For me, I'm not sure. I didn't go to college straight after HS and I kind of wish I did. I would have gotten some BS liberal arts degree 18 year old *****s love to get, and I did not realize I wanted to go into health at the time, so I would have spent a few years floundering away with that BS liberal arts degree, paying off loans working at McD's or something. On the other hand, now I would be getting a post-bac instead of toiling away at stuff I could have done years ago. On the OTHER hand, I have no idea what sort of loans my 18 year old self would have applied for that my 23-year-old self would never even consider. And, bonus, I've only got a year until I'm independent and can get better financial aid. Really looking forward to that.
I guess the only thing I can take from all this wondering is...don't wonder what you could have gone or beat yourself up for past mistakes, because it's too late now.
No matter what, you at least got into school straight away and will be an attending quicker than a non-trad. That's extra money in the bank, even if you spent extra money to get there.