When I interviewed there I loved the whole feel of the school, the faculty and students were really friendly and down to earth, I loved the location (small and cozy but close to DC) and my boyfriend of 3 and 1/2 years is living and working up there so that, of course, played a role. 🙂
Shenandoah also emphasized community service as part of their curriculum which I thought was nice. Overall, I just have a good feeling about it. 🙂
Good luck making your decisions and Merry Christmas!