US World News residency rankings??

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

rachana

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2003
Messages
154
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Albany, NY
  1. Fellow [Any Field]
Someone told me that US World News and Report ranks residency programs like they do colleges and medical schools.... I googled it but couldn't find anything. Is this true and if so, how can I get to it? Thanks!

Rachana
 
I don't know about residency programs but I do know they rank hospitals. You might want to go directly to their website.
 
They told you wrong.

rachana said:
Someone told me that US World News and Report ranks residency programs like they do colleges and medical schools.... I googled it but couldn't find anything. Is this true and if so, how can I get to it? Thanks!

Rachana
 

Members do not see ads. Register today.

rachana said:
Someone told me that US World News and Report ranks residency programs like they do colleges and medical schools.... I googled it but couldn't find anything. Is this true and if so, how can I get to it? Thanks!

Rachana

As noted above, your source is incorrect. There is no formal residency ranking source - USNWR does rank hospitals by different specialties but these are pretty useless to you - the rankings are reflective of things like research funding and have little to do with quality of residency training, lifestyle, etc. Word of mouth is your best source.
 
Sometimes the specialty you're choosing will have rankings that come out each year. For instance, in ophtho I believe the rankings are reported in Ophthalmology Times and are broken down into best research, best clinical, and most resident-friendly. However, they only rank about 20 in each. HTH.
 
US News does kind of have rankings of specialties (IM, Peds, Family med) by school. They don't do it by hospital though. The rankings are about quality of training in the specific specialty in these institutions based on word of mouth by faculty at institutions across the US (i.e., which institutions do you feel deliver the best trained people in this (your) specialty).

It only kind of does because, e.g., they refer to "Harvard" for IM in the top 3 but don't differentiate between MGH/BWH/BIDMC. However, it does offer a good overall picture of how places are considered relative to one another.

Honestly, residency ranking isn't everything. You have to know what you want to do down the road (academic medicine, clinical medicine, etc). The "best" places (i.e., Harvard and others) put out EXCELLENT academicians but not necessarily the best practicing clinicians or the most clinically experienced. I'm not saying they aren't great and the residents aren't extremely well educated. It's a question of what you want.

So take it with a grain of salt, especially when you hear about things by word of mouth. Just because institution A seems like the best in one person's eyes doesn't mean it's the best for you.
 
Instead of reading ranking schemes that probably aren't that relevant for an applicant, try asking the PD at your home program, and faculty members whom you respect, what their top 20 programs are. Chances are, the same 10 programs will make everyone's list.
 
Hurricane said:
Instead of reading ranking schemes that probably aren't that relevant for an applicant, try asking the PD at your home program, and faculty members whom you respect, what their top 20 programs are. Chances are, the same 10 programs will make everyone's list.
This is solid advice.

Don't rely on rankings. Some of the best training programs might be at hospitals that aren't in the USNews & World Report's "Honor Roll" of hospitals.
 
Thanks for the advice, guys. Another question: is there any place where residency programs might publish average board scores/qualifications/requirements of their admitted residents? Or is the whole thing just a crapshoot? I mean, how do I know where I have a shot of getting in and where I have no chance?? thanks.
 
rachana said:
Thanks for the advice, guys. Another question: is there any place where residency programs might publish average board scores/qualifications/requirements of their admitted residents? Or is the whole thing just a crapshoot? I mean, how do I know where I have a shot of getting in and where I have no chance?? thanks.
If you don't already have one, I'd find an advisor within the department. My advisor looked at my application for five minutes, then correctly predicted where I would and wouldn't get interviews. She was right except for one program out of 29. Not bad, huh?
 
Top Bottom