Well, I guess I can help lol. I have interviewed at both WVSOM and COMP-NW and I was accepted at COMP-NW this year. Both schools are great and will get you where you want to be. However, if I had to pick between both schools I would attend COMP-NW over WVSOM.
WVSOM is a great school, they have fairly decent board pass rates when you consider that they accept many students with lower stats. WVSOM main selling point when I interviewed was that they created an excellent anatomy program that many new schools basically emulate. However, my train of thought is if new schools are basically copying what they created and improving upon it, then who cares. WVSOM is very cheap if you are an in-state student, OOS state is about 50k, so about the same as COMP-NW. WVSOM has state-of-the-art human sims which I thought were very cool because you can practice many scenarios without killing a live patient. As far as I know COMP-NW doesn't have human sims, if they do I don't remember seeing them on my tour. COMP-NW really pushes patient exposure and as a student you will have many simulated patient encounters in your first 2 years which I prefer over the human sims. WVSOM also has simulated patients encounters but not nearly as many COMP-NW. I prefer Lewisburg over Lebanon, it was just cooler and prettier town all around. Outside of the towns, COMP-NW is in a much better location. You're 1.5 hours or less from the ocean, mountains, or Portland. West Virgina is beautiful and has it's fair share of outdoor activities, but it just doesn't compare to Oregon. Both schools are located in relatively cheap areas to live. All of WVSOM 3rd year rotations are done in WV, COMP-NW's are mostly in Oregon with a few also near the Tacoma area. I believe both schools allow more flexibility in their 4 year rotations. Both schools will definitely provide exposure to rural medicine but COMP-NW has rotations in bigger cities as well.
gcoug: Thank you so much for your response. This is exactly what I was looking for and is very helpful comparing/contrasting the programs. I know that the tuition prices are comparable (as I am considered OOS for both institutions). I think you bring up a good point in reference to sim patients vs sim robots in the curriculum, and I will make sure to take that into consideration on interview day to squeeze some information out of the staff. I agree that both places are great for those who love to be outdoors, and it seems as if both are rooted in smaller communities as well. I cannot wait to 'feel' out Lebanon and the surrounding areas in my travels there. Thank you again so much for going into detail regarding both institutions. I still am a bit curious about COMP-NW's preparation for the boards as well as a few key parts of their curriculum. I hope to find out more next weekend, and will report back accordingly! Thanks again!