- Joined
- May 8, 2006
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 0
I was wondering what school is good. I'm thinking about staying in FL. What do you all think about Barry University?
~BaByGuRl~ said:I was wondering what school is good. I'm thinking about staying in FL. What do you all think about Barry University?
~BaByGuRl~ said:I was wondering what school is good. I'm thinking about staying in FL. What do you all think about Barry University?
whiskers said:My only advice, EVER....
Stick with schools who have medical school students in their basic science classes.
Haha, yeah like the plague.krabmas said:welcome back.
You've been missed.
capo said:Haha, yeah like the plague.
~BaByGuRl~ said:I was wondering what school is good. I'm thinking about staying in FL. What do you all think about Barry University?
ppormansdoormd said:best podiatry school? that's easy.
here is the ultimate list:
1.DMUCPMS
2.SCPM
3.TUSPM
4.AZPOD
5.OCPM
6.NYCPM
7.BUGMS
8.CSPM
enjoy!
ppormansdoormd said:best podiatry school? that's easy.
here is the ultimate list:
1.DMUCPMS
2.SCPM
3.TUSPM
4.AZPOD
5.OCPM
6.NYCPM
7.BUGMS
8.CSPM
enjoy!
gustydoc said:I don't think the purpose of this thread was to knock any particular schools and obviously people are going to have different opinions, whether they are biased or not. I agree that there is no accurate way to rank the schools that I have seen, but if you look at the list that ppormansdoormd posted I think it is not a bad list if you take certain factors into consideration such as:
-school facilities
-integrated curriculum (w/MD,DO)
-% PM&S 36 residency placement
-fourth year extern options (how many programs can you visit etc.)
-Board Scores (most important factor in my opinion and possibly the reason for the low CSPM rank)
With that being said I do believe that you can receive a good education at any of the podiatric medical schools if you are willing to work hard. Each school has its own strengths and weaknesses. As for babygurl's original question there is no definitive answer to what schools are the best, but I would certainly ask questions when visiting each school about board scores and residency placement. Personally I am glad to see that some pre-podiatry students want to know what schools will prepare them to be the best doctors possible and are not just choosing a school based on location or a little more scholarship money. Just my opinion though.
Whiskers since you're such an authority on the schools, where's Barry in this list? Did you 'forget' there's more than 7 schools? I mean, I guess, 7 is close enough to 8. Of course, this is just as close as your comments on the field are 'close enough' to the truth, as well. Ah hell, why be precise huh?whiskers said:My list
1. DMU
1.5 AZ
1.5 Temple
3. Scholl
Ether
5. NY Pod
6. Ohio
7. California
whiskers said:My list
1. DMU
1.5 AZ
1.5 Temple
3. Scholl
Ether
5. NY Pod
6. Ohio
7. California
krabmas said:besides leaving out Barry I agree with the list except fot temple I think it could go with the last 3. just because it is associated with a med school does not mean much since they do not take classes with the med students. same teachers is not the same thing. At NYCPM we have the same teachers as Mount Sinai School of Medicine, Columbia, New York College of Medicine ... but that does not mean that we get the same quality lectures as the med students.
dpmgrad said:Hmm. I am not sure if I would agree with you about Temple. You are correct in that we do not sit in the same class as the MD students at Temple because we are on different campuses and the basic science courses for MD students and DPM students are offered in different semesters. The course content for Physiology, Neuroscience, Pharmacology, Pathology, Physical Diagnosis are identical to the MD course and are taught by the same professors. Many of my classmates utilize the MD old exams to assist us in preparation for the exam since the exam content is same as the MD students. In fact, every year, Pathology course coordinator usually compare the overall average of the MD and DPM students in the Pathology course every year. There are one or two years where DPM students actually had a higher overall average than the MD students. The only basic science courses that has course content different from the MD school are Biochemistry, Anatomy, and Microbiology.
Physical Diagnosis course is identical to the MD school. Of course, TUSPM also tacks on several extra lectures for the Lower Extremity. Similar to the MD students, the TUSPM students have to go through a live simulated patient practical and go to Temple University Hospital to do x amount of H&Ps.
As for our clinical rotations, TUSPM students are expected to function like any other MD/DO students on that clinical rotation. We rotate along MD/DO students in facilities like Temple University Hospital, Graduate Hospital, University of Pennsylvania - Presbyterian Medical Center, etc..... In fact, TUSPM has started to implement "shelf exams" for several of the clinical rotaions to test the student's knowledge on that clinical rotation. This is model after shelf exams that MD/DO students take after their clinical rotations.
As for TUSPM students placement, TUSPM students continue to be placed into many of the top Podiatric Surgical residency program in the country, such as, Tucker (Northlake), West Penn, Seattle, etc... I think that it is ridiculous for you to say that TUSPM should not be in the top of the list of Podiatry schools because we do not sit in the same classes as Temple MD students (similar to NYCPM). Unlike NYCPM, TUSPM is very much integrated with the Temple MD program in terms of clinical training and basic science training since the course contents are identical to and are same quality as the MD school, even though, we don't sit in the same courses as the MD students. Just because MD faculty at NYCPM do not provide the same quality lectures to the NYCPM students as they do to the MD students, it does not mean that it will happen every where else. I am sure that at Scholl, the Scholl students get the same quality lectures as the MD students in courses that they do not sit in the same classroom as the MD students. I usually do not get involved with ranking of Podiatry schools since each students need to find the Podiatry school that will be the best fit for him or her. In my opinion, TUSPM is amongst the top Podiatry schools along with AZPOD, DMU, and Scholl.
Oh my... pass me the bottlekrabmas said:repeat - oops.
and I do not even have a gateway.
capo said:Oh my... pass me the bottle
capo said:Whiskers since you're such an authority on the schools, where's Barry in this list? Did you 'forget' there's more than 7 schools? I mean, I guess, 7 is close enough to 8. Of course, this is just as close as your comments on the field are 'close enough' to the truth, as well. Ah hell, why be precise huh?
How can you rank, when you don't even know how many schools of podiatry exist? And you were/are a pods student, am I correct sir? Where... on the moon?
whiskers said:The ether zone sometimes contains things (whole or fractured) and sometimes it contains a very empty vacuum.
This isn't a random thought... Instead it's a way to describe a condition .. or better yet, a weird state of affairs. I'm some how confident that the first four schools, ranked 1-3, will not be forgotten, but what about the remainder of the programs wondering in that empty podiatry pond? Maybe today we can see an answer instead of a question?
My personal advice, don't get lost in any "outer spaces."
In any event, thank-you for reminding me of the #8 that the ether zone forgot. But to be honest, tomorrow it could be one of the others floating somewhere.
IlizaRob said:Are you two classmates or something, you and Krabmas I mean. You seem to have a tea party going on in all the threads. Just curious.
No I don't! You just like me!krabmas said:He just likes me.
yup. I'm in raleigh, NC currently working at WakeMed.
capo said:No I don't! You just like me!
No, truth be told, you're marrying whiskers and you didn't want to tell us nor invite us.
Haha.... gotcha on that one didn't I, Krab?
krabmas said:I want to clarify that I never ranked NYCPM better than Temple. So in that respect I am uncertain why they are being compared here.
Maybe with these improvements Temple will be better but what I have heard from students that attend Temple pod they say that profs do not show up sometimes to class (unacceptable) due to traffic between the campuses. This is not an occasional occurance according to these students.
And I have met a few Temple grads in clinical settings and have not been impressed with them. I know all schools have their black sheep but is that all i have met so far.
I do not think that Temple is a bad school but I also do not think that it belongs in the top 4.
That is just my oppinion, but I chose my school based on location so what do I know.
dpmgrad said:Actually, you are the one who compared TUSPM to NYCPM in your original posting by stating that just because we have MD school faculty teaching our basic sciences courses and we are not physically in the same classroom as the MD students, it does not mean that the course would be of the same quality as the MD school course, as in the case at NYCPM. I was just merely pointing out to you that the content and quality of the TUSPM basic science courses taught by MD school faculty were at the same quality of the MD school course.
As for ranking TUSPM above NYCPM, I do believe that TUSPM is a better school than NYCPM. It is my opinion. Of course, you are entitled to your opinion in that TUSPM should not be ranked along with the other top three schools. As you said, most people would choose the school that would best fit them. For example, you chose your school based on location. I chose my school because it is still in the Northeast and many Podiatrists back home in New York City told me not to go to NYCPM.
As for problems at TUSPM, all podiatry schools have their share of problems. TUSPM has tons of them that need to be worked on. As you said, perhaps, if they correct some of these problems, the school might be even better. In regards to the professor being late and not showing up due to traffic issues, there will always be traffic issues since TUSPM is located in downtown Philadelphia and the medical school is located about 4 miles north of the downtown area. Perhaps, a solution would be to relocate TUSPM onto the Temple University Health Science Campus. Hopefully, the school is working on something to resolving this issue of professors not showing up. This rarely happened to me when I was a student. Of course, things do change over time. In agreement with you, it is not acceptable for a professor to not show up to class.
As for meeting some of the "not so impressive" Temple grads in the clinical settings, you are right in that every school have their blacksheep. I am not here to make excuses for the "not so impressive" Temple grads that you may have encountered. After looking at the last 5 years of residency placement, majority of the TUSPM students have been placed into good surgical programs in greater Philadelphia area, top Podiatric Surgical Residency programs in the US, or away from the Northeast. There are a few exceptions where some of the decent students are in programs like Morristown and Yale. Based on the list of residency placement, majority of the "bottom of the barrel" students usually end up programs in New Jersey or New York. Again, there are a few exceptions. The reason for this is that the state of Pennsylvania requires the student to be able to sit for and pass the PMLexis (NBPME Part III) to start any residency program in Pennsylvania. Many of the "bottom of the barrel" students could not sit for the PMLexis because they could not pass the Part 2 boards. Hence, those students would seek programs in NJ or NY, where students are not required to sit for the PMLexis (NJ) or not required sit for the PMLexis during the first year after graduation (NY). During some of the NYC Podiatry conferences, I have run into some of the TUSPM grads doing their residency training in NYC. One of those grads did not even pass Part 2 boards when this person began the training at one of the more popular 3 year surgical residency programs in NYC. My point is that you probably did run into several of the blacksheep of TUSPM during your clinical exposures. If you want to know what the quality of TUSPM students are like, I would recommending you checking out some of the decent surgical residency programs in the greater Philadelphia area or in the more popular or top surgical residency programs outside of the NY/NJ area.
krabmas said:just to clarify...
I have not met any temple grads in the NY area.
I met them in philly and DC. I have not visited one NY program except MSSM for free food.
I have no interest in staying in the NY NJ area.
dpmgrad said:I guess that you have made your point about the quality of TUSPM students. By the way, I may have run into you at one or two of the Podiatry conferences in NYC.
dpmgrad said:I guess that you have made your point about the quality of TUSPM students. By the way, I may have run into you at one or two of the Podiatry conferences in NYC.
krabmas said:do you know if you have?
dpmgrad said:I think so because I met your friend/classmate at the NY Podiatry Conference at Marriott Marquis. Your friend/classmate then introduced you to me at the MSSM conference. I realized who you were after you indicated what programs you were externing at on SDN.
krabmas said:oh -crap. I know who you are too.
OK so you are the exception from your school.
dpmgrad said:I think that some of the posters here on SDN may get jealous since I have met you in person. By the way, I am joining a group in Philadelphia when I get done with my residency at the end of this month. If you are ever in the Philly area, feel free to drop by and say hi.
copen said:Is OCPM that bad of a school? Does anyone have experience there? They're hooked up with Case Western Reserve... I thought that was a good thing.