- Joined
- Apr 9, 2007
- Messages
- 18
- Reaction score
- 0
Is anyone else here starting UPenn's pre-health post-bacc program this May?
Heinz57 - when did you send in your app for Penn? is it for summer admission? i applied the last week in march for summer admit and haven't heard anything. good luck on your interview!
Rich-
I know you PMed me and as promised i will write back I just saw your post and thought i'd jump in....
i'm glad this forum is anonymous....the new director is questionable. On paper she an immense asset to the program, yet I have not found one student (exception those accepted or with extremely high grades) that like her and find her informative. She is new so we are all waiting to see, but for the most part she sounds like a "how to get in to med schook book" as i have heard...very general, kinda BS answers to very important, specific questions. I can't speak from experience however, I have not yet met her. Her credentials are very impressive so i'm sure she knows what shes talking about maybe just not fully disclosing her knowledge- why i dont know.
anyway, the purpose of my post: she is a lot different than the previous director dr. hunter. Hunter was very open to DO schools whereas hershman is not apparently. additionally, she has told people to quit their jobs and focus on grades....which is empty, useless advice for, i'll go out on a limb, everyone who needs to work!....dr. hunter on the otherhand was the one who boasted how successful the full-time workers are while taking 2 classes. so all in all you'll get the advising you want, but you'll have to go after answers a bit more veraciously than first assumed. ok back to work!
Crissy, maybe you should not just "jump in" especially if you are so misinformed. Mrs. Hershman has been at UPenn for roughly 11 weeks. Of course the students are displeased with her currently because she is new and at the same time she is trying to interview and prepare for the incoming class. Thus, she doesn't have the time the current students would like to have to spend with her.
The previous advisor for the last class was there for them and at their beckoning call. Especially at a time (i.e. now) that they need an advisor the most, since the application process is soon approaching. Because Mrs. Hershman is not available, doesn't mean she is "questionable."
Additionally, I would hope that you are not that dense to see that your statement "On paper she an immense asset to the program, yet I have not found one student (exception those accepted or with extremely high grades) that like her and find her informative." is from a blatently biased point of view.
Maybe because these students that are not happy are not in the same situation as those accepted, thus indicating the need for an advisor that isn't able to meet with them...
Also, "I'll go out on a limb" and say since I have talked with her personally, in now way did I get the feeling that I should "quit my job."
Enough of my harangue, back to the subject at hand.
I graduated from UVA in 2005 (philosophy/bioethics major), thought I wanted to do health law/policy, but found out after 1 1/2 of law school that this is not what I really want in life. I think I'm young enough and dedicated enough to make the switch; I'm really excited about getting back into the sciences. I'm working at the ER in my hometown right now. Will probably start at UPenn in May, but I am keeping open the possibility of going to UVA (application deferred).
I really want to do the UPenn program in one year, but I am hearing from people on SDN that most (if not all) UPenn postbaccs choose to do the program in two. I didn't get the impression from the new director at UPenn that so many students choose the two-year plan, so I'm eager to find out just how doable the one-year plan is. Any thoughts on this?
-Rich
Actually you should refrain from making such disparaging statements about Crissy since some of what she says is COMPLETELY TRUE!!!!
She has practically told many of the people in the program, who I know work, to quit their job or take a leave of absence so that they can focus more on their school work. This is extremely unreasonable and frankly kind of dumb!
And yes, in many ways she IS like some admissions booklet b/c she tries her hardest not to give any personal advice.
Many students currently feel as if she has neglected to accept the role of as an advisor...and I think much of what she says in these general meetings speak volumes to that viewpoint.
I've found Mrs. Hershman to be really helpful.