I was told on more than one occasion on my trail, that the ACGME is trying to make a significant proportion of the IM training on an outpatient basis (something like 60-40 outpatient:inpatient ratio). I have a feeling that may actually be one of the important components of the discussion.
I also find it interesting how most of the people in favor of working hard - including the 12 hours per day - (on this thread) - are med students.
Don't get me wrong, I'd love it if residency was 9 hours a day x 5 days a week, but that will never happen.
I also don't think that 7-7 is the best time for the 12's. I'd rather see 5-5 or 6-6...that way when you get home, you still have some time with the family in the evening (on your day shifts), or in the morning (on your night shifts). Doing 7-7's just takes away everything, and is not the ideal place to put that time marker.
I do understand that 6 12's might result in slightly less "free time". That being said, it's better for us physically, it's safer for us and the patients, and a reasonable work schedule might help entice more people into a profession most people see as past its prime.
The difficulty of hand-offs is a lame excuse, IMO. Yes, we made it through undergrad with 3.8 GPA's, rocked the MCAT, made it through medical school, and the boards...but we can't handle a patient hand-off. Riiight.
Having worked in an ER, I also think that saying that ER docs have less responsibility and thus, have an easier time doing hand-offs is also a poor excuse. ER docs will often do a hand-off on a patient with no clear diagnosis, sometimes in rather serious condition. Imagine walking into your shift and being handed a patient with no diagnosis, no labs back, no imaging back, and only a weak EMT history and another guy's physical exam to go on. Happens all the time, and it's not a big deal. I can't imagine it'd be that much worse for anyone else, training or not.
I'm actually glad the 5 hour nap is dead. 5 hours does nothing for me.
I should add that I am rather partial to my sleep. I have a PSVT that gives me much more trouble when I don't get much sleep (despite an ablation at one of the best centers in the country...it's just in a terrible place (right at the superior aspect of the coronary sinus os), unless I want a pacemaker, which I don't). So, I'd rather work sane hours and be able to sleep. I can make do otherwise, but it's not my favorite thing to do. Also, I'm old and the joints and stamina are not quite what they were when I was 24 and running around stages rocking out at all hours of the night and day.
I love IM, but one of the main things pushing me away from choosing it is the arduous (for me, at least) schedule. EM and FP residents and attendings (amongst others) have a much more humane schedule...we'll have to see who wins out over the next couple of years...