (assuming your husband can find a job). i don't know how old you are so maybe commuting isn't that big of a deal (with regards to social gatherings).

I will say this, as someone from the New England who is dating someone from FLA (she didn't see snow until her first year of school in New England) winter is something you should seriously think about. my girlfriend suffers from seasonal affective disorder (or at the very least, miserable winter-time disorder) and gets downright miserable in winter (even here in Baltimore, where we both now live). central Ohio is gonna have a lot of snow and cold and shorter days with way less sunshine. this may seem trivial but if you are not conducive to cold weather do not make yourself more miserable for four years.

but personally OSU sounds like the best assuming your husband can find a job fairly easily.
 
I'm going to Ohio! Congrats to whoever gets the Wertheim Scholarship at FIU!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top